WEBVTT

00:00:15.626 --> 00:00:17.918
I think it is a Dostoyevsky quote, he said

00:00:17.959 --> 00:00:21.375
\"Perhaps it\'s beauty that
will save the earth.\"

00:00:34.501 --> 00:00:39.417
The sound of the whales is something
that can help us all just to feel

00:00:39.459 --> 00:00:43.209
this kind of community of beauty
that we\'re a part of.

00:00:44.417 --> 00:00:48.125
When I hear the whale and
respond with the cello,

00:00:48.167 --> 00:00:53.542
it\'s really just... it\'s about
the beauty of the sound.

00:00:56.501 --> 00:00:59.918
I know that there is some discussion,
some mystery about what the whales

00:00:59.959 --> 00:01:05.042
are actually trying to convey with these
extraordinary assortment of sounds that they make,

00:01:05.083 --> 00:01:08.709
but the other thing is to
simply relate to it as beauty.

00:01:11.250 --> 00:01:13.334
Ah, whales!

00:01:13.375 --> 00:01:19.334
The thing that drew me
to whales was I fell in love with whales.

00:01:20.042 --> 00:01:24.209
One would think of whales as a species
which was perhaps so large that it

00:01:24.250 --> 00:01:29.501
would be unaffected by almost anything that affects
the oceans, but that answer would be wrong.

00:01:29.542 --> 00:01:34.250
Their breeding cycle is deeply
affected by climate change.

00:01:34.292 --> 00:01:39.626
The effects on the females – the
conditions which destroy her food source

00:01:39.667 --> 00:01:42.667
causes her to not have a
calf in a given year.

00:01:51.918 --> 00:01:54.709
The whaling nations,
Japan, Norway, Iceland,

00:01:54.751 --> 00:02:01.042
all exploit loopholes in the so-called
moratorium which was created on whaling.

00:02:01.083 --> 00:02:06.334
It was zero quota and all these countries
are ignoring them for various reasons

00:02:06.375 --> 00:02:11.876
hey claim they\'re doing science, they claim they\'re
doing all sorts of things, but it\'s just nonsense.

00:02:11.918 --> 00:02:17.751
And so what I have watched is the
destruction of my life\'s work

00:02:17.792 --> 00:02:22.000
going on before my eyes, and
it\'s a horrible thing to see.

00:02:22.042 --> 00:02:24.792
But you can\'t talk
about it usually.

00:02:24.834 --> 00:02:30.959
Mainstream society doesn\'t want to
hear about our sorrow

00:02:31.000 --> 00:02:33.792
for what is happening to life on earth.

00:02:33.834 --> 00:02:39.250
That gets reduced right away
to some personal pathology.

00:02:39.292 --> 00:02:47.167
What a deliverance to realize that
that\'s not a private burden

00:02:47.250 --> 00:02:53.083
but a shared experience with
our brothers and sisters;

00:02:53.375 --> 00:02:59.667
that\'s what happens over and over again
in the work that reconnects.

00:03:01.334 --> 00:03:09.334
As we speak the truth of our pain for the world, we
discover our interconnectedness with each other.

00:03:12.000 --> 00:03:20.000
That comes forward when we read together from
the list of endangered and threatened species.

00:03:20.792 --> 00:03:26.042
Read them, just like…with a drumbeat:

00:03:28.042 --> 00:03:30.250
Polar Bear,

00:03:30.292 --> 00:03:33.375
Bengal Tiger,

00:03:33.417 --> 00:03:36.584
Swallowtail Butterfly,

00:03:36.626 --> 00:03:38.918
Wolf,

00:03:38.959 --> 00:03:41.667
Ferret,

00:03:41.709 --> 00:03:45.000
Harp Seal,

00:03:45.042 --> 00:03:48.042
African Elephant.

00:03:49.501 --> 00:03:57.042
To think of these species and wonder at their
strength and their beauty, their wisdom,

00:03:57.083 --> 00:04:01.876
their weirdness, their particularities.

00:04:02.542 --> 00:04:05.459
We are creatures here
just like all the others.

00:04:05.501 --> 00:04:10.667
We didn\'t create them and we have
no right to destroy them.

00:04:15.459 --> 00:04:20.626
We\'re losing species today at 1000 times the
rate that species do normally go extinct.

00:04:20.667 --> 00:04:26.000
We are killing off
the rest of the creation.

00:04:29.876 --> 00:04:35.042
As soon as you take a moral principle
like not harming life, really to heart,

00:04:35.083 --> 00:04:38.167
your eyes see the world in a different way.

00:04:38.209 --> 00:04:44.417
You\'re almost compelled to witness
the suffering as you see it.

00:04:44.876 --> 00:04:50.959
Now the hard part is actually being with
that suffering, not turning away from it.

00:04:51.000 --> 00:04:55.918
Not simply to judge it or dismiss
it or be angry about it,

00:04:55.959 --> 00:05:00.167
but to actually see it and in that seeing,

00:05:00.209 --> 00:05:04.209
the opportunities for action will arise.

00:05:04.250 --> 00:05:10.417
We can\'t all take care of all the problems in the
world, and we can\'t be in all places at once.

00:05:10.459 --> 00:05:16.751
So we can be most thoroughly
in the place where we are.

00:05:18.000 --> 00:05:21.459
If we will have the wisdom to survive,

00:05:21.501 --> 00:05:26.250
to stand like slow-growing
trees on a ruined place,

00:05:26.292 --> 00:05:29.083
renewing, enriching it,

00:05:29.125 --> 00:05:32.626
if we will make our seasons welcome here,

00:05:32.667 --> 00:05:36.792
asking not too much of earth or heaven,

00:05:36.834 --> 00:05:44.792
then a long time after we are dead the
lives our lives prepare will live there,

00:05:44.834 --> 00:05:49.209
their houses strongly
placed upon the valley sides,

00:05:49.250 --> 00:05:53.167
fields and gardens rich in the windows.

00:05:53.209 --> 00:05:57.834
The river will run clear,
as we will never know it,

00:05:57.876 --> 00:06:03.042
and over it, birdsong like a canopy.

00:06:03.083 --> 00:06:07.542
On the levels of the
hills will be green meadows,

00:06:07.584 --> 00:06:10.584
stock bells in noon shade.

00:06:24.000 --> 00:06:31.334
The thing that is at the heart of our daily
lives is the abundance of cheap fossil fuel.

00:06:31.375 --> 00:06:35.667
For 200 years it has defined what it
means to be a Western human being.

00:06:35.709 --> 00:06:38.876
Everything we do all
day relies on fossil fuel.

00:06:38.918 --> 00:06:40.542
It\'s what\'s made us rich.

00:06:40.584 --> 00:06:45.751
The problem is, that same
fossil fuel is now killing us.

00:06:45.792 --> 00:06:53.792
And so somehow, we have to get off of the thing that is
at the center of our daily lives before it does us in.

00:06:55.042 --> 00:07:01.334
That is a very, very difficult task, the most
difficult task that human beings have ever faced.

00:07:01.667 --> 00:07:05.792
I think that climate change -

00:07:05.834 --> 00:07:12.167
let\'s say 20 years ago, when we understood
that it was due to our burning fossil fuels

00:07:12.209 --> 00:07:20.209
and as well as our deforestation of forests, was
an unfortunate consequence of our industrialization.

00:07:20.667 --> 00:07:25.334
At that time there was no need for judgment
because people didn\'t realize

00:07:25.417 --> 00:07:28.417
that that could actually
change the atmosphere,

00:07:28.542 --> 00:07:34.459
which in turn could change the radiative
balance on the whole planet.

00:07:34.501 --> 00:07:36.375
But now we know.

00:07:36.417 --> 00:07:39.542
It is no longer just a consequence of
the Industrial Revolution.

00:07:39.584 --> 00:07:47.584
It is a crime against humanity and we need to
articulate and come up with a language for that crime.

00:07:48.250 --> 00:07:52.083
For most people the discussion about
climate change is kind of abstract.

00:07:52.125 --> 00:07:58.918
We\'re talking about how many parts per millions
of CO2, or how many degrees warming by what date.

00:07:58.959 --> 00:08:06.959
But really, this hits people in the form of vulnerability
to natural disasters, floods and fires and droughts.

00:08:10.042 --> 00:08:11.876
That has been happening
in places like Australia.

00:08:11.918 --> 00:08:14.542
It\'s happening in the Sahel in Africa.

00:08:14.584 --> 00:08:22.083
It\'s happening in regions where people are making a living
by dint of extraordinary labor and effort, just barely.

00:08:22.125 --> 00:08:29.792
And then this tiny, tiny change in expected amounts
of water comes and \"oh well\" it wipes you out,

00:08:29.834 --> 00:08:31.000
and that\'s what they\'re facing.

00:08:31.042 --> 00:08:35.417
And when you get wiped out, now you\'ve got to
move, you\'ve got to leave, but nobody wants you.

00:08:35.459 --> 00:08:40.626
You have these displaced populations of
people who, as their desperation increases,

00:08:40.667 --> 00:08:44.626
do exactly what you and I would do
if our desperation increased enough,

00:08:44.667 --> 00:08:50.250
which is they become, in their efforts
to find food, in some cases violent.

00:08:50.292 --> 00:08:57.083
And so that increase of violence is
a direct effect of global warming.

00:08:57.125 --> 00:09:01.792
It has been recognized by the US
military as the great future problem,

00:09:01.834 --> 00:09:05.918
which the United States security
forces will be facing–

00:09:05.959 --> 00:09:08.501
displaced hordes of people.

00:09:14.375 --> 00:09:18.250
One of the things that oceans create
for the world is glaciers,

00:09:18.292 --> 00:09:21.918
of course, because the evaporation of
water from the oceans goes up

00:09:22.042 --> 00:09:24.417
and falls as rain or snow
and in high mountains

00:09:24.667 --> 00:09:27.292
collects as ice and becomes glaciers

00:09:27.334 --> 00:09:31.501
which then as pure unsalted
water flow down to the sea.

00:09:31.542 --> 00:09:35.375
And then as global warming occurs, of
course, these glaciers are all melting,

00:09:35.417 --> 00:09:36.918
they\'re going away very fast -

00:09:36.959 --> 00:09:40.501
now you\'re talking about a
couple of human lifetimes.

00:09:44.209 --> 00:09:50.918
There are whole cities, to name a random example, Los
Angeles, which are utterly dependent on glaciers.

00:09:51.792 --> 00:09:58.709
There are a lot of people out there who say, once the
problem is sufficiently severe science will find a way.

00:09:58.751 --> 00:10:02.584
And the answer to that is baloney!

00:10:02.626 --> 00:10:06.667
Science will find a way, which if you
can afford it might work - sure.

00:10:06.709 --> 00:10:10.501
Let\'s put it this way, suppose
Los Angeles ran out of water.

00:10:10.542 --> 00:10:12.292
Solve that one.

00:10:12.334 --> 00:10:17.167
And the answer could be oh, well you put in a
desalination plant, a giant desalination plant.

00:10:17.209 --> 00:10:20.375
Yes, but what happens to the
price of water at that point?

00:10:20.417 --> 00:10:27.083
How much will you enjoy paying a dollar a gallon for
water just to wash your car, or water you lawn?

00:10:27.125 --> 00:10:31.751
Science will not solve the problem at
any sort of reasonable expense level

00:10:31.792 --> 00:10:37.459
to pay for things which are the services
that are performed free by the environment.

00:10:37.501 --> 00:10:41.042
Somebody has actually put a
price on that, has guessed at what it is.

00:10:41.083 --> 00:10:46.167
If I recall it correctly, I think it\'s the
free services performed by the environment

00:10:46.209 --> 00:10:52.167
for humankind worldwide come
to $30 trillion a year.

00:10:52.209 --> 00:10:53.209
Well, that\'s no problem.

00:10:53.250 --> 00:10:57.250
We\'ll just raise $30 trillion and perform
those services for ourselves. No!

00:11:01.250 --> 00:11:05.250
When CO2, carbon dioxide
dissolves in seawater,

00:11:05.292 --> 00:11:12.501
it turns into carbonic acid and that increases
the acidification or the acidity of the oceans.

00:11:12.542 --> 00:11:18.250
And that\'s going on big time, because of course there
is so much more carbon dioxide than there was before.

00:11:18.292 --> 00:11:23.167
And what that increase in acidity
does is an absolutely dreadful occurrence.

00:11:23.209 --> 00:11:28.542
You can show experimentally that that is going
to result in the inability of a huge number

00:11:28.584 --> 00:11:31.334
of species to actually lay down shells.

00:11:31.375 --> 00:11:32.792
They won\'t be able to do it anymore.

00:11:32.834 --> 00:11:35.334
And the result is they will die.

00:11:35.375 --> 00:11:39.626
If those species are plankton, these little
single cell things that nobody ever worries about

00:11:39.667 --> 00:11:45.876
but which are the absolute foundation of life
on earth, if that happens to them, that\'s it!

00:11:45.918 --> 00:11:53.334
These planktonic creatures are the base of every
oceanic food chain and all these oceanic food chains

00:11:53.375 --> 00:11:58.792
result in the species that we
eat most, and rely on most.

00:11:58.834 --> 00:12:06.459
A billion people - over a billion people in this world
have as their principle source of animal protein.

00:12:06.501 --> 00:12:11.375
If plankton go, nothing makes it out alive.

00:12:11.417 --> 00:12:13.584
And I fear that is exactly
what is happening.

00:12:13.626 --> 00:12:18.292
I also fear that you can just kiss goodbye
to the beauty of coral reefs.

00:12:18.334 --> 00:12:23.834
I don\'t think that is something that our great
grandchildren will see or know except in films.

00:12:23.876 --> 00:12:25.167
Is that important?

00:12:25.209 --> 00:12:27.501
Oh, yes it is very important!

00:12:27.542 --> 00:12:35.459
These coral reefs are structures
which support whole island nations.

00:12:35.501 --> 00:12:39.459
If you remove the protection that the
island has from massive ocean waves

00:12:39.501 --> 00:12:43.667
then the result of that
is the island goes away also.

00:12:51.042 --> 00:12:55.792
If you lose coral reef completely, you lose
all the species which depend on coral reefs,

00:12:55.834 --> 00:12:59.125
and there are a huge number of them,
most of them are extremely beautiful.

00:12:59.167 --> 00:13:01.667
So you\'ll lose a lot of beauty.

00:13:03.292 --> 00:13:07.209
This problemwould be hard enough
were it confined to one nation,

00:13:07.292 --> 00:13:10.626
ours, because the power of
the fossil fuel industry

00:13:10.709 --> 00:13:15.125
is enough to make it very
difficult to get change to happen here.

00:13:15.167 --> 00:13:18.042
It is made infinitely more complex by
the fact that it is the first global scale

00:13:18.083 --> 00:13:25.667
problem and we need to involve the entire globe,
and much of that globe, most of it is poor.

00:13:25.709 --> 00:13:31.751
Our deep economic inequality which has always been
a sin, is now an enormous practical impediment

00:13:31.792 --> 00:13:39.042
to getting action because China, India,
and the rest, the easiest path for them

00:13:39.083 --> 00:13:45.626
to pull people out of poverty is to do it the the
way we did it: burn lots and lots of cheap coal.

00:13:45.667 --> 00:13:50.250
If they do that, there\'s no hope of
dealing with the global warming crisis.

00:13:50.292 --> 00:13:52.459
It will just overwhelm us.

00:13:52.792 --> 00:13:59.083
We have to figure out some way to allow China and
India and the rest to forgo that coal burning

00:13:59.125 --> 00:14:04.959
and develop anyway and that\'s going to take
some serious help from the rich world

00:14:05.000 --> 00:14:11.709
in the form of technology and resources
to allow that leap-frogging to happen.

00:14:11.751 --> 00:14:14.834
We will find out if we are
generous enough to do that or not.

00:14:14.876 --> 00:14:22.792
It\'s all a question of pace, whether we can make the politics
change as fast as the physics and chemistry are changing.

00:14:23.459 --> 00:14:28.959
I am always well aware that the world around
us is not going to be any more beautiful

00:14:29.000 --> 00:14:35.459
or intact than it is right now, so I do
everything I can to take great pleasure in it.

00:14:35.501 --> 00:14:41.167
One of our jobs is clearly to bear witness
to the beautiful world that we were given,

00:14:41.209 --> 00:14:47.918
and to understand that it\'s never going to be quite
this glorious again so we better pay attention.

00:14:47.959 --> 00:14:49.959
And I do.

00:14:54.918 --> 00:14:57.292
Dear darkening ground,

00:14:57.334 --> 00:15:02.209
You\'ve endured so patiently the
walls we\'ve built,

00:15:02.250 --> 00:15:06.292
perhaps you\'ll give the
cities one more hour

00:15:06.334 --> 00:15:09.959
and the churches and cloisters two.

00:15:10.000 --> 00:15:16.334
And those that labor — you\'ll let their
work still grip them for another five hours

00:15:16.375 --> 00:15:22.959
or seven, before you become forest again,
and water, and wilderness

00:15:23.000 --> 00:15:28.709
in that hour of inconceivable terror when
you take back your name from all things.

00:15:30.667 --> 00:15:33.709
Oh just give me a little more time!

00:15:34.584 --> 00:15:37.250
I just want a little more time.

00:15:37.292 --> 00:15:41.542
Because I\'m going to love the things

00:15:41.584 --> 00:15:46.209
I\'m going to love the things as no one
has thought to love them.

00:15:47.709 --> 00:15:52.709
We are effectively killing ourselves,
killing the ground of our own being.

00:15:52.751 --> 00:16:00.751
The antidote to that, I believe is to get
back in touch with our own deep, primary,

00:16:01.375 --> 00:16:07.584
fundamental connection with what
it is that makes us living beings.

00:16:07.626 --> 00:16:15.417
Some people access that through meditation,
other people do it through long walks.

00:16:15.459 --> 00:16:18.083
People ask me all the time,
with the kind of writing I do,

00:16:18.125 --> 00:16:25.542
how I stay relatively sane to
the extent that I do and hopeful and so on.

00:16:25.584 --> 00:16:27.167
A lot of it has to do with music.

00:16:27.209 --> 00:16:28.709
I play the violin,

00:16:28.751 --> 00:16:30.709
I\'ve played the violin since I was a child.

00:16:30.751 --> 00:16:32.834
I play 90 minutes a day.

00:16:32.876 --> 00:16:34.167
It\'s nothing profound.

00:16:34.209 --> 00:16:38.834
I\'ll never be a professional violinist,
but it feeds me in a certain way,

00:16:38.876 --> 00:16:41.292
and especially when I am
playing with other musicians.

00:16:41.334 --> 00:16:43.542
That\'s the payoff.

00:16:49.250 --> 00:16:55.209
I don\'t think that scientists can
change the world, or save it.

00:16:55.250 --> 00:17:00.501
I don\'t think the world can be saved without paying
attention to what the scientists have to say.

00:17:00.542 --> 00:17:04.542
But I think the people who can
save the world are artists.

00:17:04.584 --> 00:17:10.000
That\'s because what we need, really, is
a new story that we tell ourselves.

00:17:10.042 --> 00:17:12.375
At the present time, the story
we tell ourselves is that

00:17:12.417 --> 00:17:17.626
the earth was made for us, and it\'s for us
to exploit it in any way we like.

00:17:17.667 --> 00:17:22.459
But I think the people who can make a new
story about what we are here for,

00:17:22.501 --> 00:17:28.667
that\'s people who are not scientists, who
are storytellers, who are mythmakers.

00:17:28.709 --> 00:17:32.334
I am all for them and all
for what they can achieve.

00:17:32.667 --> 00:17:34.876
…in the middle of dinner, and she said

00:17:35.167 --> 00:17:38.125
\"You!
You\'re so brave!

00:17:38.167 --> 00:17:41.918
But why didn\'t you ask what ails thee?

00:17:41.959 --> 00:17:43.876
Were you afraid to ask?\"

00:17:45.042 --> 00:17:48.375
And Percival, who was a brave knight,

00:17:48.542 --> 00:17:51.375
and he didn\'t think a witch
should speak to him that way…

00:17:51.501 --> 00:17:57.292
It is such an incredible
gift to have children,

00:17:57.334 --> 00:18:01.292
whether they\'re our own children or whether
they\'re other people\'s children.

00:18:01.334 --> 00:18:08.083
But to be around children, I feel less
optimistic about our own generation

00:18:08.125 --> 00:18:13.000
and more optimistic about the
generations coming behind us,

00:18:13.042 --> 00:18:18.209
because when I look at the four and
five-year-olds that come to this church,

00:18:18.250 --> 00:18:23.918
and I love to gather them around after
church and invite them to ring the bell.

00:18:23.959 --> 00:18:30.334
And they love to go flying to the ceiling
on the weight of the bell on the rope,

00:18:30.375 --> 00:18:32.751
and in that joy,
in that happiness,

00:18:32.792 --> 00:18:40.209
there seems to me to be the seeds of contentment
and being satisfied with simple things.

00:18:40.250 --> 00:18:44.584
And that it doesn\'t take
that much to be happy.

00:18:51.042 --> 00:18:59.042
I feel deep grief at the kind of devastation and
the kind of dying that is occurring around us.

00:18:59.209 --> 00:19:04.167
And we have to grieve and then we have
to look to the children and say,

00:19:04.209 --> 00:19:10.042
how can we make your life fuller and
richer and simpler and more happy?

00:19:10.083 --> 00:19:14.667
And in doing that I
find my highest calling.

00:19:22.751 --> 00:19:26.501
It\'s really a terrific honor to have helped
bring this group of people together.

00:19:26.584 --> 00:19:27.918
Thanks so much for being here.

00:19:28.000 --> 00:19:29.751
Ecosocialist Horizons is…

00:19:29.834 --> 00:19:32.334
I think, increasingly, the
young ones are getting it,

00:19:32.375 --> 00:19:37.542
they are getting to see where unmoderated
capitalism has taken us.

00:19:37.584 --> 00:19:40.459
Money rules’ is probably the
most simple way to explain it.

00:19:40.501 --> 00:19:45.501
Money becomes the means
through which everything is evaluated.

00:19:45.542 --> 00:19:48.209
You see this in the climate
change debates right now,

00:19:48.250 --> 00:19:56.250
that people are suggesting, for instance, that in order
to keep the air free of pollution we should privatize it,

00:19:56.918 --> 00:20:02.167
and if somebody were to own it then they would
be able to measure the cost of pollution.

00:20:02.209 --> 00:20:05.751
So this is the length that this
system has led us to, that

00:20:05.792 --> 00:20:10.834
we are talking about selling
the air we breathe.

00:20:10.876 --> 00:20:15.667
I don\'t think it\'s a done deal that humanity
is going to survive to the year 3000,

00:20:15.709 --> 00:20:18.125
in terms of my understanding
of climate science.

00:20:18.167 --> 00:20:21.209
We are at stage right now where we are trying to
figure out how to take power away from the people

00:20:21.250 --> 00:20:27.417
who are going to run the planet into the ground, that
want to suck every penny out of this dying system.

00:20:27.459 --> 00:20:30.709
Consumer culture is so pervasive and
I think it really prevents people

00:20:30.751 --> 00:20:33.626
from seeing alternatives or other ways.

00:20:33.667 --> 00:20:35.709
I mean it\'s so huge.

00:20:35.751 --> 00:20:39.417
You walk anywhere around where I
live and you\'re bombarded

00:20:39.459 --> 00:20:42.459
with images of what you\'re
supposed to look like.

00:20:42.501 --> 00:20:44.584
Or act like or sound like.

00:20:44.626 --> 00:20:50.542
And it\'s all fake and it\'s highly
impossible for most people.

00:20:50.584 --> 00:20:56.667
For five years I was an organizer in West
Virginia fighting mountain top removal.

00:20:56.709 --> 00:21:03.000
And I believe these choices that young people are
making will make a huge impact on climate change.

00:21:03.042 --> 00:21:04.751
Will it be in time?

00:21:04.792 --> 00:21:10.250
I feel like I don\'t ask myself that
question as often as I used to.

00:21:10.292 --> 00:21:13.667
I certainly appreciate those who do.

00:21:13.709 --> 00:21:18.209
But just now, in this time,
I want to keep my head down

00:21:18.250 --> 00:21:20.959
and do the work of supporting
these young people who, I think,

00:21:21.000 --> 00:21:25.584
are going to bring us
around as quickly as it an be done.

00:21:25.626 --> 00:21:28.417
I don\'t know exactly
what my life will hold.

00:21:28.459 --> 00:21:33.751
I\'m going to do as much as I can,
not only because that\'s what\'s necessary,

00:21:33.792 --> 00:21:36.584
because that\'s what\'s most fun.

00:21:48.918 --> 00:21:52.667
The Exxon CEO made plain the
reason for his unwillingness

00:21:52.709 --> 00:21:56.584
to change in the second interview
a few weeks ago with Charlie Rose,

00:21:56.626 --> 00:21:58.834
who asked him his philosophy.

00:21:58.876 --> 00:22:05.083
He just looked at the camera and
said \"my philosophy is to make money.\"

00:22:05.125 --> 00:22:09.083
That\'s an apt summation of
too much of our society,

00:22:09.125 --> 00:22:13.042
but here in this place, we have to
stand in some counterpoint.

00:22:13.083 --> 00:22:16.083
Our goal must be to make real the gospel,

00:22:16.125 --> 00:22:20.626
with its injunction to love our
neighbors, not to drown them...

00:22:20.667 --> 00:22:28.667
those who think of ourselves as Christians
are called on not only in the Old Testament

00:22:29.876 --> 00:22:36.334
to defend creation and steward it wisely,
something that we are clearly failing to do.

00:22:36.375 --> 00:22:44.167
We are also called upon over and over again in
the Gospels to love our neighbor as ourselves.

00:22:44.209 --> 00:22:45.167
We\'re failing there, too.

00:22:45.209 --> 00:22:49.876
At the moment we are drowning our neighbors,
giving them mosquito borne diseases,

00:22:49.918 --> 00:22:54.584
destroying the chances for them to grow their
crops, making life all but unbearable.

00:22:54.626 --> 00:22:59.417
And we are doing that so we can keep
on living exactly as we are living.

00:22:59.459 --> 00:23:02.626
We see the impacts of it on a daily basis.

00:23:02.667 --> 00:23:06.167
Longer summers, hotter summers,

00:23:06.209 --> 00:23:11.459
the rain is later and when the rain
comes it is also much more.

00:23:11.501 --> 00:23:17.876
I just feel that it is unfair that people in the
global south have to make all these adaptations

00:23:17.918 --> 00:23:23.417
when the root of
the problem is in the north.

00:23:23.459 --> 00:23:30.250
The way we experience the developed world\'s
impact on local communities is around seed.

00:23:31.417 --> 00:23:35.375
Historically, we were
colonized in different forms.

00:23:35.417 --> 00:23:37.501
Slavery was one.

00:23:37.542 --> 00:23:39.751
Education was one.

00:23:39.792 --> 00:23:43.584
But now the corporations,

00:23:43.626 --> 00:23:50.083
Monsanto and other allies,
giants, are also colonizing Africa

00:23:50.125 --> 00:23:53.250
and all of us through
food, through seed.

00:23:53.292 --> 00:24:00.959
The Monsanto seed is not only seeds,
it\'s a seed with a technology of herbicide,

00:24:01.000 --> 00:24:04.250
with a technology of insecticides.

00:24:04.292 --> 00:24:07.292
And these seeds,
you can only plant it once.

00:24:07.334 --> 00:24:12.250
You can plant it a second time but the
yields get lower and lower.

00:24:12.292 --> 00:24:15.209
When you plant it for the
third time, there\'s no crop.

00:24:15.250 --> 00:24:18.542
So we\'re saying, \"No!, No!\"

00:24:18.584 --> 00:24:21.417
These seeds, from outside the country,

00:24:21.459 --> 00:24:25.209
through the government system,
they\'re pushing the GMOs,

00:24:25.250 --> 00:24:28.501
taking away the seeds of the people.

00:24:28.542 --> 00:24:32.501
And that is creating a lot of
pain and bad feeling,

00:24:32.542 --> 00:24:36.209
especially to indigenous people who know,

00:24:36.250 --> 00:24:39.250
who have been keeping seed a long time.

00:25:00.334 --> 00:25:05.751
Climate Change is being used as an excuse
and false solutions are being put forward

00:25:05.792 --> 00:25:12.459
so that the profit motive could
be advanced and could continue.

00:25:12.501 --> 00:25:14.125
I am worried about that.

00:25:14.167 --> 00:25:16.501
I am worried about what it will
mean for my people

00:25:16.542 --> 00:25:21.542
and what it will mean for other
people in the global south.

00:25:21.584 --> 00:25:25.584
It is the responsibility of women to
do the majority of the farm work –

00:25:25.626 --> 00:25:29.834
more than 50% of our food is grown by women
farmers and in many parts of the world,

00:25:29.876 --> 00:25:33.000
women are not even recognized as farmers.

00:25:33.751 --> 00:25:35.626
Women are the water stewards.

00:25:35.667 --> 00:25:36.959
They are the seed custodians.

00:25:37.000 --> 00:25:39.334
They are the energy
managers of the families.

00:25:39.375 --> 00:25:41.417
They look after the livestock,

00:25:41.459 --> 00:25:47.083
they are the life force behind the
health and vitality of any community.

00:25:48.000 --> 00:25:52.542
And yet, 70% of the world\'s
poor are women and girls.

00:25:57.626 --> 00:26:03.000
There is so little recognition that is
paid to their immense body of knowledge:

00:26:03.042 --> 00:26:06.083
How to farm organically, how
to make natural pesticides,

00:26:06.125 --> 00:26:08.209
how to make natural fertilizers,

00:26:08.250 --> 00:26:12.459
how to save seeds which are the
drought resistant millets

00:26:12.501 --> 00:26:16.542
which can survive a particularly
lean drought period.

00:26:16.751 --> 00:26:19.709
That knowledge lies in the
hands of women farmers.

00:26:47.167 --> 00:26:51.834
Via Campesina is a wonderful example of a
movement that is happening at the global level,

00:26:51.876 --> 00:26:57.792
it is a movement of indigenous people;
fisher folks, livestock managers,

00:26:57.834 --> 00:27:05.417
small farmers who are coming together to recognize
that the current growth paradigm is not working.

00:27:05.501 --> 00:27:13.167
It\'s a system of accumulation and acquirement of
those who are already in privileged positions.

00:27:13.209 --> 00:27:18.083
We\'re going to have to change that
system that we are working in.

00:27:18.125 --> 00:27:23.459
We really have a badly failing
democracy in our country.

00:27:23.501 --> 00:27:27.459
It\'s very close to rule by
money and corporations.

00:27:27.501 --> 00:27:33.667
We\'ve known for a long time that the principle
economics actors were corporations.

00:27:33.709 --> 00:27:38.667
But, now we are seeing that the principle
political actors in our system are corporations.

00:27:38.709 --> 00:27:43.542
We need to rethink why we
really have economic activity.

00:27:43.584 --> 00:27:48.292
We\'ve had a tremendous amount of growth as
a result of this system that we\'ve had,

00:27:48.334 --> 00:27:55.209
but wages have not risen, the
environment has gone steadily downhill,

00:27:55.250 --> 00:28:01.250
life satisfaction and happiness in the
country for decades now has been flat-lined.

00:28:01.292 --> 00:28:03.876
Poverty is at a 50 year high.

00:28:03.918 --> 00:28:10.792
Now we find ourselves with no real choice but to act
drastically if we are going to stave off those things,

00:28:10.834 --> 00:28:18.501
and yet we have these really pathetic political
leaders that have so totally dropped the ball,

00:28:18.542 --> 00:28:20.876
not just dropped the ball but hidden it.

00:28:20.918 --> 00:28:24.751
And we live in a very strange place
where in order to save the planet

00:28:24.792 --> 00:28:30.501
the environmentalists and others have to show
that it\'s not going to hurt the economy.

00:28:30.542 --> 00:28:34.083
Can you imagine that is
the place where we are?

00:28:34.125 --> 00:28:38.375
And the terrible thing about the capitalist
mentality is that it can\'t be satisfied.

00:28:38.417 --> 00:28:45.459
The everlasting competition, the everlasting
search for profit is going to pull with it nature,

00:28:45.501 --> 00:28:53.501
and it\'s going to over rule the wisdom that we see
in nature our true foundation, our true being.

00:28:55.292 --> 00:28:58.709
We have what\'s going on in Canada,
the Alberta Tar Sands,

00:28:58.751 --> 00:29:01.918
just tearing up, the size of Connecticut.

00:29:01.959 --> 00:29:08.501
This beautiful province in Canada, destroying
the earth, wasting incredible amounts of water,

00:29:08.542 --> 00:29:15.167
producing this filthy oil, going deep into
the Gulf of Mexico, that horrible oil spill.

00:29:21.751 --> 00:29:24.751
They\'re tearing off the tops of mountains.

00:29:31.125 --> 00:29:37.417
These things are multiplied endlessly around the world
because they\'re driven by these titanic forces,

00:29:38.125 --> 00:29:42.792
when it becomes not just an individual
decision, but the entire civilization

00:29:42.834 --> 00:29:46.292
in the grip of this insanity
to expand at all costs.

00:29:46.334 --> 00:29:49.000
At all costs, the cost
is our own destruction.

00:29:49.042 --> 00:29:51.626
Economic growth is something
pretty recent in human history.

00:29:51.667 --> 00:29:57.459
It has just been going on for a few decades and
mostly as a result of having cheap, abundant,

00:29:57.501 --> 00:30:01.667
concentrated fossil fuels to make
the engine of industry turn.

00:30:01.709 --> 00:30:08.000
But we\'ve internalized that idea
that economies should always grow,

00:30:08.042 --> 00:30:09.751
when, in fact, it is an absurdity.

00:30:09.792 --> 00:30:12.667
Nothing grows forever on a finite planet.

00:30:12.709 --> 00:30:20.709
The industrial growth model flaws are
becoming more and more painfully obvious,

00:30:20.834 --> 00:30:23.000
so that\'s probably a good thing.

00:30:23.042 --> 00:30:28.042
But in the meantime it\'s a lot of
suffering to witness.

00:30:28.083 --> 00:30:35.792
There will be some showdowns around
energy and they could be quite ugly.

00:30:35.834 --> 00:30:41.959
We could go to more wars, we could have more of
a fascist state to protect our energy reserves.

00:30:42.000 --> 00:30:49.042
I don\'t know if we\'ll go that way, but we are not going
to give up the industrial growth model very easily.

00:30:49.083 --> 00:30:55.876
There\'s a lot invested in it, and it is in the
profit structure of the largest companies.

00:30:55.918 --> 00:31:01.083
The industrial growth society
is destroying itself.

00:31:01.125 --> 00:31:08.167
I don\'t see the call being for us to go and
attack it and muster all its defenses,

00:31:08.209 --> 00:31:15.334
but to help it come apart,
to assist its disintegration.

00:31:15.375 --> 00:31:20.792
We have to build new and let emerge new
sustainable ways of doing things,

00:31:20.834 --> 00:31:24.209
building the new
within the shell of the old.

00:31:24.250 --> 00:31:32.250
Don\'t pour all your energy into defeating
what\'s already defeating itself at the core.

00:31:33.250 --> 00:31:38.584
But build living economies,
living ways of producing food,

00:31:38.626 --> 00:31:43.334
Basic changes in our judicial system,
restorative circles,

00:31:43.375 --> 00:31:50.709
basic changes in how we understand and
measure our wealth and prosperity.

00:31:51.209 --> 00:31:56.209
The biggest changes we\'ve see in
thousands of years, I think.

00:31:58.667 --> 00:32:04.292
And it needs all of us, or as many of
us who will show up.

00:32:10.667 --> 00:32:13.125
I don\'t think Occupy has fizzled.

00:32:13.167 --> 00:32:18.834
The visible presence of occupations in
public spaces may have dissipated,

00:32:18.876 --> 00:32:24.709
but that energy has continued and
kind of gone underground, or gone quieter.

00:32:24.751 --> 00:32:31.626
\"Occupy\" has gone super local and that\'s really big
because that\'s where people are most passionate.

00:32:31.667 --> 00:32:34.501
And I also think that the
fight for public space isn\'t over

00:32:34.542 --> 00:32:40.709
and we are going to see a
resurgence of the public reclaiming space.

00:32:40.751 --> 00:32:44.542
We are only here because we
supposedly broke the law.

00:32:44.584 --> 00:32:46.918
And one of our colleagues always says,

00:32:46.959 --> 00:32:49.626
\"If it\'s the right thing to do, you
have every right to do it.\"

00:32:49.667 --> 00:32:55.876
And we planted \"illegally\" on land which
we believe is meant for the public

00:32:55.918 --> 00:33:00.626
because it is administered by a public
institution and if we adhered to the law,

00:33:00.667 --> 00:33:03.292
we wouldn\'t be here

00:33:05.667 --> 00:33:08.209
and we wouldn\'t have this
amazing community of people

00:33:08.250 --> 00:33:12.042
that are so excited to come here every
week and harvest vegetables

00:33:12.083 --> 00:33:15.250
and to fight for public access.

00:33:15.292 --> 00:33:19.667
Because this is situated in an urban area
this could be accessible to so many people

00:33:19.709 --> 00:33:22.959
from many different
socioeconomic backgrounds.

00:33:23.250 --> 00:33:28.918
So we envision the whole 14 acres would become
a center for sustainable urban agriculture

00:33:28.959 --> 00:33:32.459
and would be driven by the community.

00:33:32.501 --> 00:33:34.709
I can\'t see what\'s going on behind me
right now but I am betting

00:33:34.751 --> 00:33:37.792
that there are groups of people congregating
together and laughing and smiling

00:33:37.834 --> 00:33:45.250
and crouching down over tomatoes and herbs and
it\'s just a wonderful feeling of community.

00:33:45.292 --> 00:33:51.000
I feel that fighting for public space is one of the
most crucial things that we can be doing right now.

00:33:51.042 --> 00:33:53.167
And it is not time to sit back and say,

00:33:53.209 --> 00:33:55.918
\"Well, I\'m going to vote for the
lesser of two evils because

00:33:55.959 --> 00:33:58.542
that\'s just the way it is right now
and let\'s be realistic.\"

00:33:58.584 --> 00:34:04.334
I\'m sorry, but if the civil rights movement was
realistic, if the women\'s rights movement was realistic,

00:34:04.375 --> 00:34:06.167
we wouldn\'t be here.

00:34:07.375 --> 00:34:11.834
I just think it is the time to move beyond
realistic and dream and be really bold.

00:34:17.584 --> 00:34:23.334
Mother Earth, Father Sky, and
Brother River, and the animals,

00:34:23.375 --> 00:34:29.209
they all have feelings and they listen
to what we say and they feel what we do.

00:34:29.250 --> 00:34:36.834
My people, the elders, also believe that
all these environmental catastrophes

00:34:36.876 --> 00:34:42.626
that happen to the communities around the
world, those are all cries for help.

00:34:42.667 --> 00:34:46.292
Mother Earth is crying out for help.

00:34:46.334 --> 00:34:51.667
We are killing her so
people can make a profit.

00:34:51.709 --> 00:34:57.292
The scarcity of water is
becoming more and more evident.

00:34:57.334 --> 00:35:03.501
My own family has to haul water 30 miles
one way for ourselves, for cooking,

00:35:03.542 --> 00:35:08.000
for livestock and to water crops.

00:35:11.167 --> 00:35:17.375
Senator John McCain wanted to buy the
water rights to the Little Colorado River

00:35:17.417 --> 00:35:21.876
so they could pump it to Phoenix
and all the other urban cities

00:35:21.918 --> 00:35:26.167
so they could grow
their lawns and their golf courses.

00:35:26.209 --> 00:35:30.834
They were basically saying, “We are going
to build three mainline water pipelines-

00:35:30.876 --> 00:35:32.250
two to the Navajo
Nation, one to the Hopi Nation,

00:35:32.292 --> 00:35:38.250
in exchange for us waving all our claims
to the lower Colorado River.

00:35:38.292 --> 00:35:45.501
So we\'d be giving up all our surface water for
two water pipelines, two water pipelines!

00:35:45.542 --> 00:35:50.417
There\'s 110 communities on Navajo
Nation so that to me already sounds

00:35:50.459 --> 00:35:57.042
like a bad deal and they were just main
stem water infrastructures, too.

00:35:57.083 --> 00:36:00.709
It\'s not like people could
turn on their faucets.

00:36:02.667 --> 00:36:05.501
We just started mobilizing and
campaigning on the issue.

00:36:05.542 --> 00:36:08.584
We did all these educational forums.

00:36:08.626 --> 00:36:11.667
We were really raising a ruckus about it.

00:36:11.709 --> 00:36:16.125
So then John McCain came to
Tuba City to the reservation.

00:36:16.167 --> 00:36:20.334
People are just booing him, and he\'s smiling
and waving like they are cheering him,

00:36:20.375 --> 00:36:25.417
totally oblivious to what\'s
going on, or totally in denial.

00:36:25.459 --> 00:36:27.459
We fought it and we won.

00:36:27.501 --> 00:36:28.542
We won it!

00:36:28.584 --> 00:36:32.292
The Navajo Nation council voted it down.

00:36:34.334 --> 00:36:40.083
I do feel bad for people who are used
to living on easy street in Phoenix,

00:36:40.125 --> 00:36:41.542
the same with Los Angeles.

00:36:41.584 --> 00:36:43.918
Los Angeles is in a desert too.

00:36:43.959 --> 00:36:49.417
I don\'t think people wonder where does all
their water come from for them to live there?

00:36:49.459 --> 00:36:53.292
But I think climate change is going
to force people to think about it

00:36:53.334 --> 00:36:58.417
and force people to start to
live within their limits.

00:36:58.459 --> 00:37:03.542
I think I was taught a lesson, too in this
whole water rights settlement campaign,

00:37:03.584 --> 00:37:09.042
because when you talk to elders, they are
kind of telling us stories about that, too,

00:37:09.083 --> 00:37:11.542
like we don\'t own the water either.

00:37:11.584 --> 00:37:18.459
Actually they said that who owns the water
when it reaches the land is the frog.

00:37:20.584 --> 00:37:24.292
For Navajo people - we are beginning to
feel the impact of climate change.

00:37:24.334 --> 00:37:30.083
It\'s already dry as it is, some of the
predictions is that it\'s going to get drier,

00:37:30.125 --> 00:37:33.000
we might go into a permanent drought.

00:37:33.042 --> 00:37:39.667
We\'ve released this energy force of carbon –
how does that interact with the energy forces

00:37:39.709 --> 00:37:46.918
up in the skies, you know, the sky in
all its wonders has energy forces.

00:37:46.959 --> 00:37:53.918
When we pollute or when we disrupt that
natural force by our action,

00:37:53.959 --> 00:38:01.334
it creates an imbalance within that element,
within the universe, and also within ourselves.

00:38:01.375 --> 00:38:07.083
So, that\'s where we have medicine people that understand
and know how to bring these things back to balance

00:38:07.125 --> 00:38:13.667
within ourselves as an individual person and
how to restore that balance back within us.

00:38:13.709 --> 00:38:19.375
I feel this really deep sense
of connection to my people.

00:38:19.417 --> 00:38:21.334
I pray to Mother Earth.

00:38:21.375 --> 00:38:27.125
I pray to the holy people, the spirit
people, who come out early in the morning

00:38:27.167 --> 00:38:30.709
and look for us to
see if we are awake.

00:38:30.751 --> 00:38:34.417
I also pray to all the sacred
mountains of the Navajo.

00:38:35.125 --> 00:38:43.125
It\'s time for us to be allies where people are speaking
different kinds of truth, like indigenous people.

00:38:44.000 --> 00:38:51.751
I am a small piece of a very large web and the energy
that moves through me also moves through this mountain.

00:38:51.792 --> 00:38:54.125
So I am related to the mountain.

00:38:54.167 --> 00:38:58.209
This deep view of life has sometimes
been called systems thinking.

00:38:58.250 --> 00:39:06.250
I find that not poetic enough so I like deep view, and
the metaphor I think of are Chinese scroll paintings.

00:39:07.042 --> 00:39:11.417
When you look at those fascinating
paintings that unroll and go on forever,

00:39:11.459 --> 00:39:14.334
there are always the little tiny
people down in front with their fish carts

00:39:14.375 --> 00:39:18.292
or their children or whatever,
that is the near view.

00:39:18.334 --> 00:39:22.417
And then there are the distant mountains
that you see rolling along,

00:39:22.459 --> 00:39:26.751
or the river, that give you
the kind of landscape view.

00:39:26.792 --> 00:39:32.459
But then the real art of Chinese painting is
what you can\'t literally see on the screen.

00:39:32.501 --> 00:39:38.000
It is not painted, but the painter leads
your eye up into the mountains

00:39:38.042 --> 00:39:43.000
so that you feel quite certain that there is a
path that goes over the mountain somewhere else,

00:39:43.042 --> 00:39:45.876
even though it is not literally there.

00:39:45.918 --> 00:39:50.501
And that invites your mind to
the deep view of landscape.

00:39:51.542 --> 00:39:57.375
What I can\'t see is in the realm of the
imagination and it is open to possibility.

00:39:57.417 --> 00:40:02.709
It might be a disaster zone or it
might be a zone of creativity.

00:40:02.751 --> 00:40:04.501
What\'s on the other side of that mountain?

00:40:04.542 --> 00:40:06.292
We don\'t know.

00:40:06.334 --> 00:40:13.417
We don\'t know which people are finding each
other and putting together some new solar oven.

00:40:13.459 --> 00:40:18.626
We don\'t know which landscapes are
healing even without human intervention.

00:40:18.667 --> 00:40:22.501
But that terrain of the
imagination is infinite.

00:40:22.542 --> 00:40:25.292
It has all possibility in it.

00:40:25.334 --> 00:40:30.542
The person who acts with an awareness that
their actions are always in a web of relations

00:40:30.584 --> 00:40:37.209
behaves much differently than someone who
sees themselves at the center all the time.

00:40:37.250 --> 00:40:41.417
The whole system is held
together by interdependency.

00:40:41.459 --> 00:40:46.542
And that’s how you get sustainability, is you recognize
the importance, not just of your own species,

00:40:46.584 --> 00:40:51.292
but of the world at large, of
the rest of life on earth.

00:40:51.334 --> 00:40:52.626
We\'re just another pretty face.

00:40:52.667 --> 00:40:57.709
We\'re not the star of the show, and, in fact,
until we recognize that, there will be no show.

00:40:57.751 --> 00:40:58.959
The show will be over.

00:40:59.751 --> 00:41:06.375
People who are practicing permaculture, for example,
they are becoming aware of this interdependency.

00:41:06.417 --> 00:41:09.792
That\'s one of the things
that\'s so surprising and exciting.

00:41:09.834 --> 00:41:12.709
Wherever you walk,
there\'s new food coming at you.

00:41:12.751 --> 00:41:18.834
I think of \"permaculture\" as simply
regeneration, a force for regeneration.

00:41:18.876 --> 00:41:24.959
Permaculture comes from the words \"permanent culture,\"
permanent agriculture and permanent culture.

00:41:25.000 --> 00:41:28.292
But the idea is simply that the
human presence is beneficial.

00:41:28.334 --> 00:41:32.000
We\'re not trying to ignore our presence
in the system or minimize our impact,

00:41:32.042 --> 00:41:38.125
but actually make intentional eco-systems,
intentional ecologies.

00:41:38.167 --> 00:41:43.042
We have to create these systems before
we truly do need them.

00:41:43.083 --> 00:41:47.042
We have to look forward and adapt to conditions
before those conditions are dire enough

00:41:47.083 --> 00:41:52.083
that we are just forced to
do that in an emergency,

00:41:52.125 --> 00:41:57.125
Forced to depend on food that is grown in our
region or fuel that is produced in our region.

00:41:57.167 --> 00:42:03.334
The core of the challenge in my mind is how
do we act adaptively before we are forced to?

00:42:03.375 --> 00:42:09.876
Working for food versus working for money
is such a balancing act in this transition.

00:42:09.918 --> 00:42:16.209
We\'ll all be spending a lot more time working
for our food, directly, but right now,

00:42:16.250 --> 00:42:24.250
still working for money, maybe half the time and it\'s
a little bit of a balancing act in the transition

00:42:25.876 --> 00:42:31.250
It\'s kind of a transitional art we all have
to get good at I suppose.

00:42:31.292 --> 00:42:37.501
We are going to a world of where Vermont\'s climate
might be like West Virginia\'s in 50 years.

00:42:37.542 --> 00:42:39.083
What\'s that look like?

00:42:39.125 --> 00:42:40.542
What species do we need?

00:42:40.584 --> 00:42:44.751
We should start looking south to see what\'s
useful to grow in those regions right now.

00:42:44.792 --> 00:42:49.709
We say, all right we want peaches, we want a
peach tree, but if we just plant a peach,

00:42:49.751 --> 00:42:53.083
and don\'t deal with any other species,
we have to bring in everything it needs.

00:42:53.125 --> 00:42:58.334
We have to bring in its fertility, we have to manage
all the pests because it\'s a thing in isolation.

00:42:58.375 --> 00:43:00.876
But if we say, well,
what does a peach need?

00:43:00.918 --> 00:43:05.542
It needs good soil, a diversity of species around
it that feed on things that might be pests.

00:43:05.584 --> 00:43:09.542
It needs an eco-system, a healthy ecosystem
just like we do to be healthy.

00:43:09.584 --> 00:43:13.167
Then we don\'t just plant a peach tree,
we plant an ecosystem.

00:43:13.209 --> 00:43:16.501
So we plant an understory with comfrey.

00:43:16.542 --> 00:43:20.250
This is a very useful
plant, it pulls nutrients.

00:43:20.292 --> 00:43:21.667
It\'s a nutrient pump.

00:43:21.709 --> 00:43:26.918
It pulls minerals, especially, from deep in the
soil up to the surface, and then you can see,

00:43:26.959 --> 00:43:31.501
we constantly cut it, this is the last
time I cut it with a machete, or a scythe,

00:43:31.542 --> 00:43:34.626
I\'ll come through and cut all this
stuff, we call it chop and drop.

00:43:34.667 --> 00:43:37.459
We just cut this stuff and mulch.

00:43:37.501 --> 00:43:40.167
Normally, it is much higher,
it is like up here.

00:43:40.209 --> 00:43:43.626
You see this is the level
it gets at when we cut it.

00:43:43.667 --> 00:43:50.959
I don\'t do it by hand normally but we\'ll chop it down with a
scythe, or a machete, and drop it, and it mulches the soil.

00:43:51.000 --> 00:43:53.959
It keeps the soil from being exposed,
we never want bare soil.

00:43:54.000 --> 00:43:58.626
It\'s the opposite of most agriculture, which
is a bare soil agriculture, and it rots down,

00:43:58.667 --> 00:44:00.626
and feeds the soil perpetually.

00:44:00.667 --> 00:44:05.876
And we have other plants, nitrogen fixers,
clovers and we\'ll graze chickens through.

00:44:05.918 --> 00:44:08.459
The Permaculture movement
is growing, for sure.

00:44:08.501 --> 00:44:10.709
It\'s worldwide, it\'s global.

00:44:10.751 --> 00:44:18.459
It really emerged out of Australia and Oceana,
but it\'s taking on steam faster, in some ways,

00:44:18.501 --> 00:44:25.000
in the United States than anywhere else because
we have the most visible forces to respond to.

00:44:25.042 --> 00:44:27.667
Permaculture courses are jam packed.

00:44:27.709 --> 00:44:30.589
Most permaculture courses, I think
it’s safe to say, have a waiting list,

00:44:30.626 --> 00:44:33.751
whenever they\'re offered
anywhere in the United States.

00:44:33.792 --> 00:44:41.501
People are beating down doors to pay a lot
of money, to spend a lot of time, to learn

00:44:41.542 --> 00:44:47.542
of our place within an ecosystem in an
integrated way and how to be problem solvers.

00:44:50.167 --> 00:44:52.751
If we want to know, well how do we live?

00:44:52.792 --> 00:44:56.792
How do we not just survive, but thrive
in these places in the world?

00:44:56.834 --> 00:45:00.501
Cold hilly places that aren\'t
suited to tillage agriculture,

00:45:00.584 --> 00:45:03.918
but we want to grow a grain
because grain is a very valuable thing,

00:45:04.292 --> 00:45:08.167
You can store it for years at a time –
you can live on grain.

00:45:08.209 --> 00:45:14.584
And so we got a strain of rice, a northern Japanese
strain of rice, with it\'s very short season.

00:45:14.626 --> 00:45:16.334
So it\'s a game changer.

00:45:16.375 --> 00:45:23.292
You get 5,000 pounds an acre versus
2,500 with terrestrial wheat.

00:45:23.334 --> 00:45:29.375
But the amazing thing is you can grow it where you
can\'t grow terrestrial wheat, or even vegetables.

00:45:29.417 --> 00:45:32.209
This is just degraded sub-soil land.

00:45:32.250 --> 00:45:39.709
Now there are species here that were never here, that
are here because of the food we\'re growing for us.

00:45:39.751 --> 00:45:44.626
We get to live with frogs,
thousands of frogs I live with here.

00:45:44.667 --> 00:45:51.959
And dragon flies and salamanders, tadpoles
and snakes and all sorts of birds

00:45:52.000 --> 00:45:55.626
that weren\'t here when I moved in.

00:45:55.667 --> 00:45:59.751
The sixth great extinction is not in
evidence here – it\'s just the opposite.

00:46:03.167 --> 00:46:09.125
When despair for the world grows in me and
I wake in the night at the least sound

00:46:09.167 --> 00:46:14.125
in fear of what my life and
my children\'s lives may be,

00:46:14.167 --> 00:46:22.167
I go and lie down where the wood drake rests in his
beauty on the water, and the great heron feeds.

00:46:23.667 --> 00:46:31.334
I come into the peace of wild things who do not
tax their lives with forethought of grief.

00:46:31.375 --> 00:46:35.292
I come into the presence of still water.

00:46:35.334 --> 00:46:41.292
And I feel above me the day-blind stars
waiting with their light.

00:46:41.334 --> 00:46:47.334
For a time I rest in the grace
of the world, and am free.

00:46:50.792 --> 00:46:56.000
It\'s not like, \"Oh, now we recognize there\'s a
problem but we don\'t know what to do about it.\"

00:46:56.042 --> 00:46:58.792
We do know what to do about it.

00:46:58.834 --> 00:47:00.834
We need to transform our energy system.

00:47:00.876 --> 00:47:04.000
We ought to be creating a half a million
jobs a month in this country now.

00:47:04.042 --> 00:47:08.792
There are all these huge technological
innovations that could be pursued

00:47:08.834 --> 00:47:11.834
but it helps to have a real
price on carbon to do that.

00:47:11.876 --> 00:47:19.876
Moving from fossil fuels to wind, solar power,
geo-thermal, micro-hydro, tidal power, wave power.

00:47:20.542 --> 00:47:26.626
There are many options and most of them are
very good, especially in certain places,

00:47:26.667 --> 00:47:32.083
but we\'re not going to be able to replace
fossil fuel energy on a one to one basis

00:47:32.125 --> 00:47:38.501
rapidly and make money doing so, so we
will be making sacrifices in the process.

00:47:38.542 --> 00:47:43.459
My excitement about these
21st-century technologies that may arrive

00:47:43.501 --> 00:47:51.501
is that in June and July and August we have
more sun by 9 AM then we could use all day.

00:47:52.667 --> 00:48:00.501
There is so much energy hitting the earth from
the sun, in one hour the photons of light energy

00:48:00.542 --> 00:48:05.292
can fuel the world\'s economy
for a year, for a year!

00:48:05.334 --> 00:48:07.417
One hour of sunlight.

00:48:07.459 --> 00:48:12.459
So there is abundance in the world that we
have not understood.

00:48:12.501 --> 00:48:18.709
But it is my faith that climate change will
bring us to this new kind of understanding,

00:48:18.751 --> 00:48:26.751
new infrastructure, new experimentation that will really
change civilization and that this is the trigger,

00:48:29.375 --> 00:48:33.292
this catalyst for that transition to occur.

00:48:33.334 --> 00:48:37.751
I\'m not such a good soul that if I
thought we had no chance of succeeding,

00:48:37.792 --> 00:48:41.667
I\'d waste my time flailing around at it -
I think we have a chance.

00:48:41.709 --> 00:48:47.042
I think the game is not yet over,
and the outcome not yet clear.

00:48:47.083 --> 00:48:50.751
But I sure don\'t think
it\'s going to happen automatically.

00:48:50.792 --> 00:48:54.417
I think the only hope is
to build a big movement.

00:48:54.459 --> 00:49:02.000
A true citizen\'s movement that is big, that is
tough, that is determined to make deep change.

00:49:02.042 --> 00:49:10.042
If there is a model in living memory that we need to
try to find again it was the civil rights movement.

00:49:10.542 --> 00:49:15.501
People understood that they had a
deep grievence and they understood

00:49:15.584 --> 00:49:21.501
that the system they were working in was
illegitimate and they set out to demonstrate that.

00:49:21.918 --> 00:49:23.792
We are going to act.

00:49:23.834 --> 00:49:28.334
Power responds to a demand and we have to
let that demand be heard.

00:49:28.375 --> 00:49:33.792
And it\'s time to step outside the system and
do some things that we haven\'t done before.

00:49:33.834 --> 00:49:37.042
We have got to be careful as
we do civil disobedience.

00:49:37.083 --> 00:49:40.167
We shouldn\'t make young people
the cannon fodder for it.

00:49:40.209 --> 00:49:44.000
I think it should be those of us who
spend our lives burning fossil fuel.

00:49:44.042 --> 00:49:48.959
We need to make it very clear who the
radicals in this scenario are.

00:49:49.000 --> 00:49:52.876
They are not people demanding an
end to fossil fuel burning.

00:49:52.918 --> 00:49:57.167
The radicals are the people who
are willing to fill the atmosphere

00:49:57.209 --> 00:50:01.876
with twice as much carbon as there
used to be and just see what happens.

00:50:01.918 --> 00:50:04.558
There is movement building around the
world and what you are seeing

00:50:04.584 --> 00:50:08.459
is that the movements are connecting,
so that the environmental movement

00:50:08.501 --> 00:50:11.083
is connecting to the
sustainable food justice movement.

00:50:11.125 --> 00:50:14.083
The food justice movement is connecting
to the women\'s movement.

00:50:14.125 --> 00:50:17.959
The women\'s movement is connecting
to the LGBTQ movement

00:50:18.000 --> 00:50:21.709
We simply cannot look at
these problems in silos.

00:50:21.751 --> 00:50:29.167
What needs to be done is to connect these groups which
are prefiguring in their work the future world.

00:50:29.209 --> 00:50:34.125
After all these years of being deprived
of meaning in our lives,

00:50:34.167 --> 00:50:37.083
we have an opportunity to
fight for something real.

00:50:37.125 --> 00:50:45.125
And it\'s not just a fight, it\'s really a much
more joyful existence to live in reality.

00:50:48.209 --> 00:50:56.209
This climate crisis, it could be some of the worst
sorts of things we will have seen on the planet,

00:50:56.501 --> 00:51:02.876
as the disasters pile up and there\'s
more of them than we can deal with.

00:51:02.918 --> 00:51:06.250
So the question is there about hope.

00:51:06.292 --> 00:51:08.584
Is hope necessary?

00:51:08.626 --> 00:51:11.751
What is hope in this context?

00:51:11.792 --> 00:51:18.959
And I think my answer would be, hope
is this equilibrium, this steady mind,

00:51:19.000 --> 00:51:25.876
the willingness to be present
for what it actually is and a curiosity,

00:51:25.918 --> 00:51:30.083
a kind of,
\"Well, what will it really be?\"

00:51:30.125 --> 00:51:34.042
When you\'re in the middle
of a big adventure,

00:51:34.083 --> 00:51:38.709
you don\'t have time to decide
whether you\'re hopeful or hopeless.

00:51:38.751 --> 00:51:41.542
That question can bring you
out of the present moment.

00:51:41.584 --> 00:51:45.918
It can throw you into
imaginings and conjectures

00:51:45.959 --> 00:51:49.584
when all your energy should be
right here, in the moment.

00:51:49.626 --> 00:51:56.834
I don\'t think that there is any hopeful outcome
from this, where we will avoid all messiness.

00:51:56.876 --> 00:52:02.334
Somehow the tooth fairy is going to come down
at the last minute and make everything okay.

00:52:02.375 --> 00:52:03.751
It\'s not going to happen.

00:52:03.792 --> 00:52:06.042
We are headed into a very difficult time.

00:52:06.083 --> 00:52:13.209
It\'s going to be an extraordinarily painful transition
for our species and for the rest of the natural world.

00:52:13.250 --> 00:52:21.250
That said, how painful it is and how many of
us survive, and how much of nature survives,

00:52:21.876 --> 00:52:25.250
all of that depends on what we do now.

00:52:25.292 --> 00:52:29.501
So can you imagine having the opportunity
of being alive at this moment in history

00:52:29.542 --> 00:52:35.459
when so much is at stake and choosing
to go to sleep instead?

00:52:36.667 --> 00:52:44.167
If you want an adventure, boy, what a
time to choose to be alive, to get a chance

00:52:44.209 --> 00:52:52.209
to find out what you have inside you in terms
of vitality and alertness and courage,

00:52:54.042 --> 00:52:59.751
what you have to discover in terms of what
we can do together.

00:52:59.792 --> 00:53:03.292
Don\'t waste time in
self-pity over darkness.

00:53:03.334 --> 00:53:09.542
Don\'t waste time trying to figure out
better circumstances that you might like.

00:53:09.792 --> 00:53:12.125
You are born into this.

00:53:12.292 --> 00:53:17.375
And you are here to
love it and to see that it goes on...

00:53:18.125 --> 00:53:21.083
I cannot turn my eyes,

00:53:24.542 --> 00:53:28.292
I cannot count the cost,

00:53:30.626 --> 00:53:33.918
Of all that has been broken,

00:53:37.167 --> 00:53:40.918
All that has been lost.

00:53:43.459 --> 00:53:51.459
And the light on the
hills is full of mercy.

00:53:56.709 --> 00:54:04.709
The wind in the tree, it comes to save me.

00:54:09.542 --> 00:54:17.542
The silence, it will never desert me

00:54:22.000 --> 00:54:30.000
I long to hold the whole
world in these arms.

00:54:34.626 --> 00:54:42.626
May all beings be happy.

00:54:47.250 --> 00:54:55.250
My all beings be safe.

00:54:59.876 --> 00:55:07.876
May all beings everywhere be free.