An after-school storytelling project in a diverse, but divided, city school…
Who's Next?
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
WHO'S NEXT? examines how the lives of Muslim-Americans have been affected in the aftermath of the September 11th terrorist attacks. It focuses on six Muslim families — citizens and long-time legal residents — from diverse countries and widely different circumstances. In one way or another all of them have been targeted by federal agencies, hate groups, and even former friends solely on the basis of their religious beliefs.
Family separations, threats of deportation, repeated airport detentions, unexplained travel restrictions, have become part of the daily lives of thousands of Muslims who are innocent of any crimes or even suspicious behavior. If one group can be singled out because of their religious beliefs then who's next?
The film encourages us all to choose knowledge over ignorance, take action to prevent hate speech, and to welcome strangers into our lives so that the challenges of marginalized communities can be effectively addressed.
'Who's Next? is a moving portrayal of the unrelenting assault on the lives and livelihoods of Muslims in post-9/11 America. The film provides educators with a powerful tool for helping students to challenge manufactured narratives of an Islamic threat and to contemplate constructive ways of building bridges across racial and religious difference.' Todd Green, Associate Professor of Religion, Luther College, Author, The Fear of Islam: An Introduction to Islamophobia in the West
'An important and compelling addition to the resources available that highlight the experiences of Muslims in the US in the post 9/11 era. In following a selection of families, it allows viewers into the lives of regular people who have been impacted by Islamophobia and its structural manifestations. With only half of Americans knowing a Muslim personally, Who's Next? provides a window into the lives of our fellow Americans who happen to be Muslim as well as of those who have sought refuge here.' Meira Neggaz, Executive Director, Institute for Social Policy and Understanding
'The best and most profound movie I've seen recently...As unsettling as it is important. It is an extremely well-made documentary, uncluttered, never resorting to inflated dramatics. The drama is in the stories of the families. Who's Next? is the type of artistic expression essential to those who cherish the concept of democracy.' David Rothenberg, host, Any Saturday, WBAI
'Poignant...Who's Next explores the current challenges faced by Muslims in the United States - along with their resilient efforts to raise and educate their children and contribute to a better society.' The Rev. Dr. Chloe Breyer, Executive Director, Interfaith Center of New York
'This important film should be part of every educational platform. It reminds us that we all have the capacity to raise up the other with dignity and respect.' Rabbi Laurie Phillips, Beineinu NYC
'An inspiring documentary, showing the resilience of Muslims in America and a call to action for all who care about preserving human rights and civil rights in our country.' Dr. Sarah Sayeed, Chair and Executive Director, Civic Engagement Commission of NYC
'With deep compassion and sharp insight, Cooperstein Charney gives us a painful view of what it is like to be Muslim in America today.' Roberta Brandes Gratz, Journalist, Author, We're Still Here Ya Bastards: How the People of New Orleans Rebuilt Their City
'This work brings alive the heroism and struggles of the Muslim community in today's world. It gives us all hope in telling the story of leaders stepping up for their families, communities and society as a whole as they face the challenges and realities of hate and Islamophobia.' Rabbi Bob Kaplan, Director, Center for Community Leadership, Jewish Community Relations Council of New York (JCRC-NY)
'An urgent, inspiring message with beautiful and moving portraits of American Muslims and non-Muslims living with mutual respect and care in a politically divisive age. Who's Next? shows the reality of Islamophobia in the US, but brings hope and humor as well. An ideal film for family and classroom viewing during the Trump presidency and for many years to come.' Emilio Spadola, Associate Professor of Anthropology, Director of Middle East and Islamic Studies, Colgate University
Citation
Main credits
Charney, Nancy Cooperstein (film director)
Charney, Nancy Cooperstein (film producer)
Geissbuhler, Luke (film producer)
Geissbuhler, Luke (director of photography)
Keuper, Jay (film producer)
Keuper, Jay (editor of moving image work)
Other credits
Director of photography, Luke Geissbühler; editor, Jay Keuper; composers, Peter Golub, Omar Fadel.
Distributor subjects
American Democracy; American Studies; Anthropology; Civil Rights; Family Studies; Global Issues; Hate Speech; History; Human Rights; Immigration; Islamic Studies; Law; Middle Eastern Studies; Migration and Refugees; Multicultural Studies; Political Science; Psychology; Race and Racism; Religion; Social Justice; SociologyKeywords
[00:00:03.02]
[mournful instrumental music]
[00:01:22.03]
- [Female Reporter] The
president, keeping his word
[00:01:23.08]
on one of his campaign promises
[00:01:25.09]
to ban Muslims from immigrating
to the United States.
[00:01:28.07]
- Tonight, a federal judge
just a short time ago
[00:01:31.02]
has blocked President
Trump's new travel ban
[00:01:33.06]
before it could go into effect.
[00:01:35.07]
This is now the second major defeat
[00:01:37.01]
for the Trump White House
on their proposed bans.
[00:01:40.01]
The president retweeted videos
[00:01:42.05]
that are inflammatory
anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant.
[00:01:47.08]
- A lot of us here are
using either pig's blood
[00:01:52.00]
or bacon grease on our bullets,
packing it in the middle,
[00:01:57.02]
so that when you shoot a Muslim
they go straight to hell.
[00:02:00.04]
The next step in jihad does not involve
[00:02:03.04]
random, sporadic attacks.
[00:02:04.09]
They start killin' people.
[00:02:06.06]
They start slaughterin' people wholesale.
[00:02:08.07]
Do you really expect me to stand here
[00:02:10.02]
and wait till we get to that point?
[00:02:12.04]
I'm not going to wait
till we get to that point.
[00:02:15.08]
I'm gonna start doing
something about it now.
[00:02:17.09]
[gunshots]
[00:02:21.01]
- If it was up to me, have
to completely wipe out ISIS
[00:02:24.06]
with the civilians and the children,
[00:02:26.03]
'cause those baby ISIS children are gonna
[00:02:28.00]
be even more vicious than their fathers.
[00:02:32.07]
[sorrowful violin music]
[00:03:13.04]
- My full name is Ali Khalaf Mashhour.
[00:03:17.06]
I was born in 1985 in Goshen, Indiana.
[00:03:22.06]
My father is Palestinian,
from the West Bank,
[00:03:26.09]
on the outskirts of Jerusalem.
[00:03:29.05]
My mother is born and
raised in Goshen, Indiana.
[00:03:34.07]
They meet up and they get married.
[00:03:37.00]
My mother actually converted to Islam
[00:03:39.07]
maybe five or six years
after they got married,
[00:03:42.08]
and here I come along.
[00:03:48.08]
At the age of five or six I was sent
[00:03:51.08]
to Palestine to learn Arabic.
[00:03:54.07]
Nobody for an entire year
spoke any English to me.
[00:03:58.08]
So when I came back I
had to relearn English
[00:04:02.07]
which makes English my
first and third language.
[00:04:06.05]
I would go back and forth to Palestine
[00:04:09.04]
throughout those years,
spend my summer breaks there.
[00:04:13.05]
But the bulk of my time was spent
[00:04:15.09]
as your average boy in the Midwest.
[00:04:22.07]
When I was a kid growing up,
[00:04:24.04]
I felt something pulling
me to New York City.
[00:04:27.09]
I don't know why.
[00:04:29.01]
And I remember when 9/11
happened, I was very upset.
[00:04:34.00]
The way we were seeing it on the news,
[00:04:36.02]
it looked like the whole city was on fire,
[00:04:38.02]
and I thought to myself, "They
went and ruined the city."
[00:04:43.02]
But I've always been a drifter.
[00:04:45.09]
I've always been somebody that, you know,
[00:04:48.08]
goes where the wind takes me.
[00:04:50.08]
And so I came to New York.
[00:04:55.04]
[gentle orchestral music]
[00:05:09.02]
[beeping]
[00:05:11.03]
- [Ali] Good morning.
[00:05:12.05]
[speaking in Arabic dialect]
[00:05:13.04]
- [Mohammed] How are you?
[00:05:14.02]
[speaking in Arabic dialect]
[00:05:15.00]
So glad to see you.
[00:05:16.01]
Let me ask you, originally
you are from Indiana.
[00:05:18.07]
Is that what I'm hearing?
[00:05:19.05]
- [Ali] I was born in Indiana, yeah.
[00:05:21.02]
- Indiana.
[00:05:23.02]
So from Indiana, you came to,
I guess, New York, like when?
[00:05:27.03]
- [Ali] 2006.
[00:05:29.05]
- And you got married in...?
[00:05:32.06]
- [Ali] I got married in
2010 in Trinidad and Tobago.
[00:05:36.07]
- [Mohammad] I gotcha, three, married.
[00:05:40.05]
Any kids yet?
[00:05:41.05]
- Yeah, two kids.
[00:05:43.02]
- Two kids.
[00:05:44.04]
Now talk to me about your case.
[00:05:46.03]
When did you apply?
[00:05:47.02]
And all this stuff happened?
[00:05:48.07]
- Well, I don't know.
[00:05:51.06]
I'm extremely naive on these issues.
[00:05:54.06]
You know, before I was, like, religious--
[00:05:57.09]
before I was Muslim actually,
[00:05:59.05]
because I actually officially
accepted Islam when I was 19.
[00:06:04.02]
Before that, I didn't have any problems
[00:06:06.08]
with the government at all.
[00:06:08.07]
But after I, you know, accepted Islam
[00:06:13.07]
and went to Hajj, which was in Palestine,
[00:06:16.02]
that was the last time I've
ever been to Palestine.
[00:06:19.08]
And after that time,
[00:06:24.00]
everything just started to get really bad.
[00:06:26.06]
- Gotcha.
[00:06:27.05]
[airplane engines roaring]
[00:06:31.03]
- My travel history has
always been terrible.
[00:06:35.03]
I remember as a child going
back and forth to Palestine
[00:06:39.01]
and being subjected to
all kinds of searches
[00:06:42.06]
and things because of
my Palestinian origins.
[00:06:46.05]
I was always subjected to
special scrutiny in airports,
[00:06:52.03]
and it has only gotten worse.
[00:06:54.05]
When I come to the ticket counter,
[00:06:56.02]
I tell them "Yeah, you might want to get
[00:06:58.05]
"another agent out here, because
this is gonna take awhile,"
[00:07:01.08]
because they cannot board me
[00:07:04.05]
without calling National Security
[00:07:06.05]
and asking permission to board me.
[00:07:08.09]
And it's gotten to the point
[00:07:10.00]
where if I want to rush through,
[00:07:11.02]
I don't carry luggage, I don't.
[00:07:13.00]
Usually I'll just take like a
book bag and a few essentials,
[00:07:17.00]
just so I can get through easy.
[00:07:19.00]
The biggest problem is when I'm coming
[00:07:20.07]
back into the country.
[00:07:22.02]
They'll search me with
everybody at the TSA
[00:07:24.08]
and then they'll search me again
[00:07:26.04]
as I go into the plane.
[00:07:28.02]
And sometimes they'll
search me a third time.
[00:07:30.05]
They'll wait till I'm seated in the plane
[00:07:33.07]
and then come just as the
plane is gonna pull off,
[00:07:36.05]
pull me out of the plane,
take me back to the TSA place,
[00:07:41.00]
search me again and then
if I miss my flight,
[00:07:44.05]
I miss my flight.
[00:07:45.04]
I have to wait for another one.
[00:07:46.08]
They've done that one before, too.
[00:07:48.08]
And, you know, trying to get
answers from these people
[00:07:51.04]
is like trying to talk
to a door, you know.
[00:07:53.03]
Is there anything wrong?
[00:07:54.02]
"No, no."
[00:07:55.03]
They tell me, "Oh, Mr. Mashhour,
[00:07:57.03]
"you have been randomly chosen for",
[00:08:00.01]
yeah, yeah, yeah, I know,
I know, it's very random.
[00:08:04.06]
Every time I come up
they say, "Mr. Mashhour,"
[00:08:07.02]
I say, "Wait, let me guess.
[00:08:09.07]
"I've been randomly selected."
[00:08:12.08]
They say, "Yeah, how did you know?
[00:08:14.04]
"You've done this before?"
[00:08:15.05]
I say, "Only about seven
million times I've done this."
[00:08:18.06]
You know, it's embarrassing,
it's humiliating.
[00:08:23.05]
- My son, whenever he's traveling,
[00:08:25.08]
the Homeland Security
personnel come right up to him
[00:08:29.02]
and they start asking questions.
[00:08:31.02]
- When I come back,
sometimes they'll have FBI
[00:08:33.08]
waiting for me at the plane gate.
[00:08:35.08]
But they always will have
two officers, at least,
[00:08:40.06]
escort me from the plane door to the...
[00:08:46.00]
whatever that room is.
[00:08:48.07]
I've also had them
approach me in the street.
[00:08:52.02]
Ah, this is about faulty intelligence,
[00:08:55.02]
incompetent people that are
just looking for a paycheck.
[00:08:59.06]
And so if you shake hands
with someone who remotely,
[00:09:03.05]
in some way, said some thing
or didn't say something,
[00:09:08.03]
you have now been incriminated by that.
[00:09:10.09]
One of the things that upsets me,
[00:09:12.04]
assign one agent to my case all the time.
[00:09:15.03]
Let me deal with him only.
[00:09:17.05]
They don't do that.
[00:09:18.07]
Every time it's like jack-in-the-box,
[00:09:20.06]
I don't know who's gonna, you know,
[00:09:22.00]
I don't know who's gonna show up.
[00:09:23.08]
Sometimes the FBI,
sometimes Homeland Security,
[00:09:26.08]
sometimes it's, you know,
[00:09:28.05]
somebody from the Department of Defense.
[00:09:31.07]
But unfortunately, it's
just mindless antagonizing.
[00:09:39.08]
I am totally head-over-heals
in love with my wife.
[00:09:44.01]
We got married in 2010.
[00:09:49.00]
We have two children.
[00:09:52.04]
She's a wonderful mother.
[00:09:55.06]
Her father was an imam in Trinidad,
[00:09:59.01]
but when she married me is
when she got more serious
[00:10:02.01]
about practicing Islam.
[00:10:03.09]
Before that she practiced recreationally,
[00:10:08.02]
perhaps we could say, yeah.
[00:10:13.03]
We registered the marriage immediately
[00:10:15.09]
with the government of Trinidad and Tobago
[00:10:17.08]
and with the government in America.
[00:10:19.09]
We applied for a visa, a tourist visa
[00:10:24.03]
because I wanted to take her immediately,
[00:10:26.08]
in 2011, in about January,
to meet my parents.
[00:10:30.06]
That was rejected.
[00:10:32.03]
She was turned down a visa.
[00:10:34.02]
So we decided, well let's go
in for the residency, you know.
[00:10:39.04]
So we applied for that
[00:10:40.05]
and it took them four years to respond.
[00:10:43.05]
A very monotonous four years.
[00:10:46.04]
"Bring this paper."
[00:10:47.07]
"Oh, this expired. You
need to get another one."
[00:10:50.09]
"Get this physical, get that,"
[00:10:52.06]
and thousands and thousands of dollars.
[00:10:54.08]
Finally after four years
we were served papers
[00:10:58.04]
that she has been permanently banned
[00:11:01.04]
from entering the country,
[00:11:03.08]
and she can never even
reapply for residency again.
[00:11:09.01]
And they gave it to me in writing.
[00:11:12.04]
"Possible or suspected of having links
[00:11:15.07]
"with terrorist organizations
or inciting terrorism."
[00:11:20.01]
So I have this job here in
New York, and they're there.
[00:11:24.00]
So here we are, a bit of a pickle.
[00:11:27.06]
A kosher pickle, a halal pickle, right?
[00:11:31.06]
So this is the refusal.
[00:11:36.06]
So now I have no idea what is
happening with my life now.
[00:11:41.05]
You understand what I'm saying?
[00:11:42.07]
So I'm here working in the mosque.
[00:11:46.02]
- [Mohammad] Oh my god.
[00:11:47.00]
- But every two to three months
[00:11:48.07]
I can go down there for two weeks.
[00:11:50.02]
- And then you have to come back.
[00:11:51.05]
- And come back.
[00:11:52.04]
- Oh man, and that is a
financial burden itself.
[00:11:55.09]
I think we will get to the bottom of it.
[00:11:57.05]
At least we can find out,
[00:11:59.06]
and then address it accordingly.
[00:12:03.00]
- All I'm looking for, really,
[00:12:06.02]
is what's their problem with me,
[00:12:08.07]
so that I can understand, like,
[00:12:10.05]
what am I doing or not doing.
[00:12:12.07]
What's going on with my wife?
[00:12:14.04]
I'm the American citizen
paying taxes all these years
[00:12:17.03]
and I get, you know,
ostracized from my own country.
[00:12:23.09]
[somber instrumental music]
[00:12:42.05]
- Being a Muslim has made me
scared to be in my own country.
[00:12:51.06]
I feel scared to take the subway.
[00:12:56.06]
I feel scared getting gas.
[00:13:00.05]
I am looking around in
my rear view mirrors
[00:13:05.06]
to make sure that no one
is approaching the car.
[00:13:09.04]
I also feel
[00:13:12.06]
that I take my fear out on my kids.
[00:13:18.06]
Perhaps I'm too hard with
them when we're out in public.
[00:13:23.00]
If they do something
any normal kid would do,
[00:13:26.02]
I feel like this is what
people will think of us.
[00:13:33.04]
And it will unfortunately,
for certain people,
[00:13:38.07]
perpetuate this negative stereotype.
[00:13:43.00]
I sort of feel like every day I go out
[00:13:47.08]
I'm on a PR campaign.
[00:13:50.03]
Every trip to the grocery
store, when I go to the DMV.
[00:13:57.03]
And I think naturally I am a
cheery, happy, positive person,
[00:14:04.07]
but I feel like I now
have a specific mission
[00:14:09.07]
of letting people know
that there are Muslims
[00:14:12.03]
in our community, and we're normal.
[00:14:16.00]
[somber instrumental music]
[00:14:27.04]
[percussive music]
[00:14:32.08]
I met my husband in Mauritania
[00:14:36.00]
in the village where he grew up.
[00:14:39.02]
I was a Peace Corp
volunteer for agriculture.
[00:14:43.09]
I remember seeing him and
thinking, "Wow," you know?
[00:14:48.00]
The attraction was mutual,
and we talked a lot.
[00:14:52.04]
We met up on the dunes behind the village
[00:14:56.03]
and fell in love.
[00:14:59.05]
When Cheikh Ahmed came to the U.S.,
[00:15:01.07]
my dad thought he was a terrorist.
[00:15:03.09]
He says, "You don't know him!"
[00:15:05.01]
And I said, "But, yes, I do."
[00:15:07.09]
But he didn't-- but my dad was just being,
[00:15:10.09]
you know, a good dad.
[00:15:15.00]
When we realized that we
wanted to stay together,
[00:15:17.03]
he said, "I would like you to convert.
[00:15:19.01]
"And I won't get married to you
[00:15:24.03]
"unless you convert."
[00:15:28.01]
At that point I didn't have
a particular spiritual path.
[00:15:32.01]
I was brought up Catholic,
baptized, confirmed.
[00:15:36.05]
But there were aspects
about Islam that I loved.
[00:15:42.07]
[chanting in Arabic dialect]
[00:15:46.02]
I remember praying when I was
[00:15:47.03]
a volunteer with my host family.
[00:15:49.04]
I remember praying and
feeling so much at peace.
[00:15:52.08]
For the first 10 years of our marriage
[00:15:56.04]
I didn't cover my head, I
didn't have a head scarf.
[00:16:00.05]
And I don't think I took
my commitment seriously.
[00:16:09.00]
But as the boys got older, I figured
[00:16:12.05]
if I'm going to say that I'm Muslim,
[00:16:15.06]
I need to, you know,
start making that real.
[00:16:19.00]
That was sort of probably
when I first became--
[00:16:22.00]
when I started practicing
walking the walk,
[00:16:24.06]
walking the talk.
[00:16:27.02]
- In several U.S. cities,
investigations are underway
[00:16:30.02]
into possible hate crimes against Muslims.
[00:16:32.05]
- [Reporter 1] In Minneapolis
police are investigating
[00:16:34.03]
the recent shooting of two Muslim men
[00:16:36.02]
as a possible hate crime.
[00:16:38.01]
- [Reporter 2] Tampa fire
investigators are saying
[00:16:39.07]
arson is to blame for a fire
[00:16:41.06]
that started inside a local
mosque earlier this month.
[00:16:45.08]
- In Mauritania I did not
grow up as a minority.
[00:16:52.09]
So I didn't have to
grow up being looked at
[00:16:55.00]
in a way that is
different or not pleasing.
[00:17:01.03]
Here, I'm not targeted unless I speak,
[00:17:04.08]
because I call my accent
[00:17:09.01]
my turban or my hijab.
[00:17:12.00]
- [Reporter] Surveillance
video shows a suspect
[00:17:14.01]
punching, kicking and stomping
[00:17:16.01]
on a Muslim teenager
in Brooklyn, New York.
[00:17:18.09]
The beating took place outside a mosque
[00:17:20.09]
during a midnight prayer service.
[00:17:22.06]
The mosque is urging police
[00:17:23.08]
to investigate the attack as a hate crime.
[00:17:29.09]
- I am the executive director
[00:17:32.04]
of the Islamic Leadership
Council of New York.
[00:17:36.08]
We represent the Muslim community
[00:17:39.08]
and have access to all of
the pain that it feels.
[00:17:43.08]
- [Reporter] A place of
worship now a murder scene.
[00:17:46.07]
Residents of Queens in New York gathered
[00:17:49.00]
at the mosque where just hours earlier
[00:17:50.09]
an imam and his assistant were shot dead.
[00:17:53.07]
Members of the American
Muslim community...
[00:17:56.05]
- Based on the work I do,
[00:17:58.03]
I know some communities are hit hard.
[00:18:01.00]
They are negatively impacted in a way
[00:18:03.03]
that is a lot more remarkable
than the way we are impacted.
[00:18:07.07]
[crowd cheering and yelling]
[00:18:09.03]
The contributions from
non-Muslim Americans
[00:18:14.01]
is perhaps what would help more than
[00:18:16.08]
what the Muslims themselves will do.
[00:18:19.03]
[Crowd] This is what democracy looks like!
[00:18:22.01]
- [Cheikh] Because of the fear of this
[00:18:23.06]
spilling out to other communities,
[00:18:26.00]
the moment one community is targeted
[00:18:28.05]
and cornered and vilified,
[00:18:32.05]
other communities now
have this lack of immunity
[00:18:35.03]
from this kind of problem.
[00:18:38.02]
So there is a lot of support
from the Jewish community,
[00:18:41.07]
from all minorities, and from Americans--
[00:18:46.02]
white Americans who don't accept
[00:18:48.07]
that very extreme right side.
[00:18:51.06]
So we're not alone in this.
[00:18:54.04]
- [Crowd] No hate, no fear,
refugees are welcome here!
[00:18:58.06]
No hate, no fear...
[00:19:02.04]
- The boys have never come home and said
[00:19:06.03]
that someone said something to them.
[00:19:08.04]
So for that I'm grateful.
[00:19:11.03]
I hope that they would tell
me if something did happen.
[00:19:15.08]
At our local mosque, I was working
[00:19:19.07]
with a group of teenage girls.
[00:19:24.00]
They are in public schools
wearing a head scarf.
[00:19:28.02]
They are called terrorists.
[00:19:30.09]
They are called ISIS.
[00:19:33.02]
They don't want to tell their parents.
[00:19:35.01]
They want to take care of it
[00:19:36.08]
but they don't want to draw attention.
[00:19:40.09]
I think certain parts of
the Muslim community--
[00:19:43.05]
probably the older generation,
[00:19:45.03]
probably the generation
that came here to the U.S.
[00:19:48.04]
20, 30 years ago-- still feel,
[00:19:52.08]
"Let's be quiet and it'll
all roll over," you know.
[00:19:58.01]
"Let me continue to work
hard and accumulate wealth
[00:20:01.05]
"and that will protect me."
[00:20:04.00]
You know, there's a certain
part of the Muslim community
[00:20:07.01]
that is still racist, homophobic.
[00:20:11.00]
We don't want to recognize
[00:20:12.09]
that we are prejudiced as well as victims.
[00:20:20.06]
[speaking in Arabic dialect]
[00:20:28.09]
- I wasn't Muslim at
9/11, but other Muslims
[00:20:33.09]
say that what they did was not something
[00:20:37.04]
that any Muslim would ever do.
[00:20:39.05]
[chanting in Arabic dialect]
[00:20:45.05]
If you identify yourself as a Muslim,
[00:20:47.04]
I can't come and tell you,
"No, you're not Muslim."
[00:20:50.07]
I don't have that right.
[00:20:53.05]
But I can see your actions
and hear your words
[00:20:57.09]
and say, "That's not
what a Muslim would do,
[00:21:00.02]
"that's not what a Muslim would say."
[00:21:02.03]
So within the Muslim community,
we have to acknowledge
[00:21:06.08]
that there's the whole spectrum of people
[00:21:09.09]
who will identify themselves as Muslim
[00:21:13.02]
but their actions are not consistent.
[00:21:18.01]
These terrorists did this horrible thing
[00:21:21.05]
that tarnishes me.
[00:21:25.07]
- When the World Trade
Center came tumbling down
[00:21:29.03]
and I watched in Jersey City, New Jersey
[00:21:32.04]
where thousands and thousands
of people were cheering.
[00:21:36.09]
I have a window in my apartment
[00:21:39.02]
that specifically was aimed
at the World Trade Center
[00:21:41.07]
because of the beauty of the
whole downtown Manhattan.
[00:21:44.09]
And I watched as people jumped.
[00:21:47.06]
- Politicians use 9/11 as a rallying cry
[00:21:53.02]
for everyone who's Islamophobic, bigoted,
[00:21:56.07]
racist, they're gonna use that,
just the way that they use--
[00:22:01.01]
You know, if an undocumented immigrant
[00:22:05.03]
kills or robs a store, you know,
[00:22:10.02]
there's this rallying cry
that we have to sort of
[00:22:12.04]
keep all of these folks
out of this country.
[00:22:16.03]
You know, your average American,
[00:22:18.00]
that's the seed that's
planted in their brain.
[00:22:20.06]
And there's nothing else
[00:22:21.09]
that is offering another powerful image.
[00:22:25.03]
Nothing.
[00:22:26.06]
- OK, we have a problem in this country.
[00:22:29.05]
It's called Muslims.
[00:22:31.00]
We know our current president is one.
[00:22:33.08]
We have training camps growing
[00:22:36.08]
where they want to kill us.
[00:22:38.08]
That's my question, when
can we get rid of them?
[00:22:41.05]
- We're gonna be looking at
a lot of different things
[00:22:43.01]
and you know, a lot of
people are saying that...
[00:22:45.03]
- To me, Trump is a temporary thing.
[00:22:48.00]
Yes, there will be big damage
[00:22:50.04]
to specifically the Muslim
community, I would say,
[00:22:54.02]
more than any other community.
[00:22:56.06]
And maybe you can say
the Latino community.
[00:23:02.02]
But he's a phenomena that will disappear.
[00:23:05.09]
Trump himself doesn't have the depth
[00:23:09.00]
to set up now, stage for 20 years to come
[00:23:13.07]
or 30 years to come of Trumpism.
[00:23:18.00]
No.
[00:23:21.03]
He's in violation of all of the values
[00:23:23.07]
based on which the country is built.
[00:23:28.04]
I would say that he would
have been more dangerous
[00:23:31.01]
if he tried to do all of
what he said secretly.
[00:23:37.06]
Nobody knows about it.
[00:23:39.05]
That would be dangerous.
[00:23:41.03]
But something in the open like he does,
[00:23:44.07]
it becomes some bubbles and they will--
[00:23:48.02]
it will be taken care of.
[00:23:49.09]
- God bless you, thank you.
[00:23:51.06]
Thank you very much.
[00:23:52.06]
[crowd applauding and clapping]
[00:23:58.03]
- Cheikh Ahmed's family
has extended themselves
[00:24:02.04]
and I feel so much love
and warmth from them.
[00:24:06.09]
And I think it's been
harder for my family.
[00:24:11.00]
I remember my older brother saying,
[00:24:14.01]
"If I can't have a beer with him,
[00:24:17.02]
"I can't trust him",
[00:24:20.05]
or something like that.
[00:24:24.06]
I remember we were up in
Maine for a family reunion,
[00:24:28.06]
and I was aware of how hard it might be
[00:24:31.09]
for them to see their daughter
wearing the head scarf.
[00:24:35.00]
Normally when we would go to visit,
[00:24:36.06]
if I was wearing the
head scarf in the car,
[00:24:39.02]
you know, as soon as I
was getting into the house
[00:24:42.02]
I would take it off.
[00:24:44.08]
So we were all going out to breakfast
[00:24:47.07]
and the question for myself was,
[00:24:49.05]
was I gonna wear a hijab
to this little diner
[00:24:52.09]
up in Portland, Maine?
[00:24:55.02]
And I felt like in order for me
[00:24:57.07]
to feel consistent with myself,
[00:25:00.06]
this is now part of me.
[00:25:04.03]
But I also realized that my boys needed
[00:25:08.03]
to see their mom be consistent.
[00:25:12.05]
I didn't want to have them question,
[00:25:14.04]
"Well, why is Mom doing it at home?"
[00:25:16.09]
You know, I saw it as a
time for me to fully embrace
[00:25:19.07]
this new part of me.
[00:25:21.09]
I think it went over fine.
[00:25:23.05]
I think that-- we have
this now family picture
[00:25:27.01]
of all of us, and I'm in the hijab,
[00:25:29.00]
and they have it in their different homes.
[00:25:32.09]
So I do believe people can change,
[00:25:35.07]
but it doesn't happen
easily or by accident.
[00:25:45.06]
[singing in Arabic dialect]
[00:26:03.07]
- Historically, an imam is
someone who leads the prayer.
[00:26:08.04]
And the criteria for leading prayer
[00:26:11.03]
is that a person be most well-versed
[00:26:13.06]
and well-recited in the Quran.
[00:26:15.09]
Because that's really
what all the prayer is,
[00:26:18.06]
it's a build-up to the
recitation of God's words
[00:26:23.04]
and then a build-up to asking of God.
[00:26:27.00]
That's really what the
prayer revolves around.
[00:26:30.07]
[Ali speaking in Arabic dialect]
[00:26:38.08]
And the other duties that
I do would be counseling,
[00:26:44.03]
performing marriages, reviewing
applications for charity
[00:26:49.05]
and so forth, so those are
more or less my duties.
[00:26:57.08]
But because the mosque is no longer
[00:27:01.04]
just the place where we go to pray,
[00:27:03.06]
I have a lot of other
duties that I perform.
[00:27:08.06]
People come through the
mosque at 96th Street
[00:27:11.04]
on average at least a
thousand people a day.
[00:27:14.02]
Fridays is gonna be between
3,000 and 3,500 people.
[00:27:20.09]
For the major holidays like Eid,
[00:27:23.09]
that'll usually be anywhere
from 12,000 to 14,000 people.
[00:27:29.04]
At least half of those numbers
[00:27:31.03]
I will come into some kind
of personal contact with,
[00:27:36.03]
whether it be counseling
[00:27:38.04]
or whether it be teaching,
lecturing, et cetera.
[00:27:43.09]
[instrumental oud music]
[00:28:01.09]
[Ali chanting in Arabic dialect]
[00:28:08.05]
In this country, I have, I would say,
[00:28:11.07]
one of the most prestigious
jobs or positions
[00:28:15.09]
of imam in the country, in the West.
[00:28:23.07]
So if I am labeled really absolutely
[00:28:27.03]
a threat to national security,
[00:28:29.09]
having me in a position that I am in
[00:28:31.06]
is a very serious liability, clearly.
[00:28:35.07]
It would just be silly.
[00:28:36.08]
I have a lot of influence
over a lot of people.
[00:29:00.05]
- Alright, well this
basically is where we're at
[00:29:03.02]
in the immigration process.
[00:29:06.03]
She was refused for a
non-immigrant visa in 2011.
[00:29:13.00]
Then we applied for the immigration visa
[00:29:17.01]
and we got this response in 2015.
[00:29:22.05]
- This should have been
addressed right away.
[00:29:24.04]
"Whoa, how do you come to
this conclusion," you know?
[00:29:29.07]
Did she ever live in any of the hotspots?
[00:29:32.04]
- Live in the hotspots?
[00:29:33.06]
No, she lived in Egypt
[00:29:35.02]
for a few years.
- In Egypt for a few years.
[00:29:37.05]
- Yeah, growing up.
[00:29:38.08]
- Growing up, did she
belong to any organization?
[00:29:41.00]
- No.
[00:29:41.09]
- These are all of the
questions we need to find out.
[00:29:44.04]
And it's mind-boggling,
[00:29:46.00]
because to make that kind of determination
[00:29:48.01]
that someone provided material support
[00:29:51.06]
to the enemy or to a
terrorist organization,
[00:29:54.07]
in essence you have to have
something to back that up.
[00:29:58.00]
- She's never been questioned in her life
[00:30:02.01]
by any government,
[00:30:07.01]
you know, intelligence, ever.
[00:30:12.00]
Whether it be American or otherwise,
[00:30:13.09]
she's never been detained, anything, ever,
[00:30:17.06]
not even at the local level
in Trinidad and Tobago.
[00:30:21.08]
She's never been arrested.
[00:30:24.03]
- Sometimes issues like these
[00:30:27.02]
you can solve it administratively.
[00:30:30.01]
So we talk later and we
see what can be done,
[00:30:34.01]
what cannot be done.
[00:30:36.06]
- [Mohammad] First let's get
the application from his wife.
[00:30:39.08]
As soon as you get that paperwork,
[00:30:41.06]
I'll sit down with Babatunde,
[00:30:43.06]
draft a letter denying the accusations.
[00:30:47.05]
After we do that, then
we go to the congressman
[00:30:50.03]
and get assistance.
[00:30:52.06]
- [Babatunde] You don't have to wait
[00:30:53.06]
until you write the letter
[00:30:55.00]
to get a congressman
involved in your case.
[00:30:58.00]
- [Mohammad] OK.
[00:30:58.08]
- The more you wait, you know.
[00:31:01.01]
- [Mohammad] Gotcha.
[00:31:02.05]
Alright, so we're gonna do this,
[00:31:03.06]
we're gonna do things simultaneously then.
[00:31:06.00]
So simultaneously is
gonna be he's gonna ask
[00:31:08.05]
for the paperwork and I'm
gonna make an arrangement
[00:31:10.04]
for him to meet with the congressman.
[00:31:12.06]
And then as we get the paperwork,
[00:31:15.03]
then we'll draft a letter also.
[00:31:17.02]
Sounds good?
[00:31:18.02]
- That's good.
[00:31:19.01]
- [Mohammad] And then we'll
have a conversation again,
[00:31:21.03]
what's the next step.
[00:31:22.05]
- OK.
[00:31:23.03]
- Does that sound good?
[00:31:24.02]
- Sounds good.
[00:31:25.06]
- Alright, thank you Babatunde.
[00:31:27.01]
- Good.
[00:31:27.09]
- Wonderful, thank you.
[00:31:28.08]
You're the man.
[00:31:34.01]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:31:58.05]
- Prior to 9/11, what Mr. Shahid
Ali Khan and his family did
[00:32:02.06]
was do a check-in with INS--
[00:32:05.02]
like annual check-in, putting in paperwork
[00:32:07.05]
and filing for extensions.
[00:32:23.03]
- When 9/11 happened, you had
[00:32:24.08]
to special register with INS and FBI.
[00:32:28.00]
He was a visitor here from Pakistan,
[00:32:31.00]
and Pakistan was on a list,
[00:32:32.08]
so he went to special register right here,
[00:32:34.09]
as a matter of fact, in this building.
[00:32:57.02]
- [Mohammad] But for some reason this year
[00:32:59.01]
when they went for a
check-in, they said "No.
[00:33:01.04]
"We're going to put you in
deportation proceedings,
[00:33:02.09]
"the whole family."
[00:33:05.01]
What they're doing is,
[00:33:05.09]
they're basically
throwing the book at them.
[00:33:43.06]
- [Interviewer] Were you
relieved when you saw him?
[00:33:45.06]
[both laughing]
[00:33:49.02]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:34:01.03]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:35:56.07]
[Mansoor sounding out English words]
[00:36:17.07]
- The Empire State Building.
[00:37:10.09]
Yes or no.
[00:37:27.02]
[somber instrumental music]
[00:37:37.08]
- We just came out of the
deportation unit of immigration.
[00:37:42.03]
This family was reporting regularly.
[00:37:45.01]
Now they're told that
they don't have to report
[00:37:48.09]
until such time as the
stay is adjudicated.
[00:37:52.06]
That sounds like it's very good news
[00:37:54.08]
but it basically is a state of limbo,
[00:37:58.03]
because technically they can get picked up
[00:38:01.04]
at any time since they
don't have any protection.
[00:38:04.06]
And until I have that stay
I don't know where we're at.
[00:38:09.02]
Since we have a new president,
[00:38:11.05]
many people who have
been reporting for years
[00:38:14.01]
are suddenly being picked up
[00:38:15.08]
and being removed.
[00:38:17.04]
Doesn't matter what type of ties
[00:38:19.08]
they have to the United States,
[00:38:21.05]
how many American citizen
children they have,
[00:38:24.03]
it doesn't matter particularly
[00:38:26.08]
whether they have criminal issues.
[00:38:28.09]
They're getting picked up and removed.
[00:38:36.09]
- I mean there were dozens of
families that were up there,
[00:38:38.06]
who were just sitting
there and sitting there
[00:38:40.05]
and just waiting and waiting and waiting.
[00:38:42.05]
- Not really knowing
what's going to happen.
[00:38:44.03]
- Exactly.
[00:38:45.01]
- And a lot of them don't
have representation,
[00:38:47.03]
so they're just there.
[00:38:50.01]
This is not a New York problem.
[00:38:51.07]
This is a national problem.
[00:38:53.06]
It's happening everywhere
throughout the nation.
[00:38:57.02]
Families who have been
here a real long time,
[00:39:00.02]
a couple of U.S. citizen children,
[00:39:02.03]
law-abiding, tax-paying people
[00:39:05.01]
and now they're subject
to this kind of behavior,
[00:39:09.04]
this kind of behavior on
the part of the U.S.C.I.S.
[00:39:14.09]
- It is happening more now
because of the government,
[00:39:17.02]
it's happening more now because
of the current president.
[00:39:19.07]
And these policies and initiatives
[00:39:21.05]
are not going to help the people.
[00:39:23.02]
He's just putting the
fear on these families.
[00:39:26.08]
- This is not what we're
supposed to be about.
[00:39:32.02]
[pensive instrumental music]
[00:40:24.06]
- Right after 9/11, our
fellow Americans looked
[00:40:28.00]
at the Muslim community that
was living here as the enemy.
[00:40:32.03]
[imam speaking Arabic dialect]
[00:40:39.00]
They said the Muslim community
[00:40:40.09]
was linked to terrorist attacks.
[00:40:45.02]
Just right in this neighborhood,
[00:40:46.01]
over 500 individuals were rounded up.
[00:40:49.06]
If there was a person they were
looking, for Mohammad Khan,
[00:40:52.00]
it didn't matter, if Mohammad Khan
[00:40:54.02]
was 30 years old or 60 years old.
[00:40:56.06]
They just came and just
looked for Mohammad Khan,
[00:40:59.06]
because it matched up in a database.
[00:41:03.03]
When 9/11 happened, believe me,
[00:41:05.05]
I was living that American
dream and I'm still living it.
[00:41:07.06]
I was doing great.
[00:41:09.09]
My father was the first grocery
store owner on the block,
[00:41:13.04]
and the mom-and-pop stores
in these ethnic communities
[00:41:16.07]
are the social service agency providers.
[00:41:19.06]
My dad still has a book
[00:41:21.09]
where a person who did
not get his paycheck said,
[00:41:24.04]
"Can you give me some food
till the end of the week,
[00:41:27.07]
"so then I'll give you when I get paid?"
[00:41:30.05]
"I'm looking for a job."
[00:41:32.09]
And other people who
had jobs, they're like,
[00:41:35.01]
"I'm looking for a person to hire."
[00:41:36.09]
My dad always wrote this down
and tried to help the people.
[00:41:41.01]
So because of that, right after 9/11,
[00:41:45.00]
people came to my store.
[00:41:46.08]
They said, "My husband's arrested,
[00:41:48.05]
"my brother's arrested,
my cousin's arrested.
[00:41:50.08]
"What do I do?"
[00:41:53.04]
As an American who grew up here,
[00:41:55.04]
as an individual who studied here,
[00:41:57.08]
I was like, "No, you have rights."
[00:42:00.02]
I realized this is
something we need to do.
[00:42:02.02]
We need to help everyone.
[00:42:04.06]
So I opened this office, COPO,
[00:42:06.06]
Council Of Peoples Organization,
[00:42:09.00]
just temporary for six months.
[00:42:10.07]
Let me get these individuals
the help that they need,
[00:42:13.07]
the free legal services, then OK
[00:42:15.07]
and I'll go back to my fabric store.
[00:42:18.05]
It never happened.
[00:42:20.03]
And all I'm doing is
running this organization,
[00:42:24.02]
understanding the system,
working with law enforcement,
[00:42:27.08]
working with the FBI, working with NYPD.
[00:42:31.06]
This is my calling, this
is what I'm gonna do.
[00:42:40.06]
- This one is so cute.
[00:42:42.00]
- [Woman] Oh my god.
[00:42:42.09]
- I thank God for my little baby, mwah!
[00:42:45.03]
[speaking in Arabic dialect]
[00:42:49.03]
[baby laughing]
[00:42:57.05]
- [Woman 1] Cheese!
[00:42:59.07]
Thank you.
[00:43:00.07]
- [Woman 2] No problem.
[00:43:01.05]
- [Woman 3] We prayed a lot for you.
[00:43:04.07]
- So I was born in
Pakistan and I came here,
[00:43:08.03]
I was about six and a half years old,
[00:43:10.03]
and grew up in Brooklyn.
[00:43:12.02]
So I was 18 years old, I went
back home and I met her again
[00:43:15.07]
and one thing leads to another
[00:43:17.02]
and that's how we got married.
[00:43:22.02]
So we are cousin, we're family,
like I married my family.
[00:43:26.01]
He saw me, he loved me and you know,
[00:43:28.03]
the parents said, "Do you like this guy?
[00:43:30.04]
"Do you agree with it?"
[00:43:31.04]
I say, "OK, he's a cool guy,
[00:43:33.07]
"let me get married with him, that's it."
[00:43:36.03]
Basically the parents,
they choose the girl or boy
[00:43:40.01]
and let the girl or boy know,
"OK this is the good for you.
[00:43:44.01]
"This is, you know, your life's going
[00:43:45.09]
"to be very happy with this guy.
[00:43:48.03]
"He can give you love and
support you in everything,
[00:43:51.05]
"whatever you need in life.
[00:43:53.06]
"Now you can choose
and you can decide it."
[00:43:57.01]
That's the arranged, because
the parents they decided it
[00:44:01.01]
and then the final
decision has to be them.
[00:44:05.02]
- When me and my wife met,
there were other proposals.
[00:44:10.08]
However, I felt, you know,
I was most comfortable
[00:44:12.09]
and she was most
comfortable with each other.
[00:44:16.00]
And same thing with Faizan and Aasah.
[00:44:19.01]
- We had an arranged
love marriage, I guess.
[00:44:24.02]
And I have a son and he's 13 months.
[00:44:28.04]
[baby laughing]
[00:44:33.00]
- Trump did not start all this.
[00:44:36.03]
9/11 had happened, and I had
been through a tough time.
[00:44:42.04]
I had a boy pull off my hijab
while I was switching classes.
[00:44:49.09]
I've had another student cut up my abaya,
[00:44:54.04]
I used to wear an abaya to school.
[00:44:57.03]
And I've gotten pushed
at, I've gotten beaten up.
[00:45:02.02]
Out on the street
waiting at the bus stop--
[00:45:06.01]
and this was just in
fifth and sixth grade--
[00:45:09.08]
the kid sitting next to me in fifth grade
[00:45:12.02]
would say that my father is a terrorist
[00:45:14.07]
and that I should go back to my country.
[00:45:18.02]
I was born and raised in Brooklyn
[00:45:20.06]
and I was born in Coney
Island Hospital, you know?
[00:45:24.01]
I don't know how much
more American you can get.
[00:45:28.07]
[people screaming]
[00:45:34.01]
- I did have people say to
me, "You fuckin' Muslim,
[00:45:37.01]
"go back to your country",
things like that.
[00:45:39.06]
I didn't personally
have someone attack me,
[00:45:43.06]
but I did see it happen
to a lot of people.
[00:45:47.08]
There is a time when I was in 10th grade
[00:45:50.04]
and we were sitting in the classroom,
[00:45:53.00]
and there's only me and
probably one other boy
[00:45:55.09]
within 30 kids who are Muslim.
[00:45:58.09]
And the teacher puts
on this video showing--
[00:46:01.05]
I don't know, I don't even
want to call them Muslims--
[00:46:03.04]
crazy people, just attacking,
like, the American flag
[00:46:07.01]
and just talking bad about America.
[00:46:11.00]
When he shut the video
off, nobody said a word.
[00:46:14.02]
And I'm just sitting there and I'm like,
[00:46:15.08]
OK, I wish I can just,
like, go into a little rock
[00:46:17.09]
and just hide myself because everybody
[00:46:19.03]
in this class knows I'm Muslim
[00:46:20.06]
and just had to see this video
[00:46:22.03]
that had nothing to do with Muslims.
[00:46:26.01]
Miss Razvi needs to get
dressed for the party!
[00:46:29.02]
I'm in 10th grade, I'm not even thinking
[00:46:30.08]
about ever being a teacher,
[00:46:31.07]
but I did believe what
he did was a mistake.
[00:46:34.06]
That's where hate comes from.
[00:46:36.02]
That's where it comes from.
[00:46:40.09]
- One thing that we learn,
even in Islamic school,
[00:46:44.01]
is God accepts everyone
and God loves mankind--
[00:46:48.02]
everyone, every single human being.
[00:46:50.07]
My father never said, "Don't
hang out with these people."
[00:46:53.06]
It's hate that's being taught.
[00:46:55.08]
In this growing world,
in this diverse world,
[00:46:58.02]
our prophet always teaches us
[00:47:00.02]
that we should accept every single person,
[00:47:02.07]
we should live by example,
[00:47:05.02]
we should do things in such a way
[00:47:07.08]
where we're not being
considered, you know,
[00:47:11.05]
"Oh, they don't like us
so we won't like them."
[00:47:13.07]
We should never do that.
[00:47:14.08]
Islam means, "I Shall Love All Mankind."
[00:47:18.02]
- We're always talking about advocacy
[00:47:20.00]
and, like, how important it is.
[00:47:22.01]
I know what I've been through,
[00:47:23.09]
I felt I didn't have a voice,
[00:47:26.06]
and now I want to teach girls and boys
[00:47:28.05]
that, no, they do have the voice.
[00:47:31.01]
It's scary, the trend is really scary.
[00:47:33.03]
I mean even today,
there are at times where
[00:47:35.04]
I'll have to have a
conversation with my father,
[00:47:37.04]
"Hey, Dad, how do I take
care of this situation?
[00:47:41.01]
"I don't know."
[00:47:41.09]
But I just hope that I'm able
[00:47:44.04]
to become a powerful voice for them
[00:47:47.03]
and teach them different
skills, different types,
[00:47:50.09]
so they are able to
advocate for themselves.
[00:47:54.09]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:47:57.02]
- When you get good
feedback from the community
[00:48:00.01]
and they will stop you or thank you,
[00:48:01.08]
"You helped me with this,
you helped me with that,"
[00:48:04.04]
it's amazing.
[00:48:07.01]
And if you promote this
better in the community,
[00:48:12.04]
it will be like a flower
which is becoming a good fruit
[00:48:17.04]
for the next generation
and then next generation.
[00:48:20.04]
And it would be a good place for everyone.
[00:48:23.01]
- In our culture, in Islam itself,
[00:48:25.08]
if you hurt one human being
[00:48:28.02]
it's as if you hurt all of mankind.
[00:48:31.04]
If you help one human being,
[00:48:34.05]
it's as if you helped all of mankind.
[00:48:38.01]
- After medical school,
after working for awhile,
[00:48:41.01]
I want to help my dad
advance his endeavor.
[00:48:45.04]
I'd like to believe that
modeling myself after my father,
[00:48:49.01]
it's a great way to give
back to the community
[00:48:52.04]
and a great way to protect my generation.
[00:48:54.06]
If I can, you know, take all that hate,
[00:48:56.05]
if I can stand in front of, you know,
[00:48:58.06]
all the shouting
individuals, the protests,
[00:49:00.00]
or you've had election day or anywhere,
[00:49:03.08]
then it's OK.
[00:49:05.01]
I will take that sacrifice
[00:49:06.06]
just to protect my future generation
[00:49:08.07]
and their generation to come.
[00:49:12.00]
[pensive instrumental music]
[00:49:23.09]
[tranquil instrumental music]
[00:50:25.00]
[tranquil instrumental music]
[00:51:06.06]
[waves lapping]
[00:52:19.08]
[pensive instrumental music]
[00:52:44.08]
- [Child] I get to say nothing.
[00:52:48.06]
- You'll be OK.
[00:52:49.08]
Mommy's just telling Daddy goodbye, OK?
[00:52:56.03]
[child sobbing]
[00:53:00.02]
You'll be alright.
[00:53:01.01]
He said his goodbyes already to you.
[00:53:09.07]
- [Ali] Alright, well.
[00:53:11.01]
- Give me a hug.
[00:53:27.07]
[gentle instrumental music]
[00:53:54.00]
[speaking in Arabic dialect]
[00:53:57.05]
- [Mir] Anytime, anywhere
I go, people ask,
[00:54:00.02]
"Where you come from?" or say
that "You are not part of us.
[00:54:05.08]
"Muslims don't belong here."
[00:54:13.00]
That kind of message I never
heard in the last 35 years.
[00:54:18.00]
After 9/11 it was bad, but
not as bad as it is now.
[00:54:27.01]
Lately it's becoming part
of our daily routine.
[00:54:34.08]
One day I was in shopping,
some lady came over and says,
[00:54:39.05]
"Get out of this country,
you don't belong here."
[00:54:43.06]
So that hurt me a lot.
[00:54:48.03]
- Even though we're becoming more
[00:54:49.09]
of a political influence,
[00:54:51.01]
racism and Islamophobic
are a big issue for us.
[00:54:54.07]
With Donald Trump saying
what he's saying, you know,
[00:54:56.05]
it's not really helping out a lot.
[00:54:58.07]
It's making things even worse.
[00:55:00.02]
It's marginalizing us.
[00:55:01.03]
It's making us seem
like we're the targets.
[00:55:05.02]
- According to Pew research, among others,
[00:55:08.05]
there is a great hatred toward Americans
[00:55:12.01]
by large segments of
the Muslim population.
[00:55:17.03]
- Muslims were pretty quiet
when we came to America.
[00:55:20.04]
Like, if we leave other people
alone, they won't bother us.
[00:55:24.00]
And they don't realize that
that's not the case anymore.
[00:55:26.04]
We gotta start standing
up against injustice.
[00:55:28.08]
- The Muslims pose a threat.
[00:55:30.02]
Not all Muslims, but you can't tell
[00:55:31.08]
the good ones from the bad ones.
[00:55:33.01]
It's the Muslims that
are killing Americans
[00:55:34.09]
right now, isn't it?
[00:55:35.08]
- I don't have a racist bone in my body.
[00:55:37.06]
I'm not-- I'm not that way.
[00:55:39.07]
I just think we need to vet
people a little bit better
[00:55:42.00]
and find out why they're here.
[00:55:43.09]
- You are terrorists.
[00:55:45.00]
Every one of you are terrorists.
[00:55:46.06]
I don't care what you say.
[00:55:47.08]
- I don't appreciate that I have to be
[00:55:51.07]
not safe in my own country
[00:55:53.01]
because there are some
tenets of their religion
[00:55:56.08]
that basically teach that
they're going to kill people
[00:56:00.00]
who don't believe what they believe.
[00:56:01.09]
- I don't feel safe.
[00:56:03.07]
And I think a lot of the
country feels the same way.
[00:56:10.02]
- The real task of a Muslim is
to reach out to non-Muslims.
[00:56:15.06]
My understanding of American people
[00:56:18.05]
is that if you reach
out to American people,
[00:56:20.03]
they will come.
[00:56:22.02]
In that respect, if we
as Muslims goes out,
[00:56:26.00]
make a friend of non-Muslims,
[00:56:28.00]
make a friend of our neighbors,
[00:56:29.08]
make a friend of an outsider,
[00:56:32.06]
then they will see the
good part of Muslims.
[00:56:36.03]
- We started getting involved
in politics, because that's
[00:56:38.04]
the only way you can get
things changed nowadays--
[00:56:41.01]
if you get involved.
[00:56:42.08]
And I feel like that's the
best way to combat Islamophobia
[00:56:46.08]
or any kind of phobia.
[00:56:50.00]
- I've been working with my community,
[00:56:51.07]
especially after 9/11,
because I was attacked
[00:56:56.01]
by some random police officer.
[00:57:00.02]
So after that I've been working
[00:57:01.07]
with the police department very closely,
[00:57:04.01]
because I wanted to
trust police department
[00:57:06.09]
and police department
can come and, you know,
[00:57:10.04]
have a good communication
with my community.
[00:57:18.06]
- Myself, my brother and
my dad were coming back
[00:57:20.06]
from a campaign that we
were doing in Queens.
[00:57:23.04]
A police officer pulled us over
[00:57:25.07]
and asked for our
license and registration.
[00:57:29.03]
My dad likes to keep all the
registrations of all the cars
[00:57:31.09]
from the past couple years in the car,
[00:57:33.08]
so I always tell my dad,
[00:57:35.04]
"Just make sure you give
them the right one."
[00:57:36.07]
And in pure English, my dad's like,
[00:57:38.07]
"Yeah, here's the right one."
[00:57:39.06]
And the police officer was like,
[00:57:40.06]
"Speak English like an
educated human being."
[00:57:43.04]
And then we're like,
[00:57:45.01]
my dad's got a master's
degree from Baruch.
[00:57:48.08]
We were, like, really
surprised that, y'know,
[00:57:50.07]
why would someone be
saying something like that?
[00:57:53.02]
- [Interviewer] I know
some of you were born here,
[00:57:54.09]
but those of you who were not,
[00:57:56.06]
what country do you come from?
[00:57:58.07]
- From Bangladesh.
[00:58:00.02]
- [Interviewer] You too?
[00:58:01.00]
- I'm from Bangladesh as well.
[00:58:02.09]
- [Interviewer] And how
long have you been here?
[00:58:07.09]
- 36 years in this country.
[00:58:10.06]
- And I'm 33, almost 34 years.
[00:58:14.07]
- [Interviewer] And how
long have you been married?
[00:58:16.09]
- 23 years.
[00:58:18.06]
- Almost 24.
[00:58:21.08]
- [Interviewer] And you met here?
[00:58:23.01]
- [Both] Yes.
[00:58:24.01]
- She was from Washington,
I was in New York,
[00:58:26.02]
so that would introduce a
very close friend of ours.
[00:58:32.02]
[gentle piano music]
[00:58:42.06]
- After 9/11, I was supposed
to get some printing done.
[00:58:50.00]
My printer, he was a very close friend,
[00:58:54.04]
but he refused to print any of my work
[00:58:57.08]
because of the U.S. war with the Muslims.
[00:59:02.00]
And he did not do anything anymore for me.
[00:59:06.00]
No calls received, nothing.
[00:59:09.08]
So good thing happened
that I find other printer,
[00:59:13.01]
but I lost a friend.
[00:59:24.08]
- My son, he was in first
grade when 9/11 happened.
[00:59:28.09]
And the teacher asked all the students
[00:59:32.08]
what could prevent the
Twin Tower not falling,
[00:59:37.01]
so we can have our Twin Tower remain.
[00:59:40.00]
And everybody, they draw
something, they write something.
[00:59:44.02]
So-- and they called me from the school,
[00:59:48.00]
they say my son did something.
[00:59:52.08]
He wants to destroy Twin Tower.
[00:59:58.03]
They took him on the side,
[01:00:00.02]
and some big people was around him,
[01:00:03.09]
and he gets so scared and shaky
[01:00:06.06]
because they ask him many questions
[01:00:09.00]
and they scared him so much.
[01:00:11.01]
He was in a trauma by
the time I hold his hand.
[01:00:14.06]
He was shaking.
[01:00:17.01]
And then I asked him why
he draw that picture,
[01:00:21.06]
and then he say, "I want to
make sure nobody hit Twin Tower
[01:00:27.05]
"and break our Twin Tower a second time.
[01:00:30.00]
"I want to make sure the
Twin Tower remain forever.
[01:00:33.04]
"If it's a horizontal level Twin Town,
[01:00:36.01]
"then nobody can destroy it.
[01:00:37.03]
"It's not gonna fall, nobody's gonna die."
[01:00:40.02]
That's why he draw that picture.
[01:00:44.03]
And I kept that picture with me,
[01:00:46.06]
because I want to pass
that to my grandchildren,
[01:00:49.02]
my next generation.
[01:00:51.08]
That is very important.
[01:00:56.08]
[gentle instrumental music]
[01:01:00.09]
- I went to Japan on a fully
funded trip with Global Kids.
[01:01:04.07]
They're a youth empowerment organization
[01:01:06.05]
that I work with very, very closely.
[01:01:09.03]
And despite being different--
[01:01:11.08]
Like, everyone knew we were American
[01:01:13.04]
and everyone looked at us, like--
[01:01:15.00]
They stared at us but
it was like, "Oh, OK,"
[01:01:18.02]
and then they continued.
[01:01:19.01]
You know, I wasn't treated differently,
[01:01:21.06]
versus here in my own country
[01:01:23.02]
there are times that people look at me
[01:01:25.00]
and they're like "Uh,"
[01:01:26.07]
and they'll have this kind of tone--
[01:01:28.02]
they'll change the tone of their voice
[01:01:30.02]
or they'll act differently
around me versus
[01:01:32.05]
I'm in a completely foreign country,
[01:01:35.08]
and I'm being treated
better there than I am here.
[01:01:38.05]
Yeah.
[01:01:44.00]
- After 9/11, we've been through a lot,
[01:01:47.03]
especially the woman wearing hijab.
[01:01:50.09]
The first pin.
[01:01:53.02]
Then I have to make sure I have enough.
[01:01:57.00]
But just simply, it is getting worse.
[01:02:01.02]
Any place I go, I could be target.
[01:02:06.01]
Three weeks ago a Muslim
woman got stabbed in Queens.
[01:02:11.09]
So it's all the time we're in fear,
[01:02:15.08]
me and the other women
that look like Muslim.
[01:02:22.07]
- I just do that,
[01:02:25.08]
and then I kind of frame my face.
[01:02:29.04]
The style of your hijab...
[01:02:31.00]
And then I pin it right here.
[01:02:32.03]
...it's not a one-size-fits-all
kind of thing.
[01:02:35.05]
It's like you find what fits your face.
[01:02:37.05]
And then I take the left side
[01:02:41.09]
and I just go around, and this
is kinda just to add volume.
[01:02:46.04]
Everyone experiments.
[01:02:48.03]
Sometimes it's a disaster.
[01:02:51.01]
You look back at old
pictures and you're like,
[01:02:52.06]
"Why did I do that?"
[01:02:55.07]
And then I pin it once here.
[01:02:57.08]
But then when you find
the style of your hijab,
[01:03:00.00]
like that style that will
always come through for you.
[01:03:02.01]
That's one thing you can depend on.
[01:03:06.01]
That is it, I'm done.
[01:03:08.04]
[crowd cheering]
[01:03:10.01]
- We have everything here today.
[01:03:12.05]
We have Hindus here.
[01:03:13.07]
We have Jews.
[01:03:15.04]
We have Christians.
[01:03:16.02]
We have Catholics.
[01:03:17.04]
We have atheists.
[01:03:18.04]
We have America here today!
[01:03:21.06]
This is beautiful!
[01:03:23.00]
[crowd cheering]
[01:03:32.07]
- I'm actually here because
my wife is an immigrant.
[01:03:35.09]
She came here when she was six,
[01:03:37.07]
couldn't speak English at all.
[01:03:39.04]
But I'm here for all the
other girls that are here
[01:03:42.01]
who can't speak English,
just so they can be amazing
[01:03:46.04]
to somebody else someday
like she's amazing to me.
[01:03:48.09]
- This is America.
[01:03:50.06]
The president doesn't represent us.
[01:03:52.04]
And I think it's absolutely deplorable
[01:03:54.03]
that Muslims are being
attacked and targeted.
[01:03:59.00]
We're citizens of the world.
[01:04:00.04]
We're gonna stay that way.
[01:04:01.03]
We're going forward, we're
not going back anywhere,
[01:04:03.05]
whatever that's supposed to mean.
[01:04:05.00]
- Xenophobia, just trying
to build up support
[01:04:08.03]
on the basis of people's fears,
[01:04:10.09]
and so that is what I object to.
[01:04:14.09]
- I want to be part of this movement.
[01:04:17.05]
I want to be part of this group.
[01:04:19.03]
I want to be part of this great day.
[01:04:22.04]
I don't want anybody else,
[01:04:24.01]
we suffer like what we are suffering,
[01:04:26.02]
what the Jewish people have suffered
[01:04:28.00]
or the Japanese have suffered,
[01:04:29.07]
or the blacks have suffered.
[01:04:31.04]
We want to be have this the end of it,
[01:04:33.08]
So no more should the
United States of America,
[01:04:37.03]
this should be the end of all the racism.
[01:04:41.03]
[crowd yelling and cheering]
[01:04:48.06]
[gentle instrumental music]
[01:04:55.09]
- I really want Donald
Trump and his supporters
[01:04:59.00]
to know about Islam and Muslims.
[01:05:02.02]
We are American Muslims.
[01:05:04.02]
We are like others, everything is same.
[01:05:07.01]
We have good day, bad day, we love,
[01:05:09.05]
we have family, we have
neighbor, we have pets.
[01:05:13.06]
Islam is-- the faith is for universal,
[01:05:18.07]
and if I do not love other faith
[01:05:22.02]
and other books I'm
not an American Muslim.
[01:05:25.07]
So this is Islam.
[01:05:27.08]
Islam is not something fear of it.
[01:05:30.03]
It shouldn't be phobia of it.
[01:05:32.00]
It shouldn't be hate of it.
[01:05:33.02]
It should be included
with all other faiths.
[01:05:45.04]
[pensive instrumental music]
[01:06:08.01]
- It's always like the first
time, every time it happens.
[01:06:15.05]
They call me up front
[01:06:16.07]
and they're not letting
anybody get off the plane
[01:06:19.04]
until I maneuver my way to
the front and then come out.
[01:06:22.09]
You know, and everybody's
staring at me like I'm--
[01:06:26.00]
like I'm guilty of something,
like I'm some fugitive
[01:06:28.08]
that has now been caught.
[01:06:30.05]
That's what everybody's thinking,
[01:06:31.07]
because they don't see
me again after that.
[01:06:34.00]
I go into some abyss, into some room
[01:06:36.08]
and that's it, everybody goes home
[01:06:38.04]
and basically says, "Wow,
we saw this Muslim guy,
[01:06:42.01]
"he got called to the front
[01:06:43.04]
"and then they just took him away."
[01:06:44.07]
And what does that mean?
[01:06:46.00]
That means you're guilty of something.
[01:06:51.00]
Leaving this time definitely
was heart wrenching,
[01:06:54.05]
to say the least.
[01:06:56.00]
Yesterday was bad, it wasn't good at all.
[01:07:00.04]
Yesterday was a very silent
day, which is worrisome.
[01:07:04.09]
Cold silence is a very dangerous thing
[01:07:09.04]
and it has a tendency
to atrophy compassion
[01:07:14.06]
between the spouses, so.
[01:07:18.07]
But, y'know, we left on a good note
[01:07:20.03]
and I guess you just do what you can.
[01:07:22.04]
And there's not much
else I can do right now.
[01:07:33.06]
Y'know, now I'm just
gonna call the family,
[01:07:35.06]
let 'em know I'm back.
[01:07:38.00]
I'm back into the grind again,
y'know, until next time.
[01:07:42.08]
You know, it's a frustrating situation,
[01:07:46.04]
but if I dwell on it too much
[01:07:48.07]
it's just gonna drive me insane.
[01:07:50.09]
So it's better that I just
smile and wave, y'know?
[01:07:56.08]
[bird wings fluttering]
[01:08:01.08]
- [Announcer] You ready?
[01:08:03.02]
Alright, here we go!
[01:08:04.02]
[audience applauding]
[01:08:05.05]
You're gonna love this next lady.
[01:08:06.06]
She is hilarious.
[01:08:07.07]
I saw her last night, she
brought the house down.
[01:08:10.00]
She's also Palestinian.
[01:08:11.03]
Please welcome to the stage, Suzi Afridi!
[01:08:14.01]
[audience applauding and whooping]
[01:08:25.04]
Salaam alaikum.
[01:08:28.03]
Hi guys, my name is Suzi.
[01:08:31.06]
I'm Palestinian, but I'm
married to a Pakistani.
[01:08:35.01]
[audience member cheering]
[01:08:35.09]
Well, OK.
[01:08:40.08]
You know how most people
confuse Palestine with Pakistan?
[01:08:45.00]
What I found really offensive
[01:08:47.00]
is when they confuse
Palestinians with Pakistanis,
[01:08:50.00]
because we're very different
kinds of terrorists, right?
[01:08:53.06]
[audience laughing]
[01:08:54.05]
I mean, you know, the
difference is obvious, right?
[01:08:56.06]
My people were on the
first season of Homeland.
[01:08:59.03]
[audience laughing and applauding]
[01:09:04.06]
The Pakistanis came on the fourth season.
[01:09:06.03]
[audience laughs]
[01:09:11.05]
[somber violin music]
[01:09:18.05]
[Suzi] We've been married for...
[01:09:20.04]
- [Saks] 15 years.
[01:09:21.03]
- 15 years, yeah.
[01:09:23.07]
We met at this picnic, like
an Arab salvation picnic,
[01:09:28.03]
and I was hesitant about going.
[01:09:31.03]
As soon as I walked in, I
meet, like, all these guys.
[01:09:34.02]
There were all these Gulf
Arab guys, like, you know,
[01:09:37.05]
Saudis-- were they Saudis or Kuwaitis?
[01:09:40.02]
- Both.
[01:09:41.01]
- Yeah, and I could tell right away,
[01:09:42.07]
because I'm not racist
but, like, I stereotype.
[01:09:47.05]
And so I was like, "Gulf
Arab, Gulf Arab, Gulf Arab."
[01:09:49.05]
And then I meet him, and
he totally stood out.
[01:09:52.07]
And then it was love at
first sight, I think.
[01:09:56.02]
For him mostly.
[01:09:57.03]
[both laughing]
[01:09:59.06]
We thought-- at the
time that we got married
[01:10:01.05]
we thought that we would--
people thought or we thought
[01:10:03.09]
that we would be fighting about religion,
[01:10:05.05]
like what religion, what
faith are we gonna practice.
[01:10:08.07]
- Well, we fought that battle early on.
[01:10:10.06]
We won that battle, really.
[01:10:11.05]
- [Suzi] Yeah, we settled on Islam.
[01:10:12.08]
- We moved on to the
more important battles.
[01:10:14.02]
- Yeah, yeah, we settled on Islam.
[01:10:15.06]
And the thing that I say
is that I converted, like,
[01:10:18.09]
I converted but I don't practice.
[01:10:21.05]
So I feel like I downloaded the app,
[01:10:23.05]
but I haven't really played with it.
[01:10:27.00]
- [Both] Hi!
[01:10:28.05]
- [Suzi] Hello, hello.
[01:10:29.03]
- How are you?
[01:10:30.02]
- How are you?
[01:10:31.00]
A long time!
[01:10:31.09]
Hi, it's so good to see you!
[01:10:33.03]
- [John] Hey brother, how are you?
[01:10:35.00]
- Good to see you.
[01:10:35.08]
- [Suzi] You know that
I speak Urdu, right?
[01:10:37.02]
- [Saks] We have water,
white wine, red wine.
[01:10:41.00]
- This is haram.
[01:10:41.08]
We hare having white
wine in red wine glasses.
[01:10:44.09]
- That's haram.
[01:10:46.03]
- Saks has not given me a glass.
[01:10:48.01]
- Oh, there's not one in front of you?
[01:10:49.08]
- [Suzi] There should
be a fatwa against us.
[01:10:55.08]
- Nice.
[01:10:56.07]
- [Suzi] So we're gonna scoop the bottom.
[01:10:59.06]
I hope you all eat lamb.
[01:11:00.05]
I didn't even ask.
[01:11:01.05]
- Amazing!
- Yes!
[01:11:02.07]
- [Suzi] Maqluba is a Palestinian dish,
[01:11:04.08]
and it basically means "upside down,"
[01:11:06.05]
'cause you put the vegetables,
the meat and the rice
[01:11:08.09]
all in one dish and
you let it slowly cook.
[01:11:11.01]
This is from the days when they
could only afford one fire.
[01:11:13.07]
- [Homa] Ah, OK.
[01:11:17.07]
- So we've been married a long time
[01:11:18.09]
and I've noticed there's a
[01:11:20.03]
major cultural difference between us.
[01:11:22.01]
Like he is Asian, so he
has that Asian work ethic.
[01:11:26.04]
You know what that is.
[01:11:27.06]
If one can do it than I can do it, right?
[01:11:31.06]
If no one can do it, then I must do it.
[01:11:35.02]
And I have the Arab work ethic, you know,
[01:11:38.07]
which is, if one can do it, let him do it.
[01:11:41.09]
[audience applauding]
[01:11:47.08]
And if no one can do it,
habibi how can I do it?
[01:11:53.07]
Being Palestinian, I
think you're always aware
[01:11:56.00]
of who you are.
[01:11:57.01]
You know that people
think you're a terrorist,
[01:11:59.00]
but you know who you are.
[01:12:00.05]
- I think when you grow up here,
[01:12:01.09]
you're really aware of differences
[01:12:04.08]
because everyone's from somewhere else.
[01:12:06.07]
- It's an interesting time
now, I think, in that...
[01:12:12.05]
Our level of comfort for discussing race,
[01:12:15.05]
I feel like has gone
in the other direction.
[01:12:18.03]
Y'know, we talk about America
becoming a non-white nation,
[01:12:22.01]
but that we will continually reinvent
[01:12:24.02]
the notion of whiteness
so that white people
[01:12:26.04]
are in majority or at least hold power.
[01:12:29.05]
- It's not that race created racism,
[01:12:32.04]
it's that racism created
the concept of race.
[01:12:35.02]
So our phenotypes, like what
we physically look like,
[01:12:38.04]
like in terms of, like, DNA,
[01:12:40.08]
what separates somebody who might
[01:12:42.03]
look extremely different from another
[01:12:44.07]
is, like, a minuscule
fraction of a percent.
[01:12:47.07]
- The issue to me is, like,
[01:12:49.05]
why is one thing better
than another thing?
[01:12:51.06]
We're same enough that we
can talk to each other.
[01:12:54.00]
We can, like, use words and
smiles and body language
[01:12:58.06]
to try to understand each other.
[01:13:00.02]
But no one really tries.
[01:13:02.04]
Put your energy in being
nice to each other.
[01:13:06.02]
- I grew up being part of a community.
[01:13:09.04]
Saks grew up being part of a community.
[01:13:11.05]
And we wanted our son to be exposed
[01:13:14.02]
to the right kind of Islam.
[01:13:15.07]
And we're not-- we don't practice enough
[01:13:19.09]
to be able to teach him at
home, and we wanted him--
[01:13:23.04]
I kind of, personally as a convert,
[01:13:25.03]
I wanted to learn with him.
[01:13:27.05]
I remember once my mother-in-law was over,
[01:13:30.01]
when he was really little,
and she was praying
[01:13:32.07]
and he said, "Oh Nana, you're doing yoga.
[01:13:35.02]
"I'll do yoga with you."
[01:13:36.05]
And then she said, "You
have taught him nothing!"
[01:13:39.03]
And so that-- there was a
little bit of guilt there.
[01:13:44.00]
We decided to send our
son to Sunday school.
[01:13:48.08]
You know, we were very specific
[01:13:50.04]
about what the values and the morals
[01:13:52.07]
and the beliefs of the
Sunday school that we wanted.
[01:13:54.06]
And we were so happy
to find Cordoba House.
[01:13:58.04]
The imam of the school,
who is Imam Feisal,
[01:14:00.07]
is trying to redefine what it means
[01:14:02.07]
to be an American Muslim.
[01:14:04.07]
So he takes into consideration, you know,
[01:14:07.02]
the way we are vilified on TV
[01:14:09.04]
and he also takes into
consideration, you know,
[01:14:12.06]
what it means to be Muslim after 9/11.
[01:14:14.08]
It's very hard to sort of say to yourself,
[01:14:18.02]
"I'm gonna claim this thing
that is vilified on TV."
[01:14:21.07]
I think it's easy for
completely secular Muslim
[01:14:24.08]
or ex-Muslim-- like, I have
a friend who's ex-Muslim--
[01:14:26.08]
to say, "I want nothing to do with that."
[01:14:29.00]
It's easy.
[01:14:30.03]
And it's very hard to say,
"No, I want to claim this,"
[01:14:32.07]
because being Arab and being Muslim is--
[01:14:36.09]
There's so much, there's so much culture
[01:14:39.01]
and tradition and history there
[01:14:42.04]
and it's-- you know, you have to just
[01:14:44.08]
kind of teach your kids,
we have to teach our son
[01:14:47.00]
that yes, you know, this
is the narrative on TV
[01:14:50.06]
but we are not that.
[01:14:52.04]
[audience laughing]
[01:14:54.07]
So I grew up in the West
Bank and most people wonder
[01:14:58.04]
if my real name is like Fatima Adijah,
[01:15:00.05]
but it's actually Suzi.
[01:15:02.03]
[audience laughing]
[01:15:04.02]
My sister, who looks
way more Arab than I do,
[01:15:06.07]
her name is Jane but-- Jane.
[01:15:09.08]
But her eyebrows alone speak Arabic.
[01:15:12.06]
[audience laughing]
[01:15:16.01]
This is-- a fun fact about me
[01:15:18.07]
is that I have spent more
money on facial hair removal
[01:15:21.08]
than I did on college.
[01:15:23.07]
[audience laughing]
[01:15:26.02]
- Oh my god, I feel like
I've been waiting for it
[01:15:28.05]
to happen my whole life, in a weird sense.
[01:15:30.08]
I've been waiting for some
sort of, like, crisis where--
[01:15:36.03]
- [Saks] Right, major crackdown.
[01:15:37.06]
- A major crackdown of some sort
[01:15:39.02]
where one's identity was
going to be important,
[01:15:44.01]
and that you had to choose some side
[01:15:46.07]
that you didn't ever really
necessarily think about.
[01:15:50.05]
Or if you did it wasn't necessarily like--
[01:15:52.09]
- One of the first things my parents said
[01:15:55.08]
when they saw this tattoo on my arm is,
[01:15:59.00]
"Now everybody's gonna
know you're Pakistani."
[01:16:04.00]
And I said, "Yeah, OK.
[01:16:05.06]
"So what's wrong, are you saying
[01:16:07.04]
"there's anything wrong with that?
[01:16:08.05]
"Is there anything wrong with being
[01:16:10.07]
"sort of like that I'm originally
[01:16:12.03]
"from Pakistan or anything?"
[01:16:14.01]
They said, "No, but you're
just labeling yourself
[01:16:16.09]
"very clearly, and what
if there's like some nut
[01:16:19.02]
"or psycho that sees
that and attacks you?"
[01:16:22.03]
- There's been a tension my whole life
[01:16:23.09]
that feels like something's gonna happen.
[01:16:27.00]
Like whenever I watch movies
[01:16:28.06]
that have any sort of political disruption
[01:16:33.07]
that happens all of a sudden, y'know,
[01:16:36.03]
and then there's suddenly these
sides that have to be taken,
[01:16:40.00]
or I hear about it actually
happening in other places,
[01:16:42.09]
I associate with it.
[01:16:44.04]
- John, you're the guy,
like, if something happens
[01:16:46.07]
and, like, there's a
holocaust against Muslims,
[01:16:48.08]
we will hide at your place.
[01:16:50.06]
You will protect us.
[01:16:54.07]
I want to know, Omar, what was it like
[01:16:56.07]
when you can out to your parents?
[01:16:58.04]
- I think I must have been in--
[01:17:01.03]
what was it, 9th grade or something?
[01:17:04.09]
So I think we were coming into the city,
[01:17:07.00]
my mother and I, so
sometime in high school,
[01:17:09.01]
and I told her, I said,
"Listen, what I do know is
[01:17:11.07]
"that I don't think that I'm straight."
[01:17:14.09]
And so she was pretty cool.
[01:17:16.00]
She was like, "Listen,
you know I have concerns
[01:17:17.07]
"for you in terms of, I don't want you
[01:17:19.08]
"to have something about you
[01:17:22.02]
"that would make your
life more difficult."
[01:17:24.01]
But any case, she was
fairly cool about it.
[01:17:25.08]
My father, I think my
father had a tougher time.
[01:17:31.04]
And so I also told him, I said
"Look, you know I have love,
[01:17:34.04]
"affection and sexual attraction
with men and also women."
[01:17:38.09]
So I think he chose to
focus on the women part.
[01:17:42.03]
- [Saks] There is a chance!
[01:17:43.01]
- Yeah, exactly.
[01:17:44.08]
- So you're very lucky that your parents
[01:17:47.06]
were calm about it.
[01:17:51.01]
- Yeah, I'm grateful that we
just came from a place of,
[01:17:54.08]
you know, self-knowledge and sort of
[01:17:56.09]
ease in one's own identity in that sense.
[01:18:00.02]
- So Amy Schumer has
this joke that I love,
[01:18:02.07]
she says, "I'm not a feminist,
[01:18:04.06]
"but feminists are in good hands with me."
[01:18:07.09]
And so after I did the Muslim Funny Fest,
[01:18:10.07]
a woman came up to me and said,
[01:18:11.09]
"You know, you're not really Muslim."
[01:18:13.02]
I said, "You know, you might not claim me
[01:18:15.06]
"but I think Muslims are
in good hands with me."
[01:18:17.08]
Like I'm only gonna sort
of improve the narrative.
[01:18:22.04]
And I think that that's what Muslim needs.
[01:18:24.03]
I think Muslims need
more Arabs and Muslims
[01:18:28.06]
and people of color in media
[01:18:30.01]
so that we can change the narrative
[01:18:33.01]
through our storytelling.
[01:18:36.02]
So to summarize for you guys--
[01:18:38.01]
this is like the TED
Talk portion of my show--
[01:18:40.03]
basically, when a Christian Arab girl
[01:18:42.05]
falls in love with a Muslim,
she's either disowned
[01:18:45.04]
or her mother gets a heart attack
[01:18:47.01]
or her father kills her
in an honor killing.
[01:18:49.06]
So you can imagine how hard it was for me
[01:18:51.03]
when I fell in love with a Pakistani.
[01:18:52.07]
It wasn't easy.
[01:18:53.08]
And I'm actually writing
a book about my experience
[01:18:56.08]
and it's titled, "I Married
a Muslim and No One Died".
[01:19:00.07]
[audience laughing and applauding]
[01:19:02.05]
You guys have been
amazing, thank you so much!
[01:19:05.03]
[audience applauding]
[01:19:14.09]
[instrumental oud music]
[01:19:26.09]
- The reason why it would seem
[01:19:33.04]
like I have little interest
to bring my wife to America
[01:19:37.08]
is 'cause it's been in limbo so long,
[01:19:40.03]
I'm just exhausted, y'know?
[01:19:43.08]
And I turned down a lot of opportunities.
[01:19:47.09]
I, y'know, made a lot of silly choices
[01:19:51.06]
banking on this happening.
[01:19:59.09]
It just turned out to be
endless hours of waiting
[01:20:02.09]
and filling out forms and
going here and going there
[01:20:07.04]
and, y'know, just deciding
[01:20:10.01]
to just throw the whole issue out.
[01:20:13.06]
I'm getting ready, I'm thinking
about just changing jobs,
[01:20:16.05]
changing countries, changing
nationalities, I don't know.
[01:20:20.09]
Everything, y'know?
[01:20:23.02]
I'm not expecting to be here much longer.
[01:20:26.00]
Not at this center, not in this country.
[01:20:28.06]
I just don't have much zeal to, y'know,
[01:20:34.04]
push for anything anymore,
in that respect, y'know?
[01:20:45.04]
If we can't see a light
at the end of the tunnel,
[01:20:47.09]
it makes it very difficult to proceed.
[01:20:52.09]
So, even if a person has a tragedy
[01:20:56.09]
or has prison time or something--
[01:21:00.01]
but they have a definite time--
[01:21:02.08]
they can look forward to
that, they can deal with it.
[01:21:05.08]
But this doesn't seem like it's gonna
[01:21:08.05]
work itself out any time soon, y'know?
[01:21:13.03]
It's just, y'know, so--
[01:21:16.09]
I don't know.
[01:21:18.06]
It's a real pain in the
neck, the whole thing.
[01:21:27.06]
Even if my particular
situation isn't fixed,
[01:21:31.05]
at least we can see one part of the puzzle
[01:21:34.03]
of what our direction is as a country.
[01:21:38.03]
Maybe we should do some
introspection, maybe, you know?
[01:21:44.08]
It's a lot bigger than just me.
[01:21:46.06]
I mean there are a lot of
worse things have happened
[01:21:49.02]
to a lot better people.
[01:21:52.07]
For myself, we're gonna just
settle down outside of America
[01:21:57.08]
and move on like that,
[01:22:02.01]
just to be reunited with my wife and kids,
[01:22:04.07]
keep my family together and
not end up in some divorce
[01:22:08.08]
or some irreparable emotional damage.
[01:22:14.02]
That's my ideal plan.
[01:22:21.06]
[sighing]
[01:22:29.06]
[crowd chatting]
[01:22:38.04]
- Which color's good for me?
[01:22:39.07]
What do you think?
[01:22:40.09]
Alright.
[01:22:45.03]
- No, actually that's like
my favorite color too.
[01:22:46.09]
Like teal-ish, teal-ish blue.
[01:22:49.06]
- No, I'm admiring you, yeah.
[01:22:51.02]
I'm admiring, yeah.
[01:23:03.05]
- Thank you very much.
[01:23:04.09]
- You're welcome.
[01:23:11.05]
- There we go.
[01:23:12.03]
- [Woman 1] Thank you.
[01:23:13.06]
- I feel like I have all
these sisters with me.
[01:23:16.05]
I don't have any sisters.
[01:23:18.06]
- [Woman] Today we're your sisters.
[01:23:22.00]
- She's gonna give me a sexy Turkish one.
[01:23:26.08]
If we're gonna do hijab
we might as well go sexy.
[01:23:29.09]
- You want it turban tied?
[01:23:30.09]
- Yeah, turban tied.
[01:23:33.04]
Whatever is sexier.
[01:23:35.01]
- Yeah, why not?
[01:23:37.09]
You like it?
[01:23:38.08]
- [Woman] It's nice to meet you.
[01:23:42.00]
[pensive instrumental music]
[01:23:48.01]
[crowd chatting]
[01:24:59.08]
[somber flute music]
[01:25:16.07]
[instrumental piano music]
[01:25:19.08]
Distributor: Bullfrog Films
Length: 88 minutes
Date: 2019
Genre: Expository
Language: English
Grade: 5 -12, College, Adult
Color/BW:
Closed Captioning: Available
Existing customers, please log in to view this film.
New to Docuseek? Register to request a quote.
Related Films
A personal essay revealing the passionate debates over identity and generational…
Spotlights people who escaped war, torture and persecution and introduces…