Dissent Poem
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
On January 20, 2017, over 200 protesters were arrested and charged with multiple felonies for expressing opposition to the election of Donald Trump. In Dissent Poem, an anonymous young protester, The Narrator, recounts the protest and trials of what became known as J20, reflecting on how the trial set a precedent for government surveillance and control, anarchism as a practice of freedom, and how people from diverse ideological perspectives can learn valuable lessons from the arrests and aftermath.
A collage of footage drawn from various sources documenting the protest as well as animated visuals illustrate The Narrator’s interview, engaging viewers to question the criminalization of dissent in the face of a growing fascist threat. The in-situ footage functions as an emotionally visceral visual testament to the truth of The Narrator’s story, which they tell from the perspective of a protester and J20 defendant.
The Narrator is a compelling subject who presents complex ideas in an engaging way, including questions about what is called violence in a time of increasingly excessive state violence. As The Narrator says, “violence is a term that is relative to who gets to use power and who has power used against them.” Other ideas examined in the film include the rise of racism, fascism, and xenophobia, anti-capitalism, anti fascist protests and the practices of anarchy.
The Narrator’s reflections on the arrest, detainment, and lawsuit demonstrate why these charges should be important to everyone. In The Narrator’s words “Regardless of what you think of what happened on January 20th, there is something beautiful about believing in something enough to risk your freedom.” This film is a call to question the criminalization of dissent in the face of a growing fascist threat, and an invitation to imagine new creative forms of resistance.
Citation
Main credits
Davis, Brenda (film director)
Davis, Brenda (film producer)
Meighan, Zoë (film director)
Meighan, Zoë (film producer)
Other credits
Cinematography, Alexandra Swati Guild; editing, Jacqueline Basse.
Distributor subjects
PoetryKeywords
00:00:12.012 --> 00:00:16.641
So, it was January 20th, 2017
00:00:16.641 --> 00:00:20.854
the morning of the inauguration
00:00:22.439 --> 00:00:23.982
there was a large group of people
00:00:23.982 --> 00:00:25.025
in a march.
00:00:25.608 --> 00:00:26.693
You’re marching
00:00:26.693 --> 00:00:28.028
things are tense,
00:00:28.486 --> 00:00:29.821
you’re kind of trying to decide
00:00:29.821 --> 00:00:31.656
how to interact with the police
00:00:31.865 --> 00:00:33.366
whether to stay as a group
00:00:33.366 --> 00:00:36.369
or whether to break up.
00:00:51.718 --> 00:00:54.387
We were dealing with pepper spray
00:00:54.387 --> 00:00:55.680
and these flash bangs
00:00:55.680 --> 00:00:57.348
they shoot rubber bullets
00:00:57.348 --> 00:01:00.518
shrapnel… they’re very loud
00:01:00.518 --> 00:01:02.645
they don’t make it hard to see fortunately
00:01:02.645 --> 00:01:04.230
but I guess that’s what the
00:01:04.230 --> 00:01:06.900
pepper spray is for
00:01:07.192 --> 00:01:09.652
So we were dealing with that for blocks
00:01:09.652 --> 00:01:10.904
and there’s a frontline
00:01:10.904 --> 00:01:13.364
a first wave where people are walking
00:01:13.490 --> 00:01:16.034
and then there was a line of officers
00:01:16.034 --> 00:01:18.328
that line up one by one
00:01:18.328 --> 00:01:20.413
blocking the path in front of you
00:01:20.413 --> 00:01:21.998
and you think to yourself
00:01:21.998 --> 00:01:25.835
okay, this is, you know, not great
00:01:26.211 --> 00:01:28.546
I wish there weren’t so many officers
00:01:28.546 --> 00:01:30.381
in front of me
00:01:30.381 --> 00:01:32.425
it’s only when you know you hear
00:01:32.425 --> 00:01:33.593
from the people in the back
00:01:33.593 --> 00:01:37.555
that it’s just… you’re trapped
00:01:42.852 --> 00:01:44.729
A kettle is when a protest
00:01:44.729 --> 00:01:46.272
is moving forward
00:01:46.272 --> 00:01:48.108
and the line of riot police
00:01:48.108 --> 00:01:50.276
stops it from the front
00:01:50.276 --> 00:01:52.112
and another line of riot police
00:01:52.112 --> 00:01:55.115
stops anyone from leaving the back
00:01:55.740 --> 00:01:57.575
trapping everyone
00:01:57.909 --> 00:01:58.952
Oh nevermind!
00:02:04.165 --> 00:02:05.834
They’re not gonna let anybody leave
00:02:10.171 --> 00:02:11.005
Don’t go anywhere.
00:02:11.923 --> 00:02:12.715
They won’t let you out.
00:02:14.717 --> 00:02:16.469
There was an initial burst where
00:02:16.469 --> 00:02:17.762
a lot of people broke
00:02:17.762 --> 00:02:19.305
through the line of officers
00:02:33.194 --> 00:02:36.281
Oh shit! Oh my god! Oh fuck!
00:02:43.371 --> 00:02:45.039
Back off!
00:02:46.207 --> 00:02:47.292
Back up sir!
00:02:48.501 --> 00:02:50.628
Stop! Move all the way down!
00:02:59.220 --> 00:03:00.180
Get up!
00:03:04.767 --> 00:03:07.729
The more you riot the worse it will get!
00:03:14.027 --> 00:03:16.988
Stop rioting! It’s very simple!
00:03:18.865 --> 00:03:21.451
Statement #3 from the ungovernables
00:03:21.451 --> 00:03:22.660
in 12th and L;
00:03:22.660 --> 00:03:23.953
if you agree with what we say
00:03:23.953 --> 00:03:24.954
add your voice!
00:03:24.954 --> 00:03:26.748
If you agree with what we say
00:03:26.748 --> 00:03:27.874
add your voice!
00:03:27.874 --> 00:03:29.709
Well, we’re going to jail.
00:03:29.709 --> 00:03:31.461
Well, we’re going to jail!
00:03:31.461 --> 00:03:33.254
But we aren’t going silently.
00:03:33.254 --> 00:03:35.173
But we aren’t going silently!
00:03:35.173 --> 00:03:36.507
Tide of repression has been
00:03:36.507 --> 00:03:37.967
rising for some time.
00:03:37.967 --> 00:03:39.385
The tide of repression has been
00:03:39.385 --> 00:03:41.137
rising for some time!
00:03:41.137 --> 00:03:42.889
Cops love Trump but to get rid of
00:03:42.889 --> 00:03:44.682
both, we need to get rid of the government
00:03:44.682 --> 00:03:45.600
Cops love Trump
00:03:45.600 --> 00:03:47.352
but to get rid of both we have to
00:03:47.352 --> 00:03:49.145
get rid of the government.
00:03:49.145 --> 00:03:50.939
Our safety relies on building bonds
00:03:50.939 --> 00:03:52.899
with each other outside of state control.
00:03:52.899 --> 00:03:55.109
For freedom, for anarchy!
00:04:00.698 --> 00:04:02.075
People didn’t think they were
00:04:02.075 --> 00:04:04.535
going to face such repercussions
00:04:04.535 --> 00:04:06.746
you know, I didn’t even think
00:04:06.746 --> 00:04:08.581
I was going to get arrested
00:04:08.581 --> 00:04:11.542
when I was in the kettle honestly
00:04:11.751 --> 00:04:14.879
Everyone got the worst possible charges
00:04:14.879 --> 00:04:16.422
including medics and press
00:04:17.257 --> 00:04:18.758
the DC legal system
00:04:18.758 --> 00:04:20.718
arrested 230 people
00:04:20.718 --> 00:04:23.429
and charged them all with felonies
00:04:26.432 --> 00:04:28.351
A friend of mine said
00:04:28.351 --> 00:04:30.395
“...the process is the punishment.”
00:04:30.395 --> 00:04:32.355
The idea of having felonies
00:04:32.355 --> 00:04:33.606
I mean that’s my main thing
00:04:33.606 --> 00:04:35.024
that I’m scared of
00:04:35.024 --> 00:04:36.943
more than jail time
00:04:36.943 --> 00:04:38.611
it’s more than anything else
00:04:38.611 --> 00:04:40.697
Like it’s a dark cloud
00:04:40.697 --> 00:04:42.699
over my head throughout the day
00:04:42.699 --> 00:04:44.117
but I mostly try and you know
00:04:44.117 --> 00:04:44.951
brush it away
00:04:44.951 --> 00:04:46.786
like there’s not very much I can do
00:04:49.414 --> 00:04:50.081
You know you go through
00:04:50.081 --> 00:04:51.582
thirty minutes in a protest
00:04:51.582 --> 00:04:53.626
and it changes your prospects
00:04:53.626 --> 00:04:55.920
between being a normal citizen
00:04:55.920 --> 00:04:57.964
to facing court cases
00:04:57.964 --> 00:05:00.133
to having an FBI file
00:05:00.133 --> 00:05:02.885
having your name appear in a Google search
00:05:03.136 --> 00:05:06.139
to being targeted by right wing extremists
00:05:08.474 --> 00:05:10.143
I’ve gone through most of this journey
00:05:10.143 --> 00:05:11.561
trying to be, like
00:05:11.561 --> 00:05:13.813
okay it’s out of my hands
00:05:13.938 --> 00:05:15.273
you know the government hasn’t really
00:05:15.315 --> 00:05:17.233
found more evidence on me
00:05:17.817 --> 00:05:19.819
I feel I just have to wait
00:05:21.112 --> 00:05:22.989
If I were letting this rule my life
00:05:22.989 --> 00:05:25.491
to a degree in which I was, incapacitated
00:05:25.491 --> 00:05:26.826
like I couldn’t do anything
00:05:27.076 --> 00:05:29.329
I’d be self-imprisoned for over a year now
00:05:30.621 --> 00:05:32.915
On one hand, I’m trying to live life
00:05:32.915 --> 00:05:34.334
as full as I can
00:05:34.667 --> 00:05:36.836
and I definitely have restrictions on me
00:05:37.962 --> 00:05:39.297
on the other hand
00:05:39.839 --> 00:05:42.008
when I glimpse a life outside of this
00:05:42.175 --> 00:05:44.635
not having to be scared about my future
00:05:45.470 --> 00:05:47.180
just made it so much better.
00:05:48.431 --> 00:05:50.433
I can’t wait to have a future
00:05:50.600 --> 00:05:52.018
where I don’t have to care so much
00:05:52.018 --> 00:05:53.436
about my future
00:05:56.647 --> 00:05:58.524
There were a lot of transitions between
00:05:58.524 --> 00:05:59.609
being booked
00:06:00.026 --> 00:06:01.027
processed
00:06:01.027 --> 00:06:01.694
holding
00:06:01.986 --> 00:06:03.446
waiting to see the judge
00:06:03.988 --> 00:06:05.948
all of us spent the night in jail
00:06:06.115 --> 00:06:07.784
some jail, one jail or another
00:06:08.826 --> 00:06:10.703
someone is screaming
00:06:10.953 --> 00:06:12.372
in the cell next to us
00:06:14.791 --> 00:06:15.875
Early in the morning
00:06:16.042 --> 00:06:17.794
we’re taken out of our holding cells
00:06:17.794 --> 00:06:19.545
and placed into paddy wagons
00:06:22.173 --> 00:06:23.633
so we’re in the paddy wagon
00:06:23.633 --> 00:06:25.885
and a cop is listening to some
00:06:25.885 --> 00:06:27.720
pretty good R&B actually
00:06:28.304 --> 00:06:29.389
it’s a little pleasant
00:06:29.639 --> 00:06:31.682
You can kind of see out the window
00:06:31.682 --> 00:06:32.892
of the paddy wagon
00:06:33.226 --> 00:06:34.894
through the barred glass, or whatever.
00:06:36.020 --> 00:06:37.021
It’s taking a long time
00:06:37.021 --> 00:06:38.231
to get to the courthouse
00:06:38.231 --> 00:06:39.524
because it’s driving through
00:06:39.524 --> 00:06:41.067
the women’s march in DC
00:06:41.150 --> 00:06:41.901
yeah, I mean
00:06:41.901 --> 00:06:42.860
I tell people I was
00:06:42.860 --> 00:06:43.903
in the women’s march
00:06:43.903 --> 00:06:45.071
but I was obviously
00:06:45.071 --> 00:06:46.406
in the paddy wagon
00:06:46.406 --> 00:06:47.573
going through it
00:06:47.573 --> 00:06:49.075
to be placed in a holding cell
00:06:52.078 --> 00:06:54.247
We were in gendered holding
00:06:54.372 --> 00:06:56.499
not accurately gendered holding
00:06:56.499 --> 00:06:57.417
of course
00:06:58.084 --> 00:07:00.253
I understand that I’m in the male
00:07:00.253 --> 00:07:01.587
holding tank
00:07:01.712 --> 00:07:04.340
I wish I wasn’t in the male holding tank.
00:07:04.757 --> 00:07:06.843
The pressure to perform masculinity
00:07:06.843 --> 00:07:08.761
was still there, even if you’re not
00:07:09.095 --> 00:07:10.680
around anyone who
00:07:11.013 --> 00:07:12.432
is threatening you
00:07:12.598 --> 00:07:13.933
You know, the sense of being in jail
00:07:13.933 --> 00:07:15.518
is a threat enough itself
00:07:17.520 --> 00:07:19.897
We couldn’t see any people who were
00:07:19.897 --> 00:07:22.108
in the gendered female
00:07:22.108 --> 00:07:22.900
holding tank
00:07:23.192 --> 00:07:24.527
but we could hear them when they sang
00:07:24.777 --> 00:07:26.362
and it was actually one of the only ways
00:07:26.362 --> 00:07:27.864
that we could communicate with them
00:07:27.864 --> 00:07:28.781
is that if we all
00:07:29.198 --> 00:07:31.284
sang a song over here they could hear us
00:07:31.284 --> 00:07:32.952
And it was another way we could interact
00:07:32.952 --> 00:07:34.954
with each other like on a personal level.
00:07:38.207 --> 00:07:40.877
Luckily DC courts don’t have a bail system
00:07:41.586 --> 00:07:42.628
and we were all let out
00:07:42.628 --> 00:07:44.255
into the general public the next day which
00:07:45.256 --> 00:07:46.466
thank god they did
00:07:49.635 --> 00:07:50.887
If I were to tell
00:07:50.887 --> 00:07:52.096
the generation
00:07:52.096 --> 00:07:53.931
that has just now come into the world
00:07:53.931 --> 00:07:56.976
why it’s important to express dissent
00:07:56.976 --> 00:07:57.977
I would say
00:07:57.977 --> 00:07:59.979
that this world isn’t perfect
00:07:59.979 --> 00:08:01.814
and it’s not going to be perfect
00:08:01.898 --> 00:08:03.232
and the only way
00:08:03.232 --> 00:08:05.818
that things change and become better
00:08:05.818 --> 00:08:07.487
and worth living
00:08:07.487 --> 00:08:08.613
is through difference
00:08:08.613 --> 00:08:10.990
and through experimentation.
00:08:11.991 --> 00:08:14.660
If I were to go back and tell myself
00:08:14.660 --> 00:08:16.245
how to be in the world
00:08:16.245 --> 00:08:17.163
I would say
00:08:17.163 --> 00:08:18.623
you have to listen to your heart
00:08:18.623 --> 00:08:20.166
you have to listen to others
00:08:20.166 --> 00:08:23.336
and be open to almost anything
00:08:26.339 --> 00:08:28.174
I was 15
00:08:28.591 --> 00:08:30.176
You know, I went to a
00:08:30.176 --> 00:08:31.469
collective house
00:08:31.469 --> 00:08:32.345
and they were political
00:08:32.345 --> 00:08:33.971
you know, they were all anarchists
00:08:34.096 --> 00:08:36.641
They had a Food Not Bombs in the basement
00:08:36.641 --> 00:08:39.268
and a free bike co-op
00:08:39.268 --> 00:08:41.103
and had punk shows
00:08:41.437 --> 00:08:42.939
Anarchism to me
00:08:43.439 --> 00:08:44.649
on a day to day basis
00:08:44.649 --> 00:08:46.692
looks like trying to live with as little
00:08:46.692 --> 00:08:48.653
possible repression as you can
00:08:50.029 --> 00:08:51.489
It looks like sharing and giving
00:08:51.489 --> 00:08:52.823
without expectation.
00:08:53.282 --> 00:08:54.951
You have to find your friends
00:08:54.951 --> 00:08:57.703
and try and share as much as possible
00:08:57.703 --> 00:09:00.540
share your food, share your ideas
00:09:00.540 --> 00:09:01.874
and care for each other
00:09:01.874 --> 00:09:04.210
and share your lives together
00:09:05.044 --> 00:09:07.880
I share unconditionally
00:09:07.880 --> 00:09:09.632
with my friends
00:09:09.632 --> 00:09:11.133
but I also don’t put limits
00:09:11.133 --> 00:09:13.010
on who could possibly be them
00:09:13.553 --> 00:09:14.720
You know, some people
00:09:14.720 --> 00:09:16.973
feel that anarchists are idealists
00:09:17.014 --> 00:09:20.226
and some people feel that it’s impractical
00:09:20.518 --> 00:09:22.186
It’s not about what’s practical
00:09:22.186 --> 00:09:24.897
or what works or what doesn’t
00:09:24.897 --> 00:09:27.400
it’s actually about where you stand
00:09:27.400 --> 00:09:28.484
in your heart and like
00:09:28.484 --> 00:09:30.403
what your actual desires are
00:09:36.492 --> 00:09:37.493
People who could say
00:09:37.493 --> 00:09:38.661
anarchism doesn’t work
00:09:38.828 --> 00:09:40.580
I mean the main flaw is
00:09:41.330 --> 00:09:43.708
what does working mean in this situation
00:09:44.417 --> 00:09:46.377
Those who think that anarchism can’t work
00:09:46.377 --> 00:09:48.337
are trying to fit it into a framework
00:09:48.337 --> 00:09:50.006
that it’s explicitly against
00:09:50.423 --> 00:09:51.757
How is power
00:09:51.924 --> 00:09:54.218
and control monopolized
00:09:54.218 --> 00:09:56.512
or how is it gathered from
00:09:56.512 --> 00:09:58.264
one area or one person
00:09:58.264 --> 00:09:59.724
how does one person have
00:09:59.724 --> 00:10:02.768
more or less control over
00:10:02.768 --> 00:10:04.687
their life and the life of others
00:10:05.938 --> 00:10:07.440
You're taking away this framework
00:10:07.440 --> 00:10:09.025
to have unlimited freedom
00:10:09.025 --> 00:10:11.110
to organize in ways that you see fit
00:10:13.446 --> 00:10:16.032
Anarchism to me is the immediate practice
00:10:16.032 --> 00:10:17.450
of freedom
00:10:17.450 --> 00:10:20.286
And, I feel like that happened for me
00:10:20.286 --> 00:10:21.704
on January 20th
00:10:22.204 --> 00:10:23.956
It was immensely freeing, you know
00:10:23.956 --> 00:10:26.125
it was one of the most free spaces
00:10:26.125 --> 00:10:27.126
I’ve ever been in
00:10:28.127 --> 00:10:29.629
Dealing with a court case
00:10:29.920 --> 00:10:32.131
I am less free now than I was
00:10:32.798 --> 00:10:35.551
prior to, and I feel that.
00:10:37.428 --> 00:10:39.096
I promise you that no one
00:10:39.096 --> 00:10:41.807
within the Black Bloc on January 20th’s
00:10:41.807 --> 00:10:44.310
ideal utopian society
00:10:44.310 --> 00:10:46.562
is that where they get to break windows
00:10:46.562 --> 00:10:47.772
and throw rocks.
00:10:49.315 --> 00:10:51.734
I’m not saying that what happened on
00:10:51.734 --> 00:10:53.277
January 20th was violent
00:10:53.277 --> 00:10:55.655
violence is just a monopoly of power
00:10:56.072 --> 00:10:58.824
violence is a term that is only relative
00:10:58.824 --> 00:11:00.743
to who gets to use power
00:11:00.743 --> 00:11:03.120
and who has power used against them
00:11:03.454 --> 00:11:05.998
and which power is justified
00:11:05.998 --> 00:11:08.834
and which power is not justified.
00:11:16.509 --> 00:11:17.802
When we talk about violence
00:11:17.802 --> 00:11:19.970
in the sense of property destruction
00:11:20.012 --> 00:11:21.847
what we’re actually talking about
00:11:21.972 --> 00:11:23.099
is the erasure
00:11:23.099 --> 00:11:25.351
of the time it takes to earn enough money
00:11:25.351 --> 00:11:26.811
to own property
00:11:27.978 --> 00:11:30.356
Time is all we have on this earth
00:11:30.856 --> 00:11:32.108
but since we don’t know
00:11:32.108 --> 00:11:33.317
how much of it we have
00:11:33.317 --> 00:11:35.319
we couldn’t possible trade it equally
00:11:35.319 --> 00:11:35.945
for money
00:11:36.487 --> 00:11:38.447
Capitalism is a framework
00:11:38.447 --> 00:11:39.699
that quantifies what is
00:11:39.699 --> 00:11:41.325
impossible to quantify
00:11:41.701 --> 00:11:42.785
and turns lives
00:11:42.993 --> 00:11:44.954
in very fluid experiences
00:11:44.954 --> 00:11:47.707
and abilities and very fluid ways of being
00:11:47.707 --> 00:11:48.708
into static
00:11:48.708 --> 00:11:49.792
consumable
00:11:49.792 --> 00:11:51.210
trade-able entities
00:11:57.216 --> 00:11:58.884
When they were arresting people
00:11:59.343 --> 00:12:01.053
they didn’t know who broke windows
00:12:01.345 --> 00:12:02.388
who threw rocks
00:12:02.888 --> 00:12:04.140
who was on the sidewalk
00:12:04.140 --> 00:12:05.391
who was in the street
00:12:05.683 --> 00:12:07.476
The probable cause in this case
00:12:07.476 --> 00:12:09.395
is not whether you were wearing black
00:12:10.146 --> 00:12:12.314
or whether you had anything on you
00:12:13.023 --> 00:12:14.984
the probable cause was being around
00:12:14.984 --> 00:12:16.152
or part of the group
00:12:16.485 --> 00:12:17.486
or part of a protest
00:12:17.486 --> 00:12:18.904
or even on the same block
00:12:19.864 --> 00:12:21.574
It was only after the arrests
00:12:22.074 --> 00:12:23.993
that each individual was charged
00:12:23.993 --> 00:12:25.411
with blanket charges
00:12:25.745 --> 00:12:27.913
of every single individual crime
00:12:27.913 --> 00:12:29.915
that was committed during the protest
00:12:30.750 --> 00:12:32.168
it wasn’t a matter of whether they
00:12:32.168 --> 00:12:33.753
thought you committed a crime
00:12:34.211 --> 00:12:35.838
it was whether they thought they could
00:12:35.838 --> 00:12:38.257
piece together with footage or anything
00:12:38.424 --> 00:12:39.550
after the fact
00:12:40.760 --> 00:12:41.761
Basically
00:12:42.219 --> 00:12:44.180
what the government was doing here
00:12:44.597 --> 00:12:45.598
was casting a net
00:12:45.598 --> 00:12:47.558
against all the protesters
00:12:47.892 --> 00:12:48.768
journalists
00:12:49.435 --> 00:12:50.936
National Lawyers Guild
00:12:51.854 --> 00:12:54.064
everyone who was between the blocks of
00:12:54.064 --> 00:12:56.692
L and 12th and L and 11th
00:12:57.359 --> 00:12:59.779
If any of the J20 lose their case
00:13:00.029 --> 00:13:01.447
it means that you can be arrested
00:13:01.447 --> 00:13:03.532
for being in the vicinity
00:13:03.532 --> 00:13:05.075
of property destruction
00:13:05.075 --> 00:13:06.786
and you can be tried with every single
00:13:06.786 --> 00:13:09.121
crime that could possibly be thrown at you
00:13:09.121 --> 00:13:11.123
whether they think you are
00:13:11.123 --> 00:13:13.292
individually guilty of it or not
00:13:13.459 --> 00:13:15.878
Even if you didn’t do anything
00:13:17.463 --> 00:13:18.631
People ask
00:13:18.631 --> 00:13:20.966
why would someone need to cover their face
00:13:20.966 --> 00:13:23.219
if they weren’t going to do anything wrong
00:13:23.552 --> 00:13:25.805
well, we as people
00:13:25.805 --> 00:13:27.932
don’t get to decide what’s legal
00:13:27.932 --> 00:13:29.975
and as governments change
00:13:29.975 --> 00:13:32.937
so do the definitions of right and wrong
00:13:34.647 --> 00:13:36.315
In our case itself
00:13:36.315 --> 00:13:38.442
there was a white supremacist group that
00:13:38.442 --> 00:13:39.819
infiltrated one of the meetings
00:13:39.819 --> 00:13:40.986
about January 20th
00:13:40.986 --> 00:13:42.738
which I myself was not at
00:13:43.072 --> 00:13:45.115
and gathered video on the meeting
00:13:45.908 --> 00:13:46.992
This video
00:13:47.451 --> 00:13:48.619
that was gathered by
00:13:48.619 --> 00:13:49.954
a white supremacist group
00:13:50.246 --> 00:13:52.665
was used by the government against us
00:13:53.290 --> 00:13:54.416
and not only
00:13:54.416 --> 00:13:56.502
was it used by the government against us
00:13:56.502 --> 00:13:59.004
the prosecutor held parts of the video
00:13:59.004 --> 00:14:01.507
that were beneficial to the defense
00:14:01.507 --> 00:14:02.842
from the defense
00:14:02.842 --> 00:14:04.134
it’s a violation called
00:14:04.134 --> 00:14:05.594
the Brady Violation
00:14:05.803 --> 00:14:07.513
The government broke the law
00:14:07.513 --> 00:14:09.682
in order to pursue people
00:14:09.682 --> 00:14:11.350
who did not break the law
00:14:12.852 --> 00:14:14.353
The term Antifa
00:14:14.353 --> 00:14:16.272
was kind of brought into light
00:14:16.647 --> 00:14:19.191
in a lot of ways from January 20th
00:14:19.608 --> 00:14:21.151
and the inauguration
00:14:21.360 --> 00:14:24.321
as people who were against fascism
00:14:24.488 --> 00:14:26.031
and people who saw Donald Trump
00:14:26.031 --> 00:14:28.117
as a symbol for fascism
00:14:30.202 --> 00:14:31.954
Yes, I think he’s sexist
00:14:32.538 --> 00:14:33.873
and racist
00:14:35.040 --> 00:14:36.333
and that’s terrible
00:14:36.876 --> 00:14:38.002
and that’s not the kind of person
00:14:38.002 --> 00:14:39.211
I want to have as a president
00:14:40.963 --> 00:14:42.172
but also
00:14:43.215 --> 00:14:46.218
Trump drops bombs on people
00:14:48.012 --> 00:14:49.680
Every president before Trump
00:14:50.055 --> 00:14:51.849
and every president after Trump
00:14:52.391 --> 00:14:55.394
has or will drop bombs on people
00:14:57.813 --> 00:15:00.065
The role of presidency is bad
00:15:00.065 --> 00:15:01.650
regardless of
00:15:01.650 --> 00:15:04.236
whether or not it is Trump in office
00:15:05.070 --> 00:15:07.072
however Trump in office
00:15:07.531 --> 00:15:08.741
has emboldened
00:15:09.074 --> 00:15:12.912
white nationalists, fascists, xenophobes
00:15:12.912 --> 00:15:14.496
the list goes on
00:15:15.247 --> 00:15:16.749
When we talk about dissent
00:15:16.749 --> 00:15:19.376
how we’re expressing how we feel
00:15:19.376 --> 00:15:22.588
about the current government
00:15:23.005 --> 00:15:24.423
what happened on J20
00:15:24.423 --> 00:15:26.258
was a response to everything
00:15:26.258 --> 00:15:28.052
this political regime stands for
00:15:28.218 --> 00:15:30.429
...anywhere, and everywhere.
00:15:30.429 --> 00:15:32.723
So you’re gonna have to get used to it.
00:15:32.890 --> 00:15:34.016
You’re gonna have to get used to
00:15:34.016 --> 00:15:34.934
the alt-right
00:15:34.934 --> 00:15:36.435
You’re gonna have to get used to
00:15:36.435 --> 00:15:37.603
white identity
00:15:38.103 --> 00:15:39.855
You will not replace us
00:15:39.939 --> 00:15:42.232
You will not replace us
00:15:44.068 --> 00:15:46.195
J20 was an act of passion
00:15:46.362 --> 00:15:47.863
and it was an act of joy
00:15:48.697 --> 00:15:50.074
I know that might be confusing
00:15:50.074 --> 00:15:51.075
for most people who see
00:15:51.075 --> 00:15:52.201
what happened on J20
00:15:52.201 --> 00:15:53.452
as violent
00:15:53.452 --> 00:15:55.287
and aggressive
00:15:55.287 --> 00:15:57.206
and a riot.
00:15:57.206 --> 00:15:58.916
I mean, one thing that we can learn from
00:15:58.916 --> 00:16:00.125
after the Super Bowl
00:16:00.626 --> 00:16:02.127
is that not every form
00:16:02.127 --> 00:16:03.879
of riotous expression
00:16:03.879 --> 00:16:05.547
comes from a place of hatred.
00:16:07.883 --> 00:16:10.219
I feel like what happened on J20 was
00:16:10.219 --> 00:16:13.305
a practice of anarchist ideals
00:16:13.305 --> 00:16:14.473
in the street
00:16:16.976 --> 00:16:19.561
Not only was it an aspect of dissent
00:16:20.145 --> 00:16:21.313
but it was
00:16:21.480 --> 00:16:24.108
almost an utopian event
00:16:30.948 --> 00:16:33.909
My vision of utopia is not riots
00:16:33.909 --> 00:16:36.453
it’s not the destruction of property
00:16:36.453 --> 00:16:38.622
I don’t like the destruction of property
00:16:38.622 --> 00:16:40.290
I don’t like that people
00:16:40.290 --> 00:16:41.750
might have been scared
00:16:41.750 --> 00:16:43.252
by what they saw
00:16:46.463 --> 00:16:47.589
I don’t really know
00:16:47.589 --> 00:16:49.800
what a utopian society is going to be like
00:16:50.509 --> 00:16:52.177
I don’t even think there’s a
00:16:52.177 --> 00:16:54.638
possibility for a utopian society
00:16:55.639 --> 00:16:58.142
you can’t package a utopian future.
00:17:00.436 --> 00:17:02.187
Because our desires are based on
00:17:02.187 --> 00:17:03.355
what we lack
00:17:03.605 --> 00:17:05.774
utopia looks like having our needs met.
00:17:06.942 --> 00:17:08.944
Not our needs as individuals
00:17:09.528 --> 00:17:10.821
but our collective needs
00:17:10.821 --> 00:17:12.781
that are intrinsically bound together
00:17:15.993 --> 00:17:17.703
I was out to dinner with a few friends
00:17:17.870 --> 00:17:19.038
and we were at this dumpling spot
00:17:19.038 --> 00:17:21.040
ready to dig into our dumplings
00:17:21.373 --> 00:17:22.833
and I got this text from my lawyer
00:17:22.833 --> 00:17:23.709
that said
00:17:24.334 --> 00:17:26.879
“Charges are dropped, have a nice weekend”
00:17:30.049 --> 00:17:31.717
A thirty minute protest
00:17:32.051 --> 00:17:34.553
can lead to a year and a half of stress
00:17:35.012 --> 00:17:36.055
over something that could affect
00:17:36.055 --> 00:17:37.306
the rest of your life
00:17:37.639 --> 00:17:40.559
in a mere text message it can be all over
00:17:42.686 --> 00:17:43.687
I will say
00:17:43.896 --> 00:17:45.564
that it was a lot less stressful
00:17:45.564 --> 00:17:47.066
than going to trial for me
00:17:47.066 --> 00:17:48.567
While I’m very happy I didn’t have
00:17:48.567 --> 00:17:49.818
to go to trial
00:17:50.694 --> 00:17:52.529
it was kind of anti-climactic
00:17:52.529 --> 00:17:54.865
to have my life on hold, in a lot of ways
00:17:54.865 --> 00:17:55.908
for over a year
00:17:56.575 --> 00:17:58.202
and just have everything back
00:17:58.410 --> 00:18:00.245
just because the prosecutor
00:18:00.245 --> 00:18:02.831
decides not to keep going with the charges
00:18:03.415 --> 00:18:04.416
There was no real
00:18:04.875 --> 00:18:05.876
conclusion
00:18:08.837 --> 00:18:09.588
And you know
00:18:10.089 --> 00:18:12.049
they didn’t have enough to convict us
00:18:12.591 --> 00:18:14.426
and what they did have they misused
00:18:14.426 --> 00:18:16.011
in ways that made it unlikely
00:18:16.011 --> 00:18:17.429
for them to get a conviction.
00:18:18.430 --> 00:18:20.099
The only thing that they could do
00:18:20.599 --> 00:18:21.934
was punish us
00:18:22.267 --> 00:18:24.436
by forcing us through these legal hoops
00:18:25.270 --> 00:18:27.439
forcing us to be available to their system
00:18:28.273 --> 00:18:29.775
But at the same time
00:18:30.067 --> 00:18:31.276
what I’ve learned since having
00:18:31.276 --> 00:18:32.736
my court case dismissed
00:18:32.945 --> 00:18:35.114
is that arrest isn’t the start
00:18:35.114 --> 00:18:36.281
of the process
00:18:37.449 --> 00:18:39.284
the process is going on around us
00:18:39.284 --> 00:18:40.744
at all times.
00:18:49.962 --> 00:18:51.380
It’s only when you are arrested
00:18:51.380 --> 00:18:52.798
that you start to realize
00:18:53.132 --> 00:18:55.467
how many times you interact with police.
00:18:56.135 --> 00:18:57.594
How many cameras are on you.
00:19:00.097 --> 00:19:01.640
How everything could go against you
00:19:01.640 --> 00:19:02.724
in a court case.
00:19:06.478 --> 00:19:08.438
Once the J20 charges are dropped
00:19:08.772 --> 00:19:09.982
it’s not like the information
00:19:09.982 --> 00:19:11.567
that they’ve taken goes away
00:19:12.276 --> 00:19:13.318
It sets a precedent
00:19:13.318 --> 00:19:16.071
for information gathering on protesters
00:19:16.280 --> 00:19:17.614
Whether it be legal or not
00:19:18.574 --> 00:19:20.075
as a citizen of this country
00:19:20.075 --> 00:19:21.660
despite everything
00:19:22.119 --> 00:19:23.579
I don’t think it’s just
00:19:23.579 --> 00:19:24.997
regardless of whether or not
00:19:24.997 --> 00:19:27.291
it’s deemed legal by the prosecutors
00:19:27.291 --> 00:19:28.417
the judge
00:19:28.417 --> 00:19:29.960
the United States government
00:19:30.502 --> 00:19:32.087
Time will tell whether or not
00:19:32.087 --> 00:19:33.463
these things become legal
00:19:33.922 --> 00:19:35.007
if they aren’t already
00:19:35.507 --> 00:19:36.842
but another thing is
00:19:36.842 --> 00:19:39.303
that even if it was legal to arrest
00:19:39.303 --> 00:19:41.847
en masse without any probable cause
00:19:42.181 --> 00:19:44.016
and only justify probable cause
00:19:44.016 --> 00:19:45.184
after the fact
00:19:45.184 --> 00:19:47.102
whether or not that becomes legal
00:19:47.519 --> 00:19:50.022
it is not just as it stands.
00:19:51.023 --> 00:19:52.482
Regardless of
00:19:52.774 --> 00:19:54.443
what you think of the politics
00:19:54.443 --> 00:19:56.195
of what happened on January 20th
00:19:56.820 --> 00:19:58.197
there is something beautiful
00:19:58.197 --> 00:20:00.324
to be said about believing in something
00:20:00.699 --> 00:20:02.201
enough to risk your freedom
00:20:03.785 --> 00:20:06.705
enough to risk your livelihood and
00:20:07.623 --> 00:20:09.124
risk your safety
00:20:11.376 --> 00:20:12.961
It’s because of these risks
00:20:13.795 --> 00:20:15.797
that make dissenting beautiful.
00:20:17.549 --> 00:20:19.051
We’re going to see more people
00:20:19.051 --> 00:20:20.385
whose basis of life
00:20:20.385 --> 00:20:21.553
their sheer existence
00:20:21.553 --> 00:20:23.555
is a form of resistance
00:20:23.847 --> 00:20:25.224
and through resistance
00:20:26.475 --> 00:20:28.727
is how we will have a life worth living
00:20:31.688 --> 00:20:33.565
Oh, they’re throwing tear gas
00:20:34.066 --> 00:20:35.984
I think that January 20th, 2017
00:20:37.236 --> 00:20:38.528
was one of these moments
00:20:41.573 --> 00:20:42.866
moving forward
00:20:44.076 --> 00:20:45.369
we have to resist repression
00:20:45.827 --> 00:20:46.745
as much as we can
00:20:47.746 --> 00:20:48.914
and live as though the state
00:20:48.914 --> 00:20:49.915
is not always looming over us