Manzanar, Diverted
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
An inspired and poetic portrait of a place and its people, MANZANAR, DIVERTED: WHEN WATER BECOMES DUST follows intergenerational women from three communities who defend their land, their history and their culture from the insatiable thirst of Los Angeles. In this fresh retelling of the LA water story, Native Americans, Japanese-American WWII incarcerees and environmentalists form an unexpected alliance to preserve Payahuunadü (Owens Valley), “the land of flowing water.” Featuring breathtaking photography and immersive soundscapes, the film recounts more than 150 years of history, showing how this distant valley is inextricably tied to the city of Los Angeles. It reveals the forced removals of two peoples--the Nüümü (Paiute) and the Newe (Shoshone) who were marched out of the Valley in the 1860s by the US Army and the Japanese Americans who were brought here from their West Coast homes and incarcerated in a World War II concentration camp. Water lured outsiders in and continues to fuel the greed which has sucked this once lush place dry.
University of California, Los Angeles | Renee Tajima-Peña, Professor, Asian American Studies, and Documentary Filmmaker
“Brings together a broad range of communities, whose stories of forced removal and colonization link them together….I know of no other film that takes on this ambitious task, tying together these varied strands of history into a single, commanding narrative.”
University of California, Santa Cruz | Karen Tei Yamashita, Professor Emerita, Literature, and Author, Letters to Memory
“Complicates and extends our history, taking us back in time to the displacement of other peoples, and resituates our story within the deeper and broader history of Southern California and the American Southwest.”
Pomona College | Char Miller, W.M. Keck Professor of Environmental Analysis and History
“A penetrating analysis of the historical and contemporary debates swirling around the Eastern Sierra’s most vital resource—water.”
University of California, Santa Barbara | David N. Pellow, Dehlsen Chair of Environmental Studies, and author of What is Critical Environmental Justice?
“A moving presentation of the complexities and inspiring possibilities of the intertwined struggles for racial and environmental justice.”
University of California, Santa Barbara | Janet Walker, Professor, Film and Media Studies
“This is a gorgeous cinematic work: fully intersectional, fully ecocentric, and eminently just.”
University of California, Riverside | Catherine Gudis, Associate Professor of History and Director, Public History Program
“The film sharply critiques the forms of state violence and racial injustice that have created the environmentally degraded landscape of Payahuunadü/Owens Valley…The project makes abundantly clear the ways in which race and capital together have shaped fundamentally inequitable patterns of global development.”
NPR
“A fascinating documentary looking at Los Angeles' fraught history of how it gets its water sources..”
Citation
Main credits
Kaneko, Ann (film director)
Kaneko, Ann (film producer)
Kaneko, Ann (editor of moving image work)
Kaneko, Ann (director of photography)
Jin, Yoo-Kim (film producer)
Other credits
Composers, Lori Goldston, Steve Fisk, Alexander Miranda; editor, Ann Kaneko, Susan Metzger; cinematographer, Ann Kaneko.
Distributor subjects
Asian American; Native American & Indigenous; Environmental; Diversity & Inclusion; Environment, Sustainability & STEM; Women’s Studies; Activism; Climate ChangeKeywords
|
||
Final Color and Mix, 83:31 mins |
|
February 1, 2021 |
Video |
Audio |
Timecode |
Card: Manzanar,Diverted:WhenWater Becomes Dust Dir. Ann Kaneko Pix Lock, 81 mins. Tempmusic,color,soundand graphics July 1, 2020 |
|
|
Opening Credits |
|
01:00:08 |
|
[kids playing] |
01:00:14 |
Fountain in LA |
[fountain running] |
01:00:30 |
|
[kids giggling] |
01:00:45 |
Owens valley creeks |
[creek babbling] |
01:00:56 |
Center right: Producer, Jin Yoo- Kim |
|
01:01:04 |
|
[instrumental music] |
01:01:08 |
Upper left: Director / Producer, Ann Kaneko |
|
01:01:12 |
|
[hawk cries] |
01:01:18 |
Wide shots of Owens Valley nature |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: People lived on these creeks for thousands and thousands of years. |
01:01:23 |
|
This whole valley was utilized in the mountains in the summertime, and we’d go up there and get fish and deer and plants. |
01:01:32 |
|
[bell chiming] |
01:01:41 |
|
There's a lot of factors where man has come in and messed with the balance of things. |
01:01:55 |
drone footage of creek |
Mary Roper: I remember distinctly the vegetation and the flowing, clear, wonderful water out of those artesian wells and those are no more. |
01:02:05 |
drone footage of Manzanar site |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: There are no barracks left. The main foundations, broken dishes, and a cemetery are the only physical remains. But the ruins bring forth emotional responses from people, whether they lived in Manzanar or not. And those emotions have not lessened by the passage of time. |
01:02:23 |
Owens valley nature |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: Every mountain up here has a story behind it. Those are part of who we are and where we come from. If they come in and change the land, those stories become meaningless. |
01:02:45 |
Title Card Manzanar, Diverted: When Water Becomes Dust |
[instrumental music] |
01:03:04 |
aerial overview of the monument |
[wind blowing] |
01:03:15 |
|
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: This Manzanar historic site right here is just as important to us as other places because we lived here- |
01:04:03 |
Kathy frontal Lower third: Kathy Jefferson Bancroft, Lone Pine Pauite- Shoshone Tribe |
before anybody came here, and then, before it was a concentration camp. |
01:04:13 |
bug on tree branch |
[bees buzzing] |
01:04:19 |
Kathy walking |
[footsteps] |
01:04:23 |
Lizard |
|
01:04:31 |
Kathy walking |
We used to drive all over this place... |
01:04:34 |
Kathy frontal |
...and didn't know any of this stuff was here, you know. I grew up knowing Manzanar was always here-but I didn’t- and I knew the Japanese were here, but I didn't really know... |
01:04:38 |
Kathy side view |
... the details about what was going on. |
01:04:48 |
overview of highway & valley |
[cars passing] |
01:04:55 |
|
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: This huge valley that we call Payahuunadü. It's two miles deep, |
01:04:59 |
Sierra peak |
has the Sierras on the west side, |
01:05:04 |
mountains and valley |
and the Inyos and the White Mountains on the east side. |
01:05:07 |
Map of SoCal with route traced |
|
01:05:10 |
|
It's about three-four hour drive from north of L.A.. And that's the beginning of the Los Angeles aqueduct. |
01:05:12 |
Wide shot of aqueduct in OV |
|
01:05:20 |
archival footage (early colonizers & herds) juxtaposed with aerial of valley |
[instrumental music]
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: The outsiders came into this valley and renamed it, we call it Payahuunadü, which means the place where the water always flows. [man singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
01:05:22 |
01:05:27
01:05:37 |
||
|
The indian people used the creek to irrigate the land, and grow the natural vegetation. |
01:05:39 |
|
[cows mooing] When the outsiders came, they brought in herds of cattle and they trampled all the tribal people’s food supplies. So there was conflict. And then when they were hungry, the Indian people would kill a cow. And then, they would come and kill Indians for killing cows. |
01:05:45
01:05:47 |
Text about violence against Pauite/Shoshone |
[drum beats and singing] |
01:06:03 |
|
[women singing in Nüümü/Paiute] [horses neighing] |
01:06:17 01:06:35 |
Images of Pauite juxtaposed with Army |
[gunshots] They took all the Indians and tried to get us out of the valley, marched us down by Fort Tejon, and we made our way back - most of us. My great grandmother made it back by herself as a little girl. I always think about that |
01:06:40
01:07:02 |
Kathy frontal Archival footage of aqueduct/Bishop area |
... how important this place was to her. |
01:07:17
01:07:12 |
|
They talk about history in this valley started when outsiders came in |
01:07:23 |
footage of Indigenous community historical archival continues (indigenous & settler confrontation) |
, so the native people of this valley are pushed aside, ignored, not listened to, and that's been the case all along. [old car engine] |
01:07:28
01:07:36 |
|
[indistinct chatter] |
01:08:02 |
|
This is our home. This has been our home |
01:08:10 |
Kathy with kids |
and we have that pride in this place and we want to protect that, right, and the importance of this place ... |
01:08:12 |
board: Lone Pine Paiute Shoshone Reservation cultural center nunüümüduii suma iti "remembering our people" |
...to my people. |
01:08:21 |
Manzanar Guard Tower |
[somber music] |
01:08:34 |
A: photograph of young Sue bottom center: Sue Kunitomi Embrey 1944 |
|
01:08:40 |
A: photo of sue bottom center: Sue Kunitomi Embrey 1973 |
SueKunitomiEmbrey: Mr. Chairman... |
01:08:50 |
A: footage of Sue at hearing Sue Kunitomi Embrey testifying in 1981 |
...and honorable commissioners, my name is Sue Kunitomi Embrey. I was born and raised in Los Angeles, California. I was evacuated from Los Angeles... |
01:08:52 |
archival (photographs) continues: incarceration & concentration camp |
...on May 9th 1942, along with my widowed mother and six brothers and sisters. We were sent to the Manzanar concentration camp. I lived in Manzanar for 17 months. |
01:09:01 |
|
The period I spent in Manzanar was the most traumatic experience of my life. It has influenced my perspective as well as my continuing efforts to educate, persuade and encourage others of my generation to speak out about the unspeakable crime. |
01:09:15 |
A: photograph of Monica & Sue |
instrumental music |
01:09:36 |
|
Monica Embrey: When I graduated from high school... |
01:09:39 |
Monica frontal lower third left: Monica Embrey Granddaughter of Sue Embrey |
...and decided I was going to come out to Southern California here for college, a big reason was because my grandmother lived here. |
01:09:41 |
A: photograph of Monica & Sue |
|
01:09:47 |
|
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: I had studied American history and... |
01:09:50 |
A: Sue Interview lower third right: Sue Kunitomi Embrey Manzanar Committee |
...gone to public school in Los Angeles, and I truly believe that I was American |
01:09:53 |
A: close-up of Sue |
I think I sort of gave up the idealistic idea of democracy to a more realistic one. |
01:09:59 |
A: Sue next to truck |
|
01:10:07 |
|
Monica Embrey: I was coming and taking the train in from Claremont to L.A. every weekend to see her as she got... |
01:10:10 |
footage of Sue's house |
...sicker and sicker, and I started studying more about health and environmental pollution... |
01:10:16 |
A: Sue in front of flags |
and started thinking about connections between the |
01:10:23 |
Industrial LA |
air pollution here in Los Angeles and the cough that my grandmother had... |
01:10:27 |
A: footage of Sue in front of the monument |
for as long as I could remember. |
01:10:31 |
|
[Sue coughing] |
01:10:32 |
Monica frontal |
And so thinking about my grandmother's passing actually helped motivate me to start organizing for ... |
01:10:35 |
photograph of Monica during environmental campaigns |
...environmental justice. |
01:10:40 |
nature around OV |
[stream trickling] |
01:10:44 |
|
I took an amazing class of the history of water in California and talked about how... |
01:10:52 |
A: footage (indigenous people & colonizers, roads) |
...indigenous peoples had lived in the Owens Valley because of the rich water resource and how white farmers colonized the land. How Mulholland and others captured and seized that water and brought it back to build the empire of Los Angeles. And then we skipped over the nineteen forties |
01:10:59 |
Monica frontal |
and I knew going into that class of pretty intimate history of the 1940s in the Owens Valley because of... |
01:11:16 |
A: photograph of Sue giving a speech |
...what my grandmother and others had taught me and realized a piece of the puzzle was missing. |
01:11:22 |
A: concentration camp, water, Japanese Americans using water |
And so I asked the professor why he decided to not include the 40s, and he said he didn't see a connection between Manzanar - a World War II concentration camp for Japanese Americans - and water, and water history in that region. And so I started doing some research and decided I was going to prove him wrong. |
01:11:27 |
|
[water bubbling] |
01:11:46 |
Rose walking through Manzanar NHS |
[footsteps] |
01:11:50 |
Rose frontal lower third left: Rose Masters Manzanar National Historic Site |
RoseMasters: It looks so different, it's actually sort of hard for me to identify where I worked in 2002. But... |
01:12:00 |
board: Manzanar war relocation center |
I was a junior in high school, a guy from Manzanar... |
01:12:11 |
board: Manzanar |
... National Historic Site recruited a bunch of kids to come out here and ... |
01:12:15 |
Rose frontal |
...work for the Youth Conservation Corps |
01:12:20 |
Rose walking |
And I signed up for it. |
01:12:22 |
board: Independence |
We didn't study Manzanar in my high school, I don't know why. |
01:12:27 |
streets & mountains |
So I came out here not really understanding what this place was. People would come here looking for the... |
01:12:30 |
Rose frontal |
... histories of their families’ incarceration or their own. They'd be going around trying to find ... |
01:12:39 |
View of the valley |
...where dad had been incarcerated when he was a kid. |
01:12:44 |
Rose talking to visitors |
I remember talking to a few these people coming in and just hearing their stories... |
01:12:49 |
|
Woman: I should remember |
01:12:56 |
aerials of Manzanar |
|
01:12:58 |
|
RoseMasters: Manzanar is one little tiny square mile of land that has a deep history of forced removal, and that can be forced removal to this place - like the government did with Japanese Americans - or from this place - like the government did with Owens Valley Paiute. |
01:12:59 |
|
You can also make an argument that the water and land acquisition by Los Angeles Department of Water Power had a lot of similarities to forcing people to sell their water or land. |
01:13:17 |
panning shots of the valley |
[birds chirping] |
01:13:36 |
|
[pigeons cooing] |
01:13:40 |
|
[women singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
01:13:47 |
|
[gunshots] |
01:14:02 |
|
[people clamoring] |
01:14:06 |
|
[cows mooing] |
01:14:10 |
|
[car engine] |
01:14:18 |
|
[children playing] |
01:14:26 |
|
[birds chirping] |
01:14:36 |
|
[gusting wind] |
01:15:40 |
people in a line |
[indistinct chatter] |
01:14:48 |
shots of the site lower third left: Manzanar National Historic site |
|
01:14:57 |
site tour |
AADAP Group Leader: Back behind the museum, that's the cemetery. We're going to drive through it later. These are like sacred grounds. Respect the land, just like we were talking about after the Easter picnic last week. |
01:15:01 |
|
[indistinct chatter] |
01:15:14 |
A: early archivals of Manzanar grassland |
|
01:15:08 |
archival: cars driving through manzanar area |
We drove up there, and in the distance, a pick up truck was driving toward us. We could see the two guys in the trucks had cowboy hats, and they had gun racks in the back of the truck. And they pulled up on us and they said “What are you boys doing?” And we said, “we’re not boys... |
01:15:12 |
Warren Frontal Lower third: Warren Furutani Co-Founder of the Manzanar Committee |
we’re men, and we’re looking for the camps where racists like you put us in during World War Two.” |
01:15:28 |
Valley landscape |
They started laughing, and said, “Well, you’re on the wrong side of 395”. |
01:15:32 |
Warren Frontal |
So had we not run into these two cowboys, I guess, |
01:15:33 |
photo of Warren Lower third: Warren Furutani 1969 |
and had they not been good enough to give us directions, we never would have found it. |
01:15:40 |
Archival: view of Manzanar in the 60s |
We went back to Los Angeles, and we shared this idea that we found a place to march to. We’re gonna go to Manzanar. |
01:15:46 |
Archival: Japanese americans on bus |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: The first pilgrimage to Manzanar |
01:15:58 |
A: Japanese Americas walking into Manzanar Lower third: Manzanar Pilgrimage 1969 |
was December 1969. |
01:16:10 |
A: B/W Sue Lower Third: Sue Kunitomi Embrey, Co-Founder of the Manzanar Committee |
[instrumental music] |
01:16:26 |
A: Japanese Americans setting up/cleaning |
In 1972, we applied to make Manzanar a... |
01:16:15 |
A: Japanese Americans in front of plaque |
... state historical landmark, and we dedicated the plaque, which is now at the entrance... |
01:16:24 |
A: photo of sue |
... to Manzanar. |
01:16:35 |
A: far shot of plaque |
BruceEmbrey: The Owens Valley was a very different place |
01:16:40 |
Bruce Frontal Center left: Bruce Embrey Son of Sue Embrey |
in the early 1970s than it is today. |
01:16:47 |
A: people cleaning monument |
I remember we'd have to patch the bullet holes in the monument. We couldn't recast... |
01:16:50 |
bronze plaque
Manzanar In the early Part of World War II, 11,110,000 persons of Japanese ancestry were interned in relocation...... |
the bronze plaque where they shot at it and took an ax or a hatchet. |
01:17:05 |
Bruce Frontal |
I am the co-chair of the Manzanar Committee, |
01:17:14 |
Bruce and family at pilgrimages |
and it’s a legacy thing, where I’m trying to continue my mother’s work, and keep up connected to the confinement sites, and Manzanar in particular. |
01:17:17 |
People arriving at Manzanar Pilgrimage Lower Third: Manzanar Pilgrimage, 5th Anniversay, 2019 |
[indistinct chatter] |
01:17:30 |
Bruce and Kathy hugging |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: Of course, that’s what I love about you… |
01:17:41 |
|
Bruce Embrey : I’m happy to see you, though, I’m happy to see you. |
01:17:42 |
People at pilgrimage |
BruceEmbrey: The significance of the pilgrimage is that it’s a painful place, it’s a place that symbolizes some of the worst |
01:17:45 |
Bruce Frontal |
that this country has to offer, |
00:17:47 |
People at pilgrimage |
but it also, I think, it’s a beacon, for what the best this country can offer. |
00:17:50 |
|
Woman: As Bill was speaking as we were approaching the land, it just made a few of us very emotional. Entering this space, while someone who was incarcerated and survived was here. |
01:18:04 |
Mary at visitor's center |
Mary Roper: Hello, here's a schedule of events and there's a map on the back... |
01:18:18 |
Mary giving out leaflet |
...and then you may take this. And then there is a sign in sheet ... |
01:18:16 |
lower third left: Mary Roper Friends of Manzanar volunteer |
...right there. And this is more information. |
01:18:21 |
|
My name's Mary Roper. |
01:18:31 |
Mary & Nancy frontal Lower third right: Nancy Masters, Friends of Manzanar Volunteer |
NancyMasters: and my name's Nancy Masters. We're sisters. |
01:18:33 |
A: Keith Bright at Manzanar Lower third: Keith Bright, Former Inyo County Board of Supervisor |
Our father was on the Inyo County Board of Supervisors. And he was a supporter of Manzanar. |
01:18:37 |
Nancy & Mary at the aqueduct |
[instrumental music] |
01:18:46 |
long shot of water |
NancyMasters: That is a ton of water that heads down there. (Mary Roper) Yes. (Nancy Masters) It's going fast. |
01:18:50 |
Mary profile |
Mary: My father always was talking about the finite resources because he was in the... |
01:18:57 |
Water |
... oil business. So he was an oil man, yet,... |
01:19:03 |
Mary profile |
... in a lot of ways, an environmentalist. |
01:19:06 |
Mary walking, frontal |
And I've been interested in the water issues for many years. |
01:19:12 |
A: building aqueduct b&w Lower third: Second Los Angeles Aqueduct Construction, 1965-1970 |
When the second barrel of the aqueduct went in and the DWP started to pump more to fill that aqueduct. |
01:19:15 |
More aqueduct photos |
[instrumental music] |
01:19:25 |
Aqueduct in color |
[water flowing] |
01:19:33 |
Fruit tree |
|
01:19:37 |
|
NancyMasters: At Manzanar, there were still lots of fruit trees. |
01:19:40 |
Nancy frontal |
They were dying and that was a direct result... |
01:19:45 |
dead tree |
of pumping. |
01:19:48 |
A: The Great Los Angeles Aqueduct |
[film reel running] |
01:19:53 |
A: The purpose of this Aqueduct is to supply fresh water for a prospective population of over one million people in Los Angeles |
[suspenseful music] |
01:19:57 |
split screen: LA now & before |
[trolley bell chiming] |
01:20:06 |
|
NancyMasters: City of Los Angeles experienced lots of growth in the late 19th to early 20th century. They came here for the water. |
01:20:09 |
A: photo of LA river Lower third: Los Angeles River, 1900 |
[water running] |
01:20:18 |
Text about Water conflict against contrast of OV/LA |
[suspenseful music] |
01:20:23 |
|
[distant traffic] |
01:20:33 |
A: bombing of aqueduct |
[loud explosion] |
01:20:40 |
A: people watching aqueduct |
[water gushing] |
01:20:43 |
A: operating aqueduct |
[mechanical wheels turning] |
01:20:48 |
|
NancyMasters: It's one of the prime exemplars of resource extraction by a remote... |
01:20:51 |
aerial of water layered w/ news reports |
and often hostile urban area. |
01:20:57 |
aerial layered w/ city map |
|
01:20:59 |
layered w/ car driving |
Mary Roper: They were land speculators, so they made a lot of money off of this water. They didn't want anybody to have any water rights. |
01:21:18 |
aerial of water |
So you can imagine that the local residents were really angry, really sad, really angry. |
01:21:21 |
A: Occupation of aqueduct |
[water running] |
01:21:28 |
A: Lower center Occupation of the Alabama Gates by Ranchers |
[small explosion] |
01:21:33 |
|
NancyMasters: In the 1920s, they blew up the Alabama gates, which is just to the south of here more than once. |
01:21:49 |
Sign: Trespassing-loitering forbidden by law |
|
01:21:50 |
A: News reports/photos of explosion |
|
01:21:55 |
Aerial w/ archival map of OV |
NancyMasters: Businesses failed. There were very few holdouts as far as selling to the Department of Water and Power because they had a lot of money and some of the ranchers were desperate. |
01:22:32 |
|
[discordant music] |
01:22:46 |
Kathy Frontal Center left: Kathy Jefferson Bancroft, Lone Pine Pauite Shoshone Tribe |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: Water has always been central and a common issue everywhere in this valley, and especially with the tribes. |
01:22:54 |
A: documents about Paiute and land |
The LA department of Water and Power bought all these lands, and they came up with a series of reports called “The Indian Problem”. |
01:23:02 |
Documents about Pauite and LADWP juxtposed with modern footage of community |
[women singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
01:23:17 |
A: map of dwp land exchange |
Because we did the land exchange, we were put on these small reservations with a set amount of water. |
01:23:47 |
Kathy Frontal |
That’s been a fight since the beginning, because they keep wanting to take away, take away. |
01:23:53 |
Kathy walking into community center |
[kids talking] |
01:24:04 |
Kathy and Beverly at table |
Beverly Newell: Oh, geez! |
01:24:14 |
A: Soldier in front of plane |
I remember when dad came home from the service, which is 1945, 46. |
01:24:17 |
Beverly & Kathy lower third right: Beverly Newell Aunt of Kathy Bancroft |
In fact, seems like all the Indian men on the reservation that was of that age was in the service. So we didn't hardly have any young men around. |
01:24:21 |
A: Navajo Marines being sworn in |
[men singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
01:24:30 |
A: Articles about Pearl Harbor against video of attack |
[bombs exploding] |
01:24:34 |
|
[radio static] |
01:24:37 |
|
Reporter: Severe bombing of Pearl Harbor by enemy... |
01:24:40 |
|
Beverly Newell: I had two uncles in Pearl Harbor at the time it was bombed. |
01:24:43 |
A: Young indigenous soldiers |
I just remember all my aunts sitting around, listening for casualties. |
01:24:49 |
A: Japanese American Businesses in LA Lower third: Los Angeles, 1940 |
|
01:24:57 |
|
[indistinct chatter] |
01:25:06 |
A: MP pinning order 9066 to wall |
[hammering] |
01:25:12 |
A: Little tokyo in the wake of pearl harbor |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: We were told to send the head of household to a particular location where everybody was to be registered. My mother was two six one four A, and then the rest of us were BCD and whatever down the line. |
01:25:23 |
Sue frontal Lower third right: Sue Kunitomi Embrey, Manzanar Committee |
So when we came to Manzanar, they also had us listed as that number. |
01:25:37 |
A: Roosevelt, some people... |
RoseMasters: Early March of 1942 is when the army started looking at Manzanar. |
01:25:43 |
Rose frontal lower third right: Rose Masters Manzanar National Historic Site |
And part of the reason was that it was held by a single entity. |
01:25:48 |
A: LADWP Building |
That entity was the Department of Water and Power of Los Angeles. |
01:25:53 |
Rose frontal |
It was not met positively. LADWP did not ... |
01:26:00 |
A: map |
...want this camp established here. Development equals water use ... |
01:26:03 |
Rose frontal |
...equals less water going to Los Angeles... |
01:26:06 |
A: Barracks at Manzanar |
..., a development that would eventually have 11,070 people pass through it. That's a lot of water use. |
01:26:09 |
A: People using water at manzanar |
[garden hose spraying] |
01:26:21 |
A: map, far shot Manzanar |
RoseMasters: Turns out that the U.S. government has the right to overrule Los Angeles Department of Water and Power... |
01:26:28 |
A: building concentration camp |
..., and so mostly against their wishes, they put the camp here. |
01:26:34 |
A: cars approaching Lower third: First Convoy to Manzanar, March 23, 1942 |
[cars driving by] |
01:26:40 |
|
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: My brother had volunteered with the first 1000 people to help build the camp, and he told my mother that as long as... |
01:26:52 |
Sue Frontal |
we had to be moved, that he would go ahead and see if he could make things a little bit easier for the rest of us. |
01:26:58 |
A: cars entering |
Beverly Newell: The part that I remember the most was seeing them coming in, to see this long line of cars... |
01:27:10 |
Beverly frontal lower third left: Beverly Newell Lone Pine Paiute-Shoshone Reservation |
... just coming up the highway. And as it came by, they had like... |
01:27:15 |
A: suitcases & the car |
...suitcases, pillows and blankets just tied everywhere to the car. |
01:27:20 |
A: cars Beverly frontal |
Car dealerships throughout the valley came to Manzanar and bought like all the cars - because they couldn’t take cars in there - ten dollars twenty dollars, I don't know what it was. Yeah, you prey on the weak. That’s what you do. |
01:27:27 01:27:38 |
A: moving into barracks
Sue Frontal |
[footsteps] Sue Kunitomi Embrey: My brother had already filled the mattresses with hay for all of us and had the room ready. Where's all the other people had to find the pile of hay somewhere in the dark. |
01:27:42
01:27:44
01:27:49 |
A: moving into Manzanar A: Telephone pole Madelon Frontal Center Left: Madelon Arai Yamamoto, Manzanar Incarceree |
[indistinct chatter] Madelon Arai Yamamoto: One thing that struck me is how desolate it was,
you look outside and all you could see where the stars, I was very, very, very dark. |
01:27:51
01:28:09
01:28:14 |
A: Arai family photo |
And, the first night that we were there, I remember my mother was crying. [somber music] |
01:28:20 01:28:27 |
A: moving into manzanar |
It's like watching another vanquishment. I don't know, it's just like... |
01:28:38 |
Beverly frontal
A: moving in |
...we know we had our place to live. And I guess that's where they were going to go - to there - where they have to live now. And I thought, God, what a terrible way to treat people. But then they said, well, they did that to us, ... |
01:28:41
01:28:49 |
Beverly frontal |
...when they drove us across the mountain. Yeah. Same thing, I guess. |
01:28:55 |
A: Indigenous community, Japanese Americans moving in |
[somber music]
[indistinct chatter] |
01:29:01 01:29:05 |
|
[shakuhachi music] |
01:29:12 |
Grave |
[somber music] |
01:29:25 |
wind chime |
[wind chimes] |
01:29:38 |
Sue's house |
Monica Embrey: So my grandmother, she was standing here on the porch and a neighbor came by and was commenting on how beautiful the Santa Ana breeze was, blowing through the trees. |
01:29:42 |
Monica frontal |
And she had this outburst and she said, “I hate the wind!” |
01:29:51 |
A: windy trees at Manzanar |
She goes “the wind reminds me of Manzanar.” |
01:29:53 |
|
[wind blowing] |
01:29:58 |
Wind rustling trees in OV |
[Sue coughing] |
01:30:00 |
|
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: We got dust in our eyes and and grit in our ... |
01:30:11 |
A: Sue by the plaque |
...teeth and mouth. And it seemed like it was one of the worst things that could happen to people who had come from the city and had never experienced such wind. |
01:30:14 |
Dust/wind in OV |
[wind blowing] |
01:30:28 |
A: walking in the wind |
HenryNishi: When we arrived, it was pretty raw. |
01:30:33 |
Henry frontal lower third left: Henry Nishi Former Manzanar incarceree |
It was dusty-- oh, my gosh! |
01:30:37 |
A: walking through wind at Manzanar |
|
01:30:41 |
Wind in trees OV |
[wind rustling through tree] |
01:30:47 |
Sign by highway: Blowing Dust |
[car driving past] |
01:30:51 |
old/new OV |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: When my grandmother was a young girl, she was standing on the shores of Owens Lake for 110 square miles of water out there, and her grandpa Sam told her, you're going to live to one day see this lake dry. |
01:31:04 |
A: Painting of Owens Lake |
[suspenseful music] |
01:31:20 |
A: Construction of Aqueduct |
[construction sounds] |
01:31:21 |
Kathy in car |
This was the lake, and that's what you're seeing is the dry lake bed. This was all water before that. |
01:31:37 |
A: lake drying up, dust storms, industrial |
In the 70s, they built the second aqueduct. In order to fill that up, they started groundwater pumping and that's where you saw the real decimation of this country. Off of this lake bed was huge, clouds of dust looked like a bomb had gone off, and that's a real health hazard. |
01:31:47 |
A: Dust at Manzanar Concentration Camp |
Monica Embrey: Many people, anecdotally, who lived at Manzanar were exposed to particulate matter 2.5... |
01:32:15 |
Monica Frontal Lower Third Rright: Monica Embrey, Manzanar Committee |
from the drying up of the Owens Lake. |
01:32:21 |
A: Dust storm/Monica and Sue |
And that meant that many of them developed upper respiratory breathing problems like my grandmother. |
01:32:24 |
Kathy at Doctor's office |
[blood pressure machine buzzing] |
01:32:32 |
|
Doctor: How is that atrial fibrillation? (Kathy Jefferson Bancroft) I just don't have any energy. When I walk a little ways, I get tired real fast. (Doctor) OK. (Kathy Jefferson Bancroft) Every once in a while I can feel pressure. (Doctor)Take one deep breath. |
01:32:41 |
Kathy Frontal |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: It gets to you where it's physically affected me, not just the stress of watching things be destroyed, but where it affects your body. |
01:32:55 |
Kathy at Doctor's office |
Doctor Cough a little, cough. |
01:33:05 |
|
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: Cough again. |
01:33:08 |
Kathy Frontal |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: And that's when you started, going, okay, something needs to change. |
01:33:10 |
A: Eastern Sierra Report |
[lively music] |
01:33:13 |
A: news report |
TVNewsAnchor: Sources of ongoing dust problems in the eastern Sierra remain the subject of studies. |
01:33:15 |
A: Dust Storm |
Under state law the Los Angeles DWP must study air quality and correct any dust problems that may be related to its water gathering. |
01:33:20 |
A: timelapse of basin |
[suspenseful music] |
01:33:30 |
Kathy in car/dry Lake |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: When I first came out here, I was just watching and amazed at what all was going on and going “this is ridiculous”. But of course, you know, something needed to be done about the dust. |
01:33:53 |
Industrial owens lake |
And I later got a job as a tribal monitor to come out and watched work being done. We weren't included in any of the decision making. |
01:34:07 |
Kathy side view |
When you sit here for 10 hours a day, for five and six days a week, you have a lot of time to think. |
01:34:26 |
Kathy Frontal |
And you see the things that are dug up and destroyed. And it starts to bother you. |
01:34:33 |
Industrial owens lake/text about Nuumu |
|
01:34:38 |
Kathy in car |
I know of seven different massacres that took place on this lake. |
01:34:52 |
Dry Owens Lake |
[mbira music] |
01:35:00 |
|
My people, my ancestors, my grandparents have lived on this lake for thousands of years. It means something to all of us. It's where a lot of our ancestors are buried. |
01:35:09 |
Aerial view of almost dry lake bed |
And this lake was called Patsiala, which is fed by a whole bunch of streams and creeks and rivers. |
01:35:26 |
|
They used to talk about how green, and, the water is, and the birds and the animals that were all here, you know, all of the plants. This was a really source of survival. |
01:35:38 |
|
In our recent history, it's important because of all the massacres that took place around the people that lost their lives. The bones of our ancestors are in that lake.
[water trickling] |
01:35:55 01:36:10 |
|
Water, as it gathers from clear up north, comes down and as it's coming down, it's gathering life. So even though they've drained the water, all of that power and life is still in that lake. |
01:36:14 |
Kathy walking |
A lot of people think, oh, we're out here for arrowheads, |
01:36:33 |
Kathy Frontal Scenery |
but everything is a cultural resource. The plants, the water, including all the artifacts that are left. |
01:36:40 01:36:47 |
Kathy walking/looking at nature |
[insects buzzing] |
01:36:53 01:36:55 |
|
This area right here is how the lake was before. |
01:37:02 |
Kathy Frontal
Natural/man-made OL |
It would seem that you would want to use that as a way to revegetate the lake, but they don't use anything natural. It's all man- made. |
01:37:06
01:37:09 |
|
[sprinklers running] |
01:37:17 |
People entering DWP cascades
Group of people sitting and talking |
[indistinct chatter] Walking Water Participant: Well, we have an event here like we've had this last year. Next time, is there something that the city would do differently in terms of how to handle an abundance of water? Too much water. |
01:37:25
01:37:31 |
James Yannotta side view Lower Third: James Yannotta, Now Retired LA Aqueduct Manager
Paarticipants listening/James talking |
James Yannotta: We had an extra about 250,000 acre foot that we didn't know what to do with. I couldn't send it to L.A. because the aqueduct could only handle so much. So what was I going to do with that extra 250,000? It would've went to Owens Lake. People say, oh, that's great. Then you resolve an issue. The problem with that is if all that water went to Owens Lake, it would have risen the water level in the lake seven foot. It would have flooded and damaged 1.2 billion dollars of infrastructure. So there would have been at least two, three, four hundred thousand dollars of infrastructure that would have been damaged. |
01:37:45
01:37:54 |
Infrastructure around Aqueduct/text about LADWP dust control |
[instrumental music] |
01:38:23 01:38:29 |
|
[machines running] |
01:38:33 |
Landscape of aqueduct Mary and Nancy frontal Lower third left: Mary Roper, Owens Valley Committee |
Mary Roper: So apparently, if it can't go down the aqueduct
and somebody turn their tap on and drink it, then they consider it a waste. |
01:38:41
01:38:44 |
Infrastructure around Aqueduct |
NancyMasters: There is a linearity of approach when you work with engineers. Then I personally at one point said to Mr. Yannotta, |
01:38:51 |
Nancy frontal Center left: Nancy Masters, Owens Valley Committee |
“Stop. Let's think about the Owens Valley. |
01:39:01 |
Pan of Owens Valley Nancy frontal |
It's like a big basin. It could be your recharge basin. It could be where you keep the water underground like a reservoir. And then when you need it at a reasonable rate, you can use it.” So it's transforming it, |
01:39:04
01:39:16 |
Infrastructure around Aqueduct Creek |
from being like this industrial site where you put wells - that's mining - to working collaboratively with nature. |
01:39:23 01:39:28 |
Aqueduct |
[water rushing] |
01:39:35 |
Walking Water meeting/Andy talking Treepeople volunteer site |
AndyLipkis: Our infrastructure was built for a different climate than we now have. The climate has changed, the infrastructure can no longer meet our needs. One key piece is the people taking on greater conservation. [indistinct chatter] |
01:39:38 01:39:46 |
|
[Andy] Where's the soil? [Worker] I'm getting it right now. [Andy] Okay, great. Let me know if I can help. |
01:39:59 |
|
From the beginning of work, as we began planting the city, that alerted some people on the Owens Valley to contact us and say, |
01:40:05 |
Andy frontal lower third left: Andy Lipkis, Founder of Treepeople
Volutneers planting trees Andy Frontal |
"hey, your water is coming from here and it's a problem. Can you please be careful which species you use, so you're not going to increase the consumption and hurt us more?" So that's when my eyes were really opened.
I don't think most people in Los Angeles know anything about this. |
01:40:13
01:40:19 01:40:31 |
Pan of Aqueduct |
What's being done on our behalf is pretty extraordinary and very painful. |
01:40:37 |
Andy walking dog in LA
Andy looking at WWII monument |
[passing traffic] The fact that people were moved from Los Angeles during World War Two because of a perceived threat to our safety and put in a concentration camp right there in the middle of the Owens Valley, underscores this connection. |
01:40:45
01:40:55 |
Lone Pine town sign |
[cars driving by] |
01:41:12 |
Nancy/Mary preparing for meeting/event |
NancyMasters This reminds me of when I was a mother with a child with very long hair. We have a nice long tail. (Mary Roper) I feel very together now. |
01:41:18 |
|
Mary Roper: Nineteen eighty three is when OVC started, Nancy? You were there, early eighties. (Nancy Masters) Thank you. |
01:41:31 |
Nancy handing out stickers for OVC |
NancyMasters: The Owens Valley community arose because the city of Los Angeles put in the second aqueduct. |
01:41:39 |
A:b&w photos of second Aqueduct |
The County of Inyo sued them. The Owens Valley Committee was concerned that the water agreement, |
01:41:48 |
A: article about second aqueduct |
which was being developed, be strong, |
01:41:54 |
Nancy frontal |
because this was our shot at protecting this valley. |
01:41:58 |
A: agreement being disscussed |
Narrator: The water management agreement was hammered out over a two year period in more than 200 sessions with L.A. |
01:42:01 |
Nancy frontal |
NancyMasters: The Owens Valley Committee set out to say this agreement’s gonna work for us. |
01:42:08 |
A: DWP meeting |
We do talk to the city, extensively. |
01:42:13 |
A: Mary on screen at DWP meeting |
Mary Roper: Good afternoon. My name is Mary Rober and I'm with the Owens Valley Committee. |
01:42:17 |
Nancy frontal |
NancyMasters: And in the end, that may or may not work. |
01:42:21 |
A: Mary on screen at DWP meeting |
Mary Roper: And thank you for confirming that you've received the letter from our attorney, Don Mooney, this morning. |
01:42:23 |
Nancy frontal |
NancyMasters: So we have to be prepared to use legal means. |
01:42:29 |
A: Mary on screen at DWP meeting |
Mary Roper: In the Owens Valley, pumping anywhere is pumping everywhere. |
01:42:33 |
A: Keith Bright at meeting Lower third: Keith Bright, Inyo County Board Of Supervisor, 1986-1993 |
KeithBright: There's a love hate deal for- against the DWP, |
01:42:38 |
DWP truck |
and especially the Owens Valley. |
01:42:35 |
|
NancyMasters: Our father was on the |
01:42:44 |
A: Keith signing agreement Lower third: Signing of Long Term Water Agreement 1991 |
Inyo County Board of Supervisors at the time that the water agreement was negotiated and signed. |
01:42:45 |
Mary and Nancy frontal |
And so it's a connection that comes to us maybe genetically. |
01:42:51 |
Nancy opening gate at ranch |
Mary Roper: My father always wanted to have a cattle ranch. |
01:42:59 |
Car driving through gate Water in ranch/Mary and nancy walking |
Our ranch that he ended up buying in 1962
has the South Fork of Oak Creek running through it and it has water rights. |
01:43:06
01:43:12 |
|
[stream running] |
01:43:18 |
|
So they're not diverting anything now, but when the runoff happens, they'll start diverting. Mark Lacey: Mary Roper. She and her sister are from |
01:43:21
01:43:28 |
Mark frontal |
a ranch family. I've known them and their brother for quite a long time. |
01:43:26 |
Mark working at his ranch |
They came to me, and I think really just because I have some knowledge of the Valley, and I bring a different perspective to the group. It wasn't what I would say would be a natural fit several years ago. You know, there are some of the environmental people who don't like ranching here, and there's some of the ranchers who don't like what the environmentalists want to do. We weren't on the same side.
We really benefitted from DWP’s ownership of the land. It’s always been a pretty good place to live and operate livestock operations. They've been good landlords for 100 years, until when they started to systematically dry up the balance of the valley. |
01:43:30
01:43:47
01:44:00 01:44:12 |
Pan of dry valley w/ map of inyo county on top |
[instrumental music] |
01:44:17 |
Mark frontal |
DWP owns over 90 percent of the private land in Inyo County. They own the heart of the valley, they own, everything that's worth owning. |
01:44:27 01:44:30 |
Cows |
Most of the land is as part of a lease. |
01:44:32 |
Kathy frontal |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: We don't like what the DWP did,
but what would it be if they weren't here? You know, it would probably be all developed. |
01:44:43
01:44:45 |
Nancy frontal |
NancyMasters: Has the city been unwittingly an agent of preservation? Yes, they have. |
01:44:51 |
OV scenery |
And we appreciate that. And there's probably, given the destruction that's already happened, an amount of water on an annual basis they could take so that you don't drop the water tables, too low, And we could coexist peacefully. |
01:44:56 |
|
[creek running] |
01:45:13 |
Industrial OV/text about DWP |
[engine roaring] Mary Roper: L.A. keeps talking about |
01:45:17
01:45:27 |
Nancy and Mary frontal |
being self sustainable. No, I think when they talk about that, they consider this part of their water. Nancy Masters: Local water. |
01:45:29 |
running creek Warren Frontal Lower third right: Warren Furutani, Los Angeles Public Works Commissioner, 2013 |
[stream running]
Warren Furutani: The Department of Water and Power, it's a government entity unto itself. |
01:45:39
01:45:41 |
LADWP buildings Warren Frontal |
And in terms of checks and balances relative to people. It's questionable as to what the checks and balances are with the DWP. And anybody that knows history of Los Angeles has gotta know |
01:45:46 01:45:56 |
Pan of aqueduct |
that water’s what makes Los Angeles, Los Angeles. |
01:46:00 |
Los angeles lush scenery/dry OV |
[meloncholic music] Mark Lacey: At some point, somebody has to think, what is the moral requirement here, of them to, fine, you need to deliver water to a bunch of people to the south. You own the land, but does that give you the right to destroy the economy and the environment of somewhere else in the same state? When, you know, increasingly the way the state looks at it is you have the water rights, but you don't own the water. The water is really property of the, |
01:46:04
01:46:10 |
Mark frontal |
the people, the public. |
01:46:37 |
LA fountain Lower third: Mulhollan memorial fountain |
[fountain running] |
01:46:39 |
Dry OV nature |
[birds chirping] |
01:46:47 |
|
Beverly Newell: I can remember dad in my backyard, we're putting up a fence post and |
01:46:53 |
Beverly Frontal |
he dug a hole, and I swear, at a foot, he ran into water. Water was rising to the top. |
01:46:56 |
Dry OV |
It was so wet and the water table was so high. But, boy, not anymore. |
01:47:02 |
Nancy and Mary Frontal |
NancyMasters: Let's talk about the role of memory here and how that intersects with the culture of the city of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. So we're in our 60s and we, we remember some things still - Mary Roper: might not happen next year. We might not remember, but we do now. |
01:47:10 |
Aerial of Valley/Mountains |
Nancy Masters: and part of the ploy is to outlive the people that remember. |
01:47:34 |
|
Mary Roper: And one of the things that has been their modus operandi now is that they are trying to re characterize this valley as always, being a desert, a desert devoid of, you know, vegetation, of trees. And it wasn't, it was filled with life from the seeps and springs. And what made it such a desert is their pumping. |
01:47:42 |
|
[somber music] |
01:48:07 |
|
NancyMasters: So if it's not documented and documented in a way that's easy for the future to access, then it just relies on us being truth tellers. |
01:48:10 |
Vegetation in OV/Apple orchards |
[birds chirping] |
01:48:32 |
|
RoseMasters: Up here, has a pretty high water table. That's the reason we think that these trees are still alive. |
01:48:37 |
Rose frontal |
These particular orchards that we're standing in were planted in 1921. |
01:48:49 |
A: documents/photos from early orchards |
[soft footsteps] |
01:48:54 |
|
In 1905, there was a farming community that was based in apples and pears, “Manzana” Apple Orchard. |
01:48:58 |
Nancy walking through dry valley |
[footsteps] |
01:49:10 |
|
The trees that depended on, |
01:49:13 |
Nancy frontal |
ground water vegetation died. And of course, the answer by the city of Los Angeles is to |
01:49:14 |
A: dry trees |
eliminate the effects of their pumping, cutting down dead trees so that we don't have silent witnesses. |
01:49:22 |
flora/fauna in OV |
[birds chirping] |
01:49:32 |
flora/fauna in OV |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: Many, many years later, my mother told us that for the first two weeks, |
01:49:42 |
A: Sue interview |
she used to walk quite a number of blocks over to where the apple trees were, and she used to sit under the trees and cry. And then one day she decided, well, this is ridiculous. Why am I wasting my time sitting here crying when I could be doing things? |
01:49:46 |
apple trees |
[instrumental music] |
01:50:07 |
|
[birds chirping] |
01:50:12 |
A: photo of reservoir Lower third: Manzanar Reservoir 1942 A: kids playing in reservoir Lower third: Manzanar Reservoir, 1986 |
[children playing] Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: That reservoir up there is the world's greatest swimming hole, |
01:50:15 |
01:50:22 |
||
01:50:35 |
||
Kathy Frontal A: people dipping toes into reservoir: Lower third: Manzanar Reservoir, 1998 |
better than an Olympic sized pool, clean ice cold water. Mary Roper: I remember swimming in the reservoir, you know, you'd go and float around. |
01:50:40 |
01:50:49 |
||
Dry reservoir w/ text about water drying up
A: photos/ videos of water usage at Manzanar |
[water trickling] Monica Embrey: Not only was water a major factor in the siting of Manzanar in the Owens Valley, because where else could you put a work camp without water? |
01:50:50
01:51:12 |
Monica frontal A: video of water play at Manzanar |
Water was also the means of resistance. And so it was the same vehicle ...
that people behind barbed wire used, |
01:51:23 |
01:51:26 |
||
Aerial view of dried reservoir |
to tell their stories, whether they were etching it in the concrete of the water reservoir with their fingertips, |
01:51:29 |
etching in reservoir Lower third: Beat Great Briatin and America |
|
01:51:30 |
Aerial view of dried garden at Manzanar A: Young woman in garden |
or with the beautiful, amazing gardens. And so water became, for me, this metaphor, both of the oppression, but also the resistance to that. |
01:51:40 |
01:51:45 |
||
A: women's bathroom at Manzanar |
[shower running] |
01:51:52 |
Madelon frontal Lower Third left: Madelon Arai Yamamoto, Manzanar Incarceree |
Madelon Arai Yamamoto: Not once was I ever told “don't take too long a shower.” Once I turned
all of the ten spigots on because I thought, I’m in here by myself. I’m going to turn them all on. And I go running back and forth, back and forth. |
01:51:55 |
01:51:59 |
||
A: kids at Manzanar |
Sometimes I'd be in there half an hour, just playing under the water. |
01:52:09 |
A: Sue Interview |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: People just got together collectively and really tried to make things better for everybody else. |
01:52:15 |
Creeks and ponds at Manzanar |
So gradually people began to decorate with stones and ordered fish and built fish ponds. [pond water running] |
01:52:20 |
01:52:28 |
||
Madelon and family at Manzanar |
Madelon Arai Yamamoto: There was another Barrack there. |
01:52:33 |
A: Arai family photo
Madelon frontal
A: Arai family photos |
My father was going to build something in front of our barrack because they were digging a hole. And then finally I asked them, oh, why was he digging such a big hole? He said, well, because I'm going to build a fish pond. And I said, why a fish pond, it was just as dry as can be. But I think he just wanted something that reminded him of Japan and something that would entertain us. Many of the camp residents would come by to look at the pond and sit and just watch. It was just a very quiet, beautiful area. [instrumental music] |
01:52:37 |
01:52:40 |
||
01:52:55 |
||
01:53:07 01:53:19 |
||
Madelon looking at family album A: Merritt park footage |
[birds chirping] |
01:53:21 |
01:53:29 |
||
|
HenryNishi: Everybody liked to do gardening and started planting things. |
01:53:35 |
Henry frontal Lower third left: Henry Nishi, Manzanar Incarceree |
And that helped a lot. |
01:53:39 |
A: Merritt park footage Nishi Home Lower third: Henry Nishi Home, Santa Monica, CA |
[birds chirping]
[water running] |
01:53:45 |
01:53:53 |
||
Henry holding Nishi family photo A: Nishi family at nursery Lower third: Nishi Family Nursery, West Los Angeles, 1937 |
We moved in, in November and December and war broke out and had to move out. It had to be 1937 or 1938, when this picture was taken. |
01:54:00 |
01:54:11 |
||
A: Pleasure park footage Merrit park today Lower third: Merritt park |
They all knew my dad. He worked on that Merritt Park. |
01:54:23 |
01:54:27 |
||
A: photo of Merritt Park Lower Third: Merritt Park, 1945 A: Pleasure park footage |
He was a nurseryman. |
01:54:30 |
01:54:36 |
||
A: Kuichiro in park Lower Third: Kuichiro Nishi, Merritt Park Designer |
He was actually a rose grower, he grew roses... in the San Fernando Valley. |
01:54:39 |
Henry frontal |
And everybody, they were competing against each other because they wanted to get the most beautiful garden. And everybody, they had nothing better to do... than to pretty up the place. |
01:54:47 |
A: Pleasure park footage |
Especially when you're in a place like, imprisoned, as I’d say, because otherwise you’d go nuts. |
01:55:03 |
|
There was plenty of water. A lot of water from the mountains comes back down to the Owens River. That excess water that they’d use for irrigation, |
01:55:14 |
Henry frontal |
it went back into the Shepherds Creek down below. |
01:55:27 |
Creek |
[creek flowing] |
01:55:31 |
a: Photos of Block 22 team Lower third: Block 22 garden 1942 |
|
01:55:36 |
Block 22 garden Lower third: Block 22 garden |
[birds chirping] |
01:55:45 |
Rose walking through garden |
RoseMasters: This is Block 22 Garden, and it's one of my favorites because it's maybe the very first of the Japanese gardens here at Manzanar, that I saw when I started working here at age 17. |
01:55:48 |
01:55:57 |
||
Scenery of block 22 garden |
The history of Block 22 Garden, is really fascinating. It was built by Harry Ueno, and Harry Ueno was a man that you could say was the catalyst for what came to be called the Manzanar riot. |
01:56:14 |
Rose frontal |
And the Manzanar riot was one of the big reasons that the government forced everyone to sign a loyalty questionnaire. |
01:56:31 |
|
Part of that tour, the Rangers told us to just, you know, we're a bunch of kids told us to just sit down on a rock and close our eyes and just listen. |
01:56:44 |
Scenery |
[birds chirping] [people shouting] |
01:56:58 01:57:06 |
|
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: The group started to chant and sing, and M.P.s became worried that they were going to be rushed, and so a couple of them shot their rifles into the crowd. Two young men were shot and killed.
[shouting] |
01:57:09 01:57:24 |
|
[gunshots] |
01:57:27 |
|
So that night, all the kitchen workers went out and ran the kitchen gongs, and they rang them all night long. gongs running |
01:57:31 |
Rose at block 22 garden |
[kitchen gongs ringing] It was right here and it felt like it was a really strange thing to do on a ranger program, but also a really powerful thing to do. |
01:57:39
01:57:53 |
Animals around Manzanar |
[birds chirping] |
01:58:03 |
Madelon and family at Manzanar |
[bees buzzing] Madelon Arai Yamamoto: I know after a while some of the |
01:58:17
01:58:17 |
Madelon frontal |
younger men would leave camp to go trout fishing. |
01:58:20 |
A: Japanese-American man fishing |
This was a lot that went on. We just did it quietly, the sentries were out there, but my father always spoke to them and he would explain to them why we were going out of the camp |
01:58:30 |
01:58:37 |
||
A: Japanese-American man fishing |
Danelle Gutierrez: A lot of Indian people assisted the Japanese people in going fishing |
01:58:45 |
Danelle frontal Center left: Danelle Bacoch-Gutierrez, Big Pine Pauite Tribe
A: Indigenous/Japanese Americans |
because a lot of Indians worked in that area and probably developed friendships, you know. And if I know my people, they had good sense of humor. That's one thing we're always taught that continued us to be strong - no matter everything. The forced march. The treatment of the people that came into this valley - never lose your sense of laughter, of being who you are as a person. [child giggling] |
01:58:50 |
01:59:02 |
||
01:59:19 |
||
A: Japanese-American farming photos/paintings w/ text |
[instrumental music] |
01:59:21 |
|
HenryNishi: They would grow a whole lot of stuff. During the summer months, |
01:59:45 |
Henry frontal A: Painting of Japanese American field workers harvesting watermelon |
it was a short season, but it grows fast. Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: My father was loading watermelons on the train out here. He said he’d never seen so many watermelons in his life. |
01:59:49 |
01:59:53 |
A: guards at manzanar |
And he was hitchhiking home and a sheriff picked him up, and then he started asking him all these questions, and |
02:00:02 |
Kathy frontal A: Apache people unloading beds off a truck |
dad was like, that’s really weird. And it wasn't until he dropped him off that he goes, “he thought I was from the camp!” Because they didn’t know him. BruceEmbrey: These camps were on native lands. |
02:00:08 |
02:00:19 |
||
Bruce frontal |
And the Bureau of Indian Affairs sent some of the administrators over to run these camps. |
02:00:21 |
A: white and japanese americans at manzanar |
Beverly Newell: I think he was, Osage, or some, some someplace down in the Southwest, I'm not sure what his, his tribe was. He was a procurement officer. He was the only Indian that I knew that wore a suit and tie to work. I used to go up there with |
02:00:29 |
Beverly frontal A: lush gardens at Manznar |
Mr. Wilson to the, to Manzanar. |
02:00:45 |
02:00:48 |
||
Beverly frontal |
What I knew was desert before and after they had developed it, |
02:00:54 |
A: lush gardens at Manznar |
it was just gorgeous. It was just transferred from night to day because there's little little streams running through the beautiful flowers. It was, it was a garden spot. |
02:00:57 |
A: aerial view of manzanar A: Footage of Manzanar closing |
[airplane engine] [shakuhachi music] |
02:01:14 |
02:01:19 |
||
|
[child crying] |
02:01:39 |
A: destruction of Manzanar barracks |
RoseMasters: Regarding the landscape, the idea was that the federal government was to return Manzanar to Los Angeles Department of Water and Power as close to the condition it had been in when they got it as possible. |
02:01:48 |
Relics of Manzanar today A: garage Lower third: Inyo County Road Department Garage 1994 |
[wind blowing] This gigantic auditorium, which luckily remained here, it was leased by Inyo County as a garage. When I saw it as a kid, as most people who saw it, they had no idea that that was once the camp auditorium for Manzanar. |
02:01:55 |
02:02:26 |
||
A: dance in auditorium |
[Big Band music] |
02:02:44 |
Board: Reimagine Payahuunadü |
[truck driving by] |
02:02:50 |
A: map of OV area Commemorative run through OV |
[man singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
02:03:04 |
02:03:11 |
||
|
Danelle Gutierrez: We’re having a commemorative run right now, |
02:03:15 |
Danelle frontal Lower third: Danelle Bacoch- Gutierrez, Big Pine Pauite Tribe |
to honor the memory of our ancestors that were forced to march out of the |
02:03:16 |
Back of Danelle's t shirt Commemorative run through OV |
Payahuunadü, the Owens Valley. |
02:03:18 02:03:26 |
|
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: Last year, we said, let's just do a run from Fort Independence to Owens Lake. |
02:03:27 |
Kathy in car Kathy frontal |
Drink lots of water, you guys. What's really hard is we're dealt this hand and we're trying to live in it. |
02:03:51 02:03:54 |
Camp independence sign Lower third: Camp Independence |
|
02:03:59 |
Commemorative run through OV |
[crowd cheering] |
02:04:00 |
Kathy frontal |
And that more recent years, people are like, we don't have to sit here and take it. |
02:04:14 |
Paiute reservation |
The pipe broke a few years ago and nothing was done. |
02:04:23 |
|
Danelle Guiterrez: Our irrigation line got weeds in it and everything. |
02:04:27 |
Danelle frontal |
The pipe, a pipe, it was on DWP land. |
02:04:32 |
Kathy frontal |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: It got worse and then it finally broke completely |
02:04:39 |
Board: Big Pine Pauite reservation |
where the reservation got no irrigation water. |
02:04:39 |
A: protest outside DWP Lower third: Los Angeles |
|
02:04:46 |
A: protest outside DWP |
Protestor: We must all honor our lives and stand our ground. |
02:04:50 |
|
Protestor 2: One day we're going to see all this water around DWP, it's gonna be back in the Owens Valley one day you guys, just watch. |
02:04:54 |
A: DWP public meeting
A: DWP public meeting recording |
Danelle Gutierrez: We can't even get at the table to meet with DWP, to talk with their leaders. Shannon Romero: Our tribal citizens and allies have traveled eight hours to deliver this message regarding delivery of irrigation water per the nineteen thirty nine land exchange agreement.
I'm here on behalf of my people to inform you without water, our tribe is placed in a state of emergency. The lack of irrigation water puts a strain on our aging domestic water because citizens now have to utilize treated water for our agriculture and livestock. |
02:05:03
02:05:10 |
02:05:20 |
||
Teri side view Lower third: Teri Red Owl, Owens Valley Indian Water Commission |
HarryWilliams: In 1939, you did a land exchange with certain agreements - a contractual agreements. And today they are being broken. Do you need to be sued like your history tells us in Owens Valley? TeriRedOwl: You probably have heard from your staff that they've worked out a solution to fix this, broken pipeline that's located right here below the boundary of the reservation. However, that solution comes with strings attached, and those strings are asking the Big Pine tribe, the original inhabitants of the land where your water comes from before the settlers came, before Los Angeles came. You're asking them to sign away their future water rights. |
02:05:34
02:05:47 |
A: DWP public meeting recording Lower third: Paul Huette, Big Pine Pauite Tribe |
Paul Huette: I get phone calls daily: “are we going to get water this year? Are we getting water this year?” I don't want to blame anybody, but who's to blame? The pipes’ on your land. You should be, your’re, responsible for that. |
02:06:18 |
A: DWP public meeting recording |
Christina Noonan: President Levine, may I speak for a moment?
President Levine: Sure. |
02:06:30 02:06:32 |
A: DWP public meeting recording Lower third: Christina Noonan, Former DWP Board Commissioner |
Christina Noonan: I personally apologize for the frustration and hurt that your families have experienced. I take this to heart because I have been involved with your community and I'm disappointed by the fact that I feel that legalities have not led to executing a proper agreement. That being said, to respect all of you and to honor my fellow board members, I as a personal citizen, am willing to fix the pipe on my own expense, separate and apart from legalities. But I'm happy to underwrite that. So I will issue the check as soon as uhm, the invoice is sent to me. |
02:06:33 |
A: DWP public meeting |
[people cheering] Danelle Gutierrez: And I thank you, ladies, for offering that, but no. I want DWP to do the right thing. I don't want no side handlings or nothing. I want agreements and I want action. This water - our water - that is supposed to serve our people in our Owens Valley, Payahuunadü, that you guys call Owens Valley. It's there for everybody. Natives, non natives, everybody.
[tribal singing] |
02:07:11 |
02:07:21 |
||
02:07:46 |
|
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: Because they got shamed out in public by one of their own, they finally fixed it. If they're really trying to solve a problem and make things better, they should be listening to everybody involved, and thinking of all the ideas and options. |
02:07:51 |
A: Dancing after meeting |
[people singing in Paiute] |
02:08:08 |
A: water in LA/OV |
[creek babbling] |
02:08:22 |
|
[water rushing] |
02:08:28 |
A: water in LA/OV |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: The Manzanar committee believes that the resettlement period for Japanese Americans has never really ended. The violation of human rights guaranteed by the United States Constitution, the stripping of our human dignity and the destruction of our community. |
02:08:36 |
A: sue giving testimony |
Can we honestly say that it will not happen again? |
02:08:52 |
A: children at Centerville waiting for evacuation |
|
02:08:56 |
A: sue giving testimony |
[crowd clapping] |
02:08:59 |
Kids and Kathy hanging out |
[girls talking] |
02:09:04 |
|
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: That's the best part about sitting here and talking to people (Kid): about Paya. (Kathy) About paya, huh. Paya is the most important. (Kid): I don’t know what we would do without water. |
02:09:08 |
|
Kathy: We can’t. Can we live without air? No, we can't live without air. Without water, either. |
02:09:20 |
Mary and Nancy fixing a fence |
Mary Roper: I usually have all kinds of stuff like rope and everything in my car. |
02:09:36 |
|
NancyMasters: Wait, wait, wait. |
02:09:41 |
|
My hand caught. There we go. Between ‘em. |
02:09:45 |
Nancy frontal |
Everything we as individual human organisms do have an impact somewhere. |
02:09:51 |
Water use in LA |
Turning that tap on or running the sprinkler on the lawn, it's causing, potentially, a seep or a spring to dry up up here. |
02:09:58 |
Nancy frontal |
That's not to make people feel guilty. It's to make them feel appreciative and aware. Because if they appreciate the place that their water comes from, a change might be made. |
02:10:08 |
Monica in Park |
[fountain gushing] |
02:10:37 |
Monica Frontal |
Monica Embrey: What would it have meant if we had designed cities around water tables? |
02:10:39 |
Aerial view of LA/OV |
We don't do that here. We build mega cities in areas that can't sustain it and spend ridiculous amounts of money to pipe in the resources to sustain those communities. And with the catastrophe of global climate change, we aren't going to be able to continue to live this way much longer. |
02:10:48 |
|
[pensive music] |
02:11:11 |
Kathy frontal |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: L.A. can't just take and take from this valley. This valley can't keep giving and giving. It's going to run out of things to give. |
02:11:23 |
Kathy and others at the aqueduct |
Kathy: That’s the original, over there… (Kate Bunney) In my picture that's where I wanted us to be. (Kathy Jefferson Bancroft) Right. (Charlotte Lange) Up there. (Kate Bunney) Yeah. And like, “here it is. Take it back.” Something like that. That was… |
02:11:33 |
Guard closing gates to aqueduct |
|
02:11:45 |
Andy and Kathy sitting together |
AndyLipkis: That will generate 200000 acre feet, just from recycled water from the trees in town. |
02:11:50 |
Andy frontal Lower third left: Andy Lipkis, Founder of Treepeople |
The water that we've been getting from the Owens Valley |
02:11:57 |
Aqueduct/LA A: Old/new LA water fixtures |
is extraordinarily valuable, but solutions are within reach. [ducks quacking] |
02:12:01 |
02:12:08 |
||
|
We've all been holding the notion that we live in a desert and we don't have water, and so we have to bring it |
02:12:12 |
Map of LA w/ three rivers A: Old/new LA water fixtures |
from three rivers into Los Angeles: the Sacramento, the Owens, and the Colorado. We don't see and understand the rainfall. |
02:12:18 02:12:25 |
|
When it rains an inch here, we throw away capturable runoff that could be our supply. |
02:12:29 |
LADWP building exterior |
[rain falling] You asked the question about what's it going to take to change L.A. DWP? |
02:12:38 02:12:44 |
People entering DWP building DWP meeting |
To make change happen is, it's a two way street. Speaker: And let's not forget watershed health. |
02:12:51 02:12:56 |
|
When we showed that we were willing to save water, government went, oh, wow, if you're willing to do that, we'll help you. And that worked so powerfully, |
02:12:58 |
Andy frontal |
it reduced our water use and it's never come back up above what it was in the 70s. |
02:13:09 |
A: LA wastewater plants |
The other two things that are required is to clean up aquifer, fully recycle the water and wastewater treatment plants. |
02:13:16 |
A: Old/new LA |
L.A. City, as progressive as it is, you can't do it without the people saying we're ready to conserve. We need the big investment from government to help us. [instrumental music] |
02:13:26 02:13:37 |
|
[fountain gushing] |
02:13:42 |
Highway/scenery in OV |
[lively music] |
02:13:47 |
|
Larry Mantle(KPCC): Good afternoon. It's air talk. I'm Larry Mantle. Residents of the eastern Sierra Nevada have an angry history with the city of L.A.’s Department of Water and Power. Water and land have been the historic bones of contention, but the latest dispute is over a large solar facility planned across from the old Manzanar Relocation Center near Bishop. |
02:13:49 |
Kathy frontal |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: When they wanted to put the solar project across the valley, everybody was trying to fight it on their own terms. |
02:14:10 02:14:13 |
Kathy and Bruce talking |
And when we all got together with the Manzanar Committee, it just really showed a powerful story |
02:14:16 |
Mountains and valley aerial
Bruce and Monica at home |
that we need to protect not just Manzanar, but the view around it. Why make this place a national historic site if you just build up industrial around it? You're losing the importance of what it is and the message you're trying to educate people on. And that's how we feel. If you have a ceremonial place and you're sitting there and you look down on four square miles of solar panel, it's not the same thing.
[Bruce and Monica talking] |
01:14:22
02:14:44 02:15:00 |
|
BruceEmbrey: For us, opposing the solar ranch |
02:15:07 |
Bruce frontal |
- it was a no brainer. |
02:15:10 |
Industrial OV Bruce frontal Lower third left: Bruce Embrey, Manzanar Committee |
Transmission lines stretching down from the Owens Valley to lose a significant portion of the power that you're generating just through transmitting it all the way down
was nonsense. And it was just another attempt by the DWP to use the Owens Valley, to monopolize water and power in the Los Angeles area. We got pushback from all kinds of 'friends'. |
02:15:11
02:15:21 02:15:32 |
Bruce at protest Nancy frontal |
A woman walked up to me and she said, “I worked for DWP for 25 years. Don't fight the DWP. You won't win.” NancyMasters: We do have a fear about the city monetizing this land. |
02:15:36 |
02:15:44 |
||
OV scenery |
And you look around you, this is like a national park. It's in no one's interest to monetize that, water or no water. |
02:15:50 |
A: Maps of solar project
A: photos from protests Danelle frontal |
Danelle Gutierrez: We were told that, “oh, you won't even be able to see the solar panels because they’re going to be on the other side”. So we went up there by Manzanar and we looked down and you would see them clearly. there was many elders from Manzanar that were in their 90s, and then there was us tribal people forming an alliance, to have two groups battling against DWP, trying to protect two things that are sacred in both of our histories. |
02:16:02
02:16:16 |
02:16:30 |
||
A: photos from protests |
BruceEmbrey: The Owens Valley Committee and the Lone Pine tribe, all of them played a vital role, and without them, we would not have been able to stop this. |
02:16:36 |
A: article about solar plan |
This isn’t the first time that our little committee and the DWP have squared off. |
02:16:51 |
A: congress act Bruce frontal |
When Congress acts to establish the Manzanar National Historic Site and create the national park, initially, there was almost universal opposition. |
02:16:59 |
02:17:05 |
||
Nancy Frontal |
NancyMasters: Everyone was aware of the contention. |
02:17:11 |
A: Keith with NPS ranger |
KeithBright: They said, “why should we have something for the Japanese?” |
02:17:14 |
Manzanar NHS
A: Sue with Manzanar Committee |
NancyMasters: Our father was able to identify that this could be a fiscal benefit for the county.
BruceEmbrey: The main opponent, though, was the Department of Water and Power. They did not want anything up there that was permanent, much less the scale that it’s at.
My mother was the first chair of an advisory commission. I think her experiences enabled her to understand the need to build the broadest possible coalition or network of support. Through the art of negotiation, the people of the Owens Valley came to support the creation of Manzanar.
What moved people was a sense of camaraderie. |
02:17:18
02:17:24
02:17:37
02:17:58 |
A: Sue interview |
Sue Kunitomi Embrey: In trying to - to preserve Manzanar. I've sort of turned a negative experience into something a bit more positive, and you sort of make peace with the past and try to use it to educate other people and to try to learn a lesson. |
02:18:02 |
A: Sue at Manzanar/Manzanar pilgrimage 2019 |
I think we've reached a point in America where we have to look on ourselves as more of a diverse nation and that all of us bring strength to the country and that we try to understand each other better. |
02:18:24 |
A: dedication of plaque Lower third: Monument dedication, August 1943 |
[Shinto prayer] |
02:18:33 |
A: Manzanar 1940s/Manzanar pilgrimage 2019 |
Monica Embrey: Manzanar, for me, is a place where we think about what is this resource that we are dependent on every day. Because yes, water is life. |
02:18:47 |
Manzanar pilgirmage 2019 |
[flute music] |
02:19:01 |
|
[Muslim prayer] |
02:19:06 |
Indigenous community/manzanar pilgrimage |
Kathy Jefferson Bancroft: We walk with everybody, you know, they're still - even though they’ve passed on - they're still here to help us. They're still here to teach us. They're still here to guide us. And that's how I feel any time I'm anywhere in this valley and Manzanar is no different. |
02:19:14 |
Manzanar monument |
[Buddhist chanting] |
02:19:34 |
Acknowledgements of indigenous communities |
[woman singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
02:19:39 |
|
[water running] |
02:20:08 |
|
[children playing] |
02:20:14 |
Credits |
[cello music] |
02:20:19 |
|
[man singing in Nüümü/Paiute] |
02:29:39 |