Middle of Everywhere: The Abortion Debate from America's Heartland
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
If you are not affiliated with a college or university, and are interested in watching this film, please register as an individual and login to rent this film. Already registered? Login to rent this film. This film is also available on our home streaming platform, OVID.tv.
South Dakota is America’s heartland—waving cornfields, hard-working farmers, family values and a population of 750,000, the majority of whom identify as conservative and anti-abortion. Native daughter Rebecca Lee returns home in 2006 on the brink of a historic state vote: House Bill 1215 could make South Dakota the first state to outlaw most abortions since Roe vs. Wade passed almost 30 years earlier. In The Middle of Everywhere, Lee discovers the debate to be complex, with both sides claiming compassion for women and the same desire to stop the need for abortion.
When 1215 fails to pass, Lee sets out to uncover what would make a self-proclaimed pro-life state vote against the very measure that would end most legal abortions. South Dakotans appear conflicted in their beliefs: passing the Pharmacist Refusal Law, allowing pharmacists and doctors the right not to dispense birth control if doing so goes against their religious views, yet voting along pro-choice lines to keep abortion safe and legal. Was the vote a simple misunderstanding of what it means to be pro-choice? Was it a deeply-held resentment against government intrusion into people’s private lives? Whatever the final reason, The Middle of Everywhere reveals that the issue goes beyond the simple choices of being for or against abortion to the much deeper question of what values we hold dear as Americans and as humans beings.
“Essential to learn[ing] more about the multiple layers of the abortion debate in the US…this film challenges multiple stereotypes by revealing not that they are false, but rather that they are all too real and much more complicated than we typically acknowledge.”
Jeannie Ludlow, Ph.D. Asst. Professor, Women's Studies & English, Eastern Illinois University
“Captures the essence of middle America and its ambivalence on the controversy of abortion and abortion politics…Themes of freedom, independence, and fundamentalism around the issue of abortion are explored and exposed with an objective eye.”
Jane Olsen Women's Center Dir., St. Cloud State University
"Recommended...will be of particular interest to educational institutions and public libraries."
Educational Media Reviews Online
“***...An intriguing exploration of a perennial topic, this is recommended.”
Video Librarian
Citation
Main credits
Malmberg, Jesper (filmmaker)
Lee, Rebecca (filmmaker)
Lee, Rebecca (narrator)
Lee, Rebecca (editor of moving image work)
Faivre, Bertrand (film producer)
Other credits
Director of photography, Jesper Malmberg; editors, Françoise Tourmen, Rebecca Lee; original music, The Wood Knots.
Distributor subjects
No distributor subjects provided.Keywords
WEBVTT
X-TIMESTAMP-MAP=LOCAL:00:00:00.000,MPEGTS:0
00:36.639 --> 00:36.819
Pretty stranded by.
Good morning, good morning.
00:36.830 --> 00:36.930
How are you today?
Good, good, good.
00:36.939 --> 00:37.090
You know Tom Hendry's phone number, not right
off.
00:37.099 --> 00:38.099
OK, go ahead.
00:51.139 --> 00:53.240
Good, good, Hazel.
Anyway, if God what belongs to him first,
00:53.299 --> 00:56.459
it's his, and look, I didn't feel a threat with
me several years ago.
00:56.500 --> 01:00.180
I couldn't get 32, it was before and after meal
averages.
01:00.500 --> 01:02.009
God loves these little babies.
01:02.700 --> 01:03.869
And you know what else?
01:04.080 --> 01:07.720
He loves the women that have been in those
abortion clinics.
01:59.480 --> 02:02.970
South Dakota.
In the fall of 2006.
02:07.599 --> 02:08.990
A good year for the harvest.
02:11.179 --> 02:15.779
This was also the year when the government made
abortions illegal, and the people were called
02:15.779 --> 02:17.130
out to vote on the new law.
02:32.509 --> 02:33.559
I was born here.
02:35.059 --> 02:36.649
Smack in the middle of the US.
02:39.089 --> 02:42.039
Life on the Great Plains is all about the
simple things.
02:44.740 --> 02:46.009
Wide open highways.
02:48.289 --> 02:50.850
Big trucks that pass through but never stay.
02:57.800 --> 03:00.169
Endless fields filled with soy and corn.
03:05.679 --> 03:07.899
Swimming in the lake on a hot summer day.
03:09.399 --> 03:12.779
And lots and lots of little towns that all
pretty much look alike.
03:38.149 --> 03:42.380
Who was named Bus Driver of the Year in 2005.
04:12.029 --> 04:14.500
There is a movement across this country.
04:15.690 --> 04:19.200
One wishes to save and protect the lives of
unborn children.
04:20.479 --> 04:25.829
As you know, Justice Roberts and Justice Alito
were just favorably placed on that board.
04:26.158 --> 04:31.519
There is still another chance that President
Bush will have to place another justice on that
04:31.519 --> 04:36.278
committee on that bench.
I believe it's time to pass House Bill 1215 and
04:36.278 --> 04:37.748
protect the lives of the unborn.
04:40.559 --> 04:47.160
In 1973, the US Supreme Court took up Roe
versus Wade and made abortion legal in all
04:47.160 --> 04:48.260
50 states.
04:49.660 --> 04:54.920
Since then, the issue divided the nation,
creating huge movements like pro-life and
04:54.920 --> 05:01.570
pro-choice.
South Dakota's ban, House Bill 1215,
05:02.130 --> 05:06.519
was to be the first attempt by an individual
state to take back complete control over
05:06.519 --> 05:07.609
abortion rights.
05:08.880 --> 05:13.420
The November elections would show if the
citizens thought abortions should be illegal.
05:14.880 --> 05:18.700
The campaign was now at its peak, and two men
emerged as the architects of the ban.
05:21.839 --> 05:24.649
So I'm trying to just kind of paint the picture
of why South Dakota,
05:24.730 --> 05:26.959
why now, what's happening here on the ground.
05:30.739 --> 05:35.809
First of all, I saw a shirt this last week and
I saw a few shirts that said abortion,
05:36.040 --> 05:38.269
the leading cause of death in America.
05:38.720 --> 05:45.109
It's true, you know, and if we had any other
epidemic out there that was claiming
05:45.320 --> 05:49.269
1.3 million lives, we'd be doing our darnedest
to stop it,
05:50.160 --> 05:53.709
you know, and here we are just turning a blind
eye, pretending it doesn't happen,
05:53.880 --> 05:57.149
you know, 47 million deaths have occurred.
05:57.609 --> 06:02.019
We talk about a few thousand lives lost here or
there or wherever,
06:02.250 --> 06:07.480
you know, 3,000 roughly on 9/11, 2,500 roughly in
Iraq.
06:07.769 --> 06:08.769
We've killed.
06:09.890 --> 06:13.989
47 million people who could be contributing to
our economy in some way,
06:14.609 --> 06:19.600
you know, I, I mean, I hate to talk about them,
but they would have been people,
06:19.609 --> 06:25.200
they would have been out there going to school,
working, spending money,
06:25.450 --> 06:26.720
this and that and the other thing.
06:27.130 --> 06:31.640
Some of them would have been our best friends.
Some of them would have been our worst enemies,
06:31.730 --> 06:34.890
you know.
I think there are a lot of good that could come
06:34.890 --> 06:38.399
out of it because I see families that would
like children.
06:39.380 --> 06:41.609
Don't have children.
They're going to China.
06:41.660 --> 06:45.769
They're going to Russia, the Ukraine.
They're going to, uh, Colombia,
06:46.260 --> 06:49.809
South America to basically adopt children.
06:50.260 --> 06:54.929
When if we had children that were available for
adoption here in the United States,
06:55.250 --> 06:58.489
we have families who could have children, we
would have real families.
06:59.010 --> 07:05.450
Uh, secondly, uh, I have to chuckle a little
bit that in the European area where they, uh, uh
07:05.459 --> 07:06.619
support abortion.
07:07.170 --> 07:12.079
Um, they're now having to allow a greater rate
of immigration.
07:12.839 --> 07:17.989
People coming into their countries to be able
to have people to do jobs they don't want to do
07:18.309 --> 07:23.149
and to earn money so they can collect taxes on
it to support the pension plans for the older
07:23.149 --> 07:24.950
people because they don't have enough people.
07:26.079 --> 07:30.410
Uh, there's an economic factor, an economic
plus if you would,
07:30.720 --> 07:36.920
to ensuring that we continue, uh, to allow
unborn children to live in essence.
07:37.119 --> 07:40.859
When you're talking in terms of protection of
life.
07:42.260 --> 07:46.410
To my way of thinking, that's what pro-life is
all about.
07:47.019 --> 07:53.820
Pro-choice people are not really protecting
life, they're protecting choice.
07:54.529 --> 08:01.200
And in the United States, the protection of
life has been one of our greatest values.
08:02.279 --> 08:07.679
We've gone to war in Bosnia, Somalia to protect
life and to protect people.
08:08.890 --> 08:15.279
When someone takes the life of another, they
are subject to the highest criminal penalty.
08:15.410 --> 08:16.649
They're subject to death.
08:17.640 --> 08:21.260
You know, if someone is raped, they're not
subject to death.
08:21.630 --> 08:24.670
If someone basically robs, they're not subject
to death.
08:25.570 --> 08:31.029
So our nation historically, not only in its
great documents like the Declaration of
08:31.029 --> 08:35.109
Independence where we talk about the pursuit of
life and the protection of life in our
08:35.109 --> 08:39.739
Constitution.
But we have continually, year after year, in the
08:39.739 --> 08:45.780
United States since its inception, since its
creation, have said that life is one of,
08:45.820 --> 08:47.950
if not the highest value.
09:03.539 --> 09:07.330
I wanted to know how engaged ordinary South
Dakotans were in this ban.
09:08.559 --> 09:12.590
So I started hanging around with some farmers
who were friends of my family.
09:27.390 --> 09:28.390
That about for
09:35.440 --> 09:42.320
Oh, OK.
Chiefs
09:42.320 --> 09:44.059
checking in on me to make sure I'm working.
09:47.169 --> 09:51.239
You know, I guess I don't like abortion myself,
but I'm Catholic,
09:51.359 --> 09:54.809
so then.
Catholics are totally against it supposedly you
09:54.809 --> 09:56.520
know Catholic religion is.
09:59.690 --> 10:04.330
So then it was 2 years ago at the, in the last
election, and now I suppose coming up here in
10:04.330 --> 10:07.809
the next couple weeks at church, they talked
about this,
10:07.830 --> 10:11.750
you know, telling you to vote for this and vote
for that just because of the abortion,
10:11.789 --> 10:14.510
man.
Well, I don't agree with that, you know.
10:15.380 --> 10:18.289
That's really not why I go to churches for
politics, you know,
10:18.559 --> 10:23.270
so anyway, I quit going to church two years ago
until the damn election was over.
10:24.200 --> 10:25.869
I didn't want to listen to that kind of stuff.
10:58.539 --> 11:00.809
Grassroots campaigns had now begun.
11:01.690 --> 11:04.719
Trying to mobilize voters to go to the polls in
November.
11:11.640 --> 11:13.599
Why do you think you have made in America?
11:14.570 --> 11:18.489
I think it's kind of a scary thing to say, but
I think a lot of it has to do with our
11:18.489 --> 11:23.239
political spectrum and that, uh, the religious
right has become a very powerful force,
11:23.809 --> 11:29.679
and Republicans know that they can, uh, they can
co-opt all that religious energy.
11:29.929 --> 11:35.409
They can go ahead and do that because they can
spin really well and they can make it all just
11:35.409 --> 11:40.400
mushed back into this one issue that they're
pro-life and so if you're pro life,
11:40.880 --> 11:43.200
if you love God you gotta vote for these people.
11:43.669 --> 11:49.979
I see what happened, or what has happened in
South Dakota; it's going to be really dangerous.
11:49.979 --> 11:53.020
For the public health.
Do we want people back with wire hangers?
11:53.140 --> 11:59.820
Do we want you back-alley, scary, you know,
predatory people doing fake
11:59.820 --> 12:01.049
surgeries, basically.
12:17.380 --> 12:22.359
This is Planned Parenthood's clinic in Sioux
Falls, the only clinic in South Dakota which
12:22.359 --> 12:26.169
performs abortions.
On average, 800 per year.
12:27.530 --> 12:32.169
With a population of just 750,000, that's among
the lowest in the nation.
12:37.369 --> 12:44.140
We built this building, or had it built for us,
so it was designed specifically for our use.
12:44.140 --> 12:45.390
As an abortion provider.
12:46.739 --> 12:52.299
We wanted to keep our patients away from the
public-access street where our
12:52.299 --> 12:53.609
protesters can be.
12:55.159 --> 13:01.719
Once you enter in here, you get into the
vestibule, and our staff actually have to press
13:01.719 --> 13:04.750
a button to allow you to enter into our waiting
room.
13:05.640 --> 13:07.109
So, and then it's all.
13:07.940 --> 13:09.280
It's all bulletproof.
13:10.109 --> 13:14.969
Around the building, and then we have cameras
out here so that we can always see our
13:14.969 --> 13:17.320
protester activity out on the street as well.
13:18.419 --> 13:19.690
We call it a bunker.
13:19.940 --> 13:22.419
We work sort of in a bunker environment and.
13:25.669 --> 13:31.570
I would never encourage somebody to, to have an
abortion, but I understand that there are times
13:31.570 --> 13:37.159
in which that is, um, a decision that a woman
might make,
13:37.530 --> 13:40.559
and then when that occurs, it needs to be safe
and legal.
13:41.989 --> 13:45.359
South Dakota has been sort of preparing for
this for a long time.
13:45.500 --> 13:51.200
Um, the anti-choice community has been very
strong in South Dakota.
13:51.640 --> 13:56.359
Um, we have leaders such as Leslie Unre.
We have a leader in the legislature,
13:56.489 --> 13:58.250
uh, such as Roger Hunt.
13:59.090 --> 14:04.250
Who are willing to push this agenda on the
legislature, on our governor,
14:04.409 --> 14:10.409
on the people of South Dakota over and over
again, and the legislative body has tended to
14:10.409 --> 14:14.479
be much more conservative on this issue than
the people as a whole.
14:15.820 --> 14:19.570
We've been talking about that a lot because
part of the things that we look around and see.
14:19.979 --> 14:24.840
We're pro-life, but pro-life really is such a
strong strange choice.
14:24.880 --> 14:28.640
They basically, how can you say no to life when
they have these stickers that say vote yes for
14:28.640 --> 14:32.890
life?
Everybody's pro-life, of course, of course it's
14:32.890 --> 14:39.599
a really strange use of language, and what I've
found is that there are all kinds of people in
14:39.599 --> 14:42.760
South Dakota who describe themselves as being
pro-life.
14:43.429 --> 14:48.219
But they are, in fact, pro-choice and they don't
even know it, and I can't
14:48.260 --> 14:52.489
I've never been able to figure out what they
think pro-choice really means.
14:52.859 --> 14:57.059
It just means that you would be able to,
obviously, make that decision without the
14:57.059 --> 15:03.260
government interfering in that very personal,
private, intimate decision about continuing a
15:03.260 --> 15:04.299
pregnancy or not.
15:05.520 --> 15:10.609
And for many people who self-describe
themselves as pro-life,
15:11.140 --> 15:16.219
they agree that the government should not be
involved in that decision-making process, so, to
15:16.219 --> 15:22.650
me they're pro-choice, but in their mind they
somehow think that they're
15:23.460 --> 15:26.250
pro-life. Well, so I decided that I must be pro-
life too.
15:31.030 --> 15:33.969
2 miles down the road and a full month later.
15:34.539 --> 15:39.940
I finally got 15 minutes with Kate's opposite,
the director of a crisis pregnancy center and
15:39.940 --> 15:42.099
chairwoman of the Vote Yes for Life campaign.
15:45.000 --> 15:48.599
Do you think that there are social reasons that
people are choosing not to have their babies?
15:48.659 --> 15:51.059
Like, why do you think women choose to have
abortions in the first place?
15:51.099 --> 15:52.510
It's not because they're bad people.
15:55.320 --> 15:56.830
So why, why, why do they choose it in the first
place?
15:56.919 --> 15:59.260
Why do they feel like it's a necessary choice
in their life?
15:59.469 --> 16:04.440
64% of all women have been hurt by abortions.
16:04.690 --> 16:11.119
Um, 65% have been coerced by women who, you know,
what, we're OK here.
16:11.409 --> 16:13.130
We're OK.
Yeah, we're fine.
16:14.330 --> 16:17.409
All right, thank you.
OK, yeah, do you want to put a note on the door
16:17.409 --> 16:19.210
maybe and tell them we're, yeah.
16:20.469 --> 16:22.229
Yeah, we're good.
Just let her know.
16:22.309 --> 16:24.890
Yeah, we're fine.
OK, we're good.
16:26.320 --> 16:29.650
Yeah, sure, well, we had a little emergency
here a few minutes ago,
16:29.799 --> 16:34.869
so yeah, men, there are a lot of men angry,
very angry,
16:35.479 --> 16:39.770
yeah, they're coming out here and one man came
and he took the sign and he smashed on his
16:39.770 --> 16:40.869
knees and he said.
16:41.690 --> 16:45.000
If you think you're going to ruin all of us and
ruin men,
16:45.250 --> 16:46.760
you've got another thing coming.
16:47.010 --> 16:52.640
I think having abortion on demand in this
country is giving a license to men to use women.
16:52.929 --> 16:59.880
It's giving women shame that's put on them by
society, because when you have an abortion,
17:00.210 --> 17:02.219
you hide, you live in shame.
17:02.530 --> 17:05.359
It's just so interesting when I talk to you or
when I talked to Kate Libby.
17:05.609 --> 17:10.458
Both of you seem like such completely
compassionate humans that I'm, I just can't
17:10.458 --> 17:15.899
Understand how we can't — you can sound
compassionate, but let's show compassion.
17:16.708 --> 17:19.308
Let's look at what does Katie Lobbe have at the end of
the day,
17:19.389 --> 17:21.249
what does she have?
Money in the till.
17:21.788 --> 17:23.619
What does Leslie and her have at the end of the
day?
17:25.180 --> 17:29.520
For 22 years, every bit of the service that we
have done has been free to the women.
17:29.969 --> 17:31.119
We've been there for them.
17:31.569 --> 17:35.199
Those women, many of them are working within
the walls of this campaign office.
17:35.810 --> 17:37.199
Many of them had their babies.
17:37.449 --> 17:38.800
Many of them have had abortions.
17:39.560 --> 17:42.790
But guess who was there for them at midnight, 3
in the morning.
17:43.000 --> 17:44.310
Other women like myself.
17:52.260 --> 17:55.569
In the last days before the vote, more and more
people were joining the fight.
18:02.130 --> 18:05.500
In 1973, and it's still better today.
18:05.910 --> 18:07.270
We cannot permit what he did.
18:08.709 --> 18:13.189
You and I have a duty to love our neighbor as
ourselves and to speak up for those who are
18:13.189 --> 18:15.420
unjustly being led away to the slaughter.
18:15.839 --> 18:16.839
We have a duty.
18:49.510 --> 18:55.020
Two car accidents later, this caravan of people
from a church in Wisconsin was asked to leave
18:55.020 --> 18:56.020
by the police.
18:56.589 --> 19:00.349
One of them had a 10-year-old daughter who'd
come home from school with a very graphic
19:00.349 --> 19:01.780
anti-abortion leaflet.
19:02.229 --> 19:06.270
We've got a job to do.
We've got a job to protect these people at a
19:06.270 --> 19:08.739
high school, elementary school.
19:09.390 --> 19:10.890
They are not eligible to vote.
19:11.510 --> 19:16.310
Only after asking us to turn off the camera did
the police admit to the protesters that they
19:16.310 --> 19:17.420
agreed with their message.
19:18.310 --> 19:20.859
Just not with the methods used to get it across.
19:24.790 --> 19:30.560
Thou shalt. These people were all very friendly
and helpful to each other,
19:30.770 --> 19:32.599
to us, and to the police.
19:34.040 --> 19:36.160
But they'd gotten a lot of the facts wrong.
19:39.979 --> 19:46.900
It infuriates me that pro-lifers managed to
skew the argument in this way that makes
19:46.900 --> 19:51.339
everyone who is pro-choice, pro-abortion, and
pro-death.
19:52.140 --> 19:54.500
Like that's not right. Yeah.
19:55.439 --> 19:59.069
I'm this close to starting to call
myself pro-life.
19:59.489 --> 20:03.280
I really am.
As a pro-choice advocate, I feel like I am more
20:03.280 --> 20:07.130
pro-life than any pro-lifer I've met.
You're not the first person to say that.
20:07.880 --> 20:11.709
This is what a baby looks like after it's been
in the hands of an abortion doctor,
20:11.719 --> 20:14.109
folks, not a pretty picture.
20:14.599 --> 20:16.310
We don't enjoy showing it to you.
20:17.260 --> 20:24.170
That's what it is.
Now we can go back to Roe
20:24.170 --> 20:27.689
versus Wade.
Roe versus Wade, the Supreme Court said they
20:27.689 --> 20:31.520
really didn't know when life began, but 33
years later,
20:31.650 --> 20:37.530
we do.
Thirty-three years later, terms like genes and DNA are in
20:37.530 --> 20:38.790
our vocabulary.
20:39.209 --> 20:43.280
They weren't in our vocabulary in 1973.
20:43.689 --> 20:45.130
In Roe versus Wade.
20:45.520 --> 20:50.520
The Supreme Court said nothing about
post-abortion problems that women would
20:50.520 --> 20:51.619
experience.
Why?
20:51.890 --> 20:57.770
Because post-abortion problems really weren't
known because abortions weren't legalized as
20:57.770 --> 21:00.410
they are now.
We're all doctors here in South Dakota.
21:00.599 --> 21:03.089
Science now proves that life begins at
conception.
21:03.250 --> 21:06.890
Over 96% of abortions performed in South Dakota
are for birth control.
21:07.010 --> 21:11.930
Referred Law 6 addresses these situations.
This measure does provide an exception for the
21:11.930 --> 21:15.584
life and the health of the mother.
And the morning-after pill may be taken in any
21:15.584 --> 21:20.474
event, including sexual assault or incest.
Referred Law 6 is a caring approach to protecting
21:20.474 --> 21:23.834
women and limiting abortion performers' birth
control in South Dakota.
21:24.025 --> 21:25.025
Now, what's going to happen, uh
21:31.834 --> 21:33.275
if 12:15.
21:33.660 --> 21:37.839
Uh, is approved, in essence, by the United States
Supreme Court.
21:38.130 --> 21:42.359
Well, in South Dakota, abortions are going to
be banned except to save the life of the mother
21:42.609 --> 21:45.479
or a limited exception for purposes of rape and
incest.
21:45.969 --> 21:51.900
Did you, have you read the ballot pamphlet
where they say that there is an exception with
21:51.900 --> 21:53.079
the pros and cons?
21:53.849 --> 21:55.640
How is that possible?
21:55.890 --> 21:59.500
How can— well, there clearly is no exception.
22:00.349 --> 22:02.589
But don't you think that will confuse a lot of
people? Of course,
22:02.989 --> 22:03.989
that's their intent.
22:04.339 --> 22:05.439
Why are they allowed to?
22:06.209 --> 22:08.510
I don't understand—to confuse the public.
22:10.569 --> 22:15.650
Um, because they can.
I mean, they can, they can make that argument
22:15.650 --> 22:22.489
that there is an exception in the ban for rape
and incest because there is the existence of
22:22.489 --> 22:28.939
contraception.
And somehow they equate those two
22:28.939 --> 22:35.880
things, and hopefully the public is wise enough
uh to distinguish
22:35.880 --> 22:39.500
between those two.
There is no exception for rape and incest.
22:39.619 --> 22:41.459
Do you think they will be wise enough?
22:42.130 --> 22:47.680
Um, I think that we need to continue, uh,
through this entire election process to
22:47.680 --> 22:52.469
reinforce that message that there are no
exceptions in this for rape and incest or for
22:52.469 --> 22:56.819
the health of the woman, and that allowing for
the use of birth control,
22:56.949 --> 23:02.390
which is all that the ban does is it
allows for the use of emergency contraception,
23:02.709 --> 23:07.180
which is birth control, um, that is not the
same as an exception.
23:08.420 --> 23:13.180
And I didn't know that I needed special
permission from the government to use birth
23:13.180 --> 23:17.719
control.
Well, you will soon, yeah, um, I read that
23:17.969 --> 23:23.770
South Dakota physicians or um pharmacists as
well have the right to not dispense the birth
23:23.770 --> 23:25.810
control if it conflicts with their religious
view.
23:26.010 --> 23:30.239
Yes, that's true.
We were the first state in the country to pass
23:30.239 --> 23:34.449
a pharmacist refusal law in the 1990s.
23:35.130 --> 23:41.910
And um it allows pharmacists to refuse to
dispense any form of birth control if
23:41.910 --> 23:47.150
they feel it goes against their morals and um
so you know,
23:47.599 --> 23:54.180
while you may.
Legally under the ban, have the right to
23:54.180 --> 23:57.689
use emergency contraception or other forms of
birth control.
23:58.260 --> 24:03.209
Um, in South Dakota, we have given pharmacists
the ability to say no,
24:03.579 --> 24:08.410
I, I don't think that you should have birth
control, and they would be able to limit access,
24:08.859 --> 24:12.410
particularly in a very rural environment such
as South Dakota.
25:16.079 --> 25:17.609
One Sunday isn't bad.
25:18.890 --> 25:21.229
But it was like 4 Sundays in a row.
25:22.449 --> 25:25.319
You know, every Sunday it's the same shit.
25:27.459 --> 25:30.589
And we all know what the church's position is.
25:32.729 --> 25:36.150
And I don't think they got a right to tell us
how to vote,
25:36.439 --> 25:38.729
you know.
I don't know.
25:40.520 --> 25:42.609
I got crazy ideas sometimes.
25:47.329 --> 25:49.680
Like the abortion thing, I mean, I don't agree
with it,
25:50.500 --> 25:53.489
but I think there might be some sometimes certain reasons when they.
25:54.729 --> 25:56.560
Well they should be allowed to do it, you know.
25:59.910 --> 26:01.670
Like if, like if the mother is.
26:02.400 --> 26:05.339
If it, if it's gonna hurt the mother's health,
you know,
26:05.630 --> 26:09.150
she has a chance of dying or something, well
then they should be able to.
26:10.910 --> 26:12.790
Or if she's raped or something maybe.
26:14.010 --> 26:18.510
You know, she, I don't think she should have to
look at that face all her whole life.
26:23.290 --> 26:24.290
I don't know.
26:39.109 --> 26:44.910
Do you think that people in this state feel
like this is a moral gap that needs to be
26:44.910 --> 26:46.140
filled by a law?
26:46.550 --> 26:51.410
Oh, they've said that in polls, even the
Planned Parenthood people,
26:51.430 --> 26:54.140
if you pushed them to be honest about it, would
tell you that,
26:54.310 --> 26:58.219
I mean, they know two-thirds of the people in the
state don't approve of abortion.
26:58.589 --> 27:03.890
Um,
although, and I think that there's historically
27:03.890 --> 27:06.770
been strong support for laws in our state,
courts keep striking them down.
27:06.849 --> 27:09.689
We keep passing them, they keep striking them
down, um.
27:11.089 --> 27:15.609
But if you wanted to know, I mean, and I,
I mean the longer,
27:15.900 --> 27:19.380
longer-term answer will not, as is true for
every social problem,
27:19.459 --> 27:22.250
will not be a legal answer.
The law can be an impetus,
27:22.780 --> 27:24.650
but in the end, you got to change people's
hearts.
28:31.140 --> 28:37.910
Woo.
That's a tough question.
28:38.400 --> 28:42.069
It's, uh, it might be a question I can't answer.
28:42.959 --> 28:44.609
I don't know the right answer to it.
28:50.209 --> 28:56.979
Again, if you've been raped or drugged, then
it's a different story.
28:56.989 --> 29:01.819
Why?
Because it's not choice.
29:02.109 --> 29:03.500
If you have free sex,
29:04.030 --> 29:07.770
You have casual sex, then you've already made
the choice.
29:08.420 --> 29:11.729
It sucks it's murder.
29:12.219 --> 29:15.810
When you go out in the wild, a deer has sex
with a buck.
29:16.040 --> 29:21.709
There's no, you can't, you can't like have an
abortion on a wild creature that was in the
29:21.709 --> 29:24.055
wild.
Why should humans be able to do it.
29:24.185 --> 29:27.755
There's gonna be a need and there's gonna be a
place for that kid.
29:28.064 --> 29:30.854
You were born.
Your mother did not abort you.
29:31.104 --> 29:33.614
If your mother would have, it would have been
committing murder.
29:33.704 --> 29:36.734
I'm sorry.
I think that I, that's how I think it is.
29:36.984 --> 29:40.734
It's fucking murder.
That's how I was raised and that's how my heart
29:40.734 --> 29:41.734
is.
29:57.189 --> 30:00.390
Let's rejoin Kelly Grant, who is standing by
with Leslie Unruh.
30:00.670 --> 30:07.150
I know they want, they want the vote to go their
way, but are they accepting the reality now
30:07.150 --> 30:09.989
that perhaps they're not going to succeed?
30:10.349 --> 30:14.829
I hope I heard you right, but they are not
accepting reality if that's what you ask.
30:15.189 --> 30:20.500
Leslie, tell me, the AP is saying that Vote No
is the winner.
30:20.579 --> 30:23.189
What do you have to say about that?
They're never going to win.
30:23.339 --> 30:26.109
We are never going to quit, ever, ever, ever.
30:26.380 --> 30:27.670
We're not going to give up.
30:27.900 --> 30:30.099
We are in this.
We're not conceding.
30:30.219 --> 30:31.520
I'm never conceding.
30:33.609 --> 30:36.829
None of these people are.
They have got to fight like they have never
30:36.829 --> 30:42.989
seen, because we have an army of people here, and
not just here but all over this nation we have
30:42.989 --> 30:46.790
hope in this nation.
There are people in West Virginia here; they are
30:46.790 --> 30:49.140
gonna put the same bill in their legislature.
30:49.670 --> 30:50.819
Planned Parenthood.
30:51.160 --> 30:54.849
There are people
in Texas here and they're gonna put this same
30:54.849 --> 31:00.770
bill in their legislature, and there are men
like Roger Hunt and Matt McCulley that have
31:00.770 --> 31:04.199
championed women, and there's a new day coming.
31:04.449 --> 31:09.750
Women are being heard all over this nation, and
it started here in South Dakota.
31:28.000 --> 31:30.760
After all that noise, abortions were still
legal.
31:33.060 --> 31:36.770
For me, that meant some rethinking about the
talking I had done so far,
31:37.180 --> 31:41.489
but for most people, that just meant getting
back to their normal realities.
31:49.300 --> 31:50.650
Can you see if anyone's coming?
31:52.880 --> 31:53.880
It's clear.
32:00.010 --> 32:01.359
Is it gonna get cool now?
32:02.500 --> 32:04.300
What?
Is it gonna get colder now?
32:05.130 --> 32:08.199
You're asking me?
Yeah, but you're a farmer.
32:08.209 --> 32:09.430
I don't know anything about these things.
32:09.719 --> 32:11.930
Oh yeah, I'm a farmer, not a man.
32:14.160 --> 32:17.599
Say that again.
So I'm a farmer, not a weatherman.
32:22.979 --> 32:25.380
Although I could do just about as good a job as
they did.
32:26.380 --> 32:29.739
Yesterday, it was supposed to be 80 degrees and
sunny and windy.
32:30.670 --> 32:32.000
Well, it was pretty calm.
32:32.859 --> 32:38.420
It was cloudy all damn day except until about 4
o'clock, and I had my jacket on all day,
32:38.500 --> 32:40.010
so it wasn't only 80 degrees.
32:42.140 --> 32:43.599
But he still has a job today.
32:50.599 --> 32:53.739
I wish I could do my job that wrong and still
have a job the next day.
33:00.000 --> 33:05.030
OK.
Right, I mean, you smell it all the time.
33:07.359 --> 33:08.670
I wish we had a damn gun.
33:13.219 --> 33:18.430
What? Don't you like the fact that I wish
we had a gun?
34:21.039 --> 34:25.958
How do you see this issue on the national stage
as contributing to the national kind of culture
34:25.958 --> 34:28.968
right now.
9/11 happened.
34:29.319 --> 34:35.868
The terrorists struck America, and all of a
sudden, men and women alike started to say,
34:35.918 --> 34:41.678
you know what,
some of that other stuff, it's
34:41.809 --> 34:44.519
it, it doesn't matter quite as much anymore.
34:45.229 --> 34:52.009
Let's start a family, you know, let's, let's,
um, God only knows how many days we
34:52.009 --> 34:55.799
have left, you know, before we destruct
ourselves, you know,
34:55.888 --> 35:01.789
whatever, um, and that was, that was a huge
turning point in,
35:01.938 --> 35:04.438
in America.
I don't know as we go forward.
35:04.509 --> 35:07.039
I don't know 10 years from now what the.
35:08.860 --> 35:12.409
What the net effect of the terrorist attacks
will be.
35:12.780 --> 35:14.209
I know for a short time.
35:14.989 --> 35:20.090
That it impacted people in a huge way, um, in
terms of what they,
35:20.229 --> 35:21.439
what they held near and dear.
35:21.770 --> 35:23.239
Um, I think you saw.
35:24.310 --> 35:29.139
A little more of the Midwest values spread
throughout the country.
35:29.719 --> 35:35.189
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United
States of America.
35:37.050 --> 35:42.590
Like oh.
35:45.250 --> 35:46.550
Thank you guys so much.
35:49.260 --> 35:53.929
This is Lifelight, a free Christian music
festival here in the Great Plains.
35:54.860 --> 35:58.570
It drew over 300,000 people this year, mainly
families.
36:02.570 --> 36:06.899
Uh, this one's from my church.
Uh, this one's for pro-life.
36:07.909 --> 36:10.699
And then this one's, um, breast cancer awareness.
36:11.389 --> 36:12.590
This one is um.
36:13.590 --> 36:20.520
Chastity, and so is this one, the ones that you
wanted
36:20.520 --> 36:24.080
or did you want to get all of them? I want to
get all of them because I like to wear them.
36:24.239 --> 36:30.939
I haven't taken them off for a while, so yeah,
the longest I've taken them off this summer was
36:30.939 --> 36:32.669
like two hours.
36:33.699 --> 36:34.659
Yeah, I'm attached to that.
37:04.270 --> 37:07.449
Um, let me see them both quick.
37:07.699 --> 37:08.850
Look at that one.
37:11.770 --> 37:18.520
And we encourage guys to wear this until they
get married and then save it for their
37:18.520 --> 37:25.320
son.
Our other guy's shirt that's awesome is our
37:25.320 --> 37:27.169
pornography one is for posers.
37:27.719 --> 37:33.629
Now, older guys don't know what a poser is, but
all the teenagers know what a poser is,
37:34.080 --> 37:35.629
and the back of the shirt.
37:35.850 --> 37:37.120
Now, did you read the back of the shirt?
37:37.479 --> 37:40.159
I don't remember what I said exactly. It.
37:43.379 --> 37:47.290
You know, last week I took an unbelieving kid
to a Christian camp with me.
37:47.820 --> 37:49.510
He was 12 years old.
37:50.100 --> 37:53.409
You know, within a day the girls were coming
telling me,
37:53.860 --> 37:55.830
you know, he's trying to sleep with one of us.
37:56.459 --> 37:59.689
He was 12 years old.
That's all he wants to talk about is how,
38:00.659 --> 38:04.689
well, I can't really say it, but that's all he
wanted to talk about.
38:05.500 --> 38:10.649
And before long, before he even knows it, you
know, some girl will be pregnant.
38:11.830 --> 38:16.469
You know, at 14 and having an abortion, which
is going to destroy her in about a dozen
38:16.469 --> 38:22.110
different ways emotionally and physically to
say nothing about killing the baby and she'll
38:22.110 --> 38:28.419
have the, the, you know, the human
papillomavirus and end up with cervical cancer.
38:28.429 --> 38:31.790
I mean, they're huge sex problems.
38:33.399 --> 38:35.310
It all gets into huge problems.
38:36.040 --> 38:37.179
Well, go ahead and bow with me.
38:39.179 --> 38:44.709
You are so good.
Father, I, there's a president who's got a lot
38:44.709 --> 38:45.800
of weight on his shoulders.
38:46.860 --> 38:51.639
Yes, because in the midst of that.
38:53.020 --> 38:59.929
Somehow in the darkness of war and fog of war
there, near one of the entrances
38:59.929 --> 39:04.570
to the festival was the fleet for Little Feet
bus run by Leslie Unruh.
39:05.649 --> 39:08.560
It roves the countryside, giving advice to
pregnant women.
39:12.949 --> 39:19.780
Good. Let's talk about birth control now
because I know
39:19.780 --> 39:23.409
like Planned Parenthood says that they think
that this type of law,
39:23.500 --> 39:27.389
it's naive to think that women won't still seek
birth control and abortions in the morning
39:27.389 --> 39:30.459
after pill.
I mean, what way do you guys look at that?
39:30.540 --> 39:35.050
I really don't know anything about the point of
view here and I can see how quite an operation
39:35.399 --> 39:39.280
based on this, and I really want to know what
is your stance about birth control because for
39:39.280 --> 39:44.179
example, Denmark in the 90s made birth control
free and accessible for everybody and their
39:44.179 --> 39:45.860
abortion rate dropped by 50%.
39:46.469 --> 39:48.669
Do you think that that's actually—I was in
Denmark.
39:48.830 --> 39:54.790
I spent almost 4 weeks there and we found that
the sewage department there was having a
39:54.790 --> 40:01.110
problem because when they were aborting the
children, um, and also in Sweden they were having
40:01.110 --> 40:07.429
problems because of the high abortions that
were there, so, um, it's not really true that
40:07.429 --> 40:10.820
women were and still are becoming pregnant in
Denmark.
40:12.000 --> 40:17.030
The view on sexuality is typically diverse,
with Scandinavia on the more liberal side.
40:18.000 --> 40:20.629
The abortion stats are half that of the US.
40:21.560 --> 40:25.320
I have never heard about this, and I don't know
why it should take place.
40:25.399 --> 40:29.949
You have public hospitals all over the country
where you can get an abortion for free,
40:31.159 --> 40:36.790
so, so I'm pretty sure that nobody wants to do
an abortion at home.
40:37.520 --> 40:40.929
I can't see any logical or health reasons to
do this.
40:42.120 --> 40:43.669
So that is not the case.
I can tell.
40:44.270 --> 40:48.909
The funny thing is that when we talk about
reducing the number of abortions,
40:49.389 --> 40:55.350
we actually get strong support from the
Christian party in parliament who said even we
40:55.350 --> 40:59.739
don't like abortion, we know that we should
support information,
40:59.830 --> 41:04.260
we should support sexuality education and good
access to contraceptive means.
41:04.750 --> 41:08.219
That is the way you reduce the number of
abortions in reality.
41:09.770 --> 41:12.030
And, and that is what is taking place in
Denmark.
41:12.110 --> 41:18.669
We have more than half the number of abortions
since abortion became legal because
41:19.360 --> 41:21.399
On the one hand, it is legal.
On the other hand,
41:21.600 --> 41:25.189
we have good education and sexuality
information.
41:28.550 --> 41:32.979
To encourage right choices, we must be willing
to confront the dangers young people face,
41:33.389 --> 41:35.389
even when they're difficult to talk about.
41:37.040 --> 41:43.959
Each year about 3 million teenagers contract
sexually transmitted diseases that can harm
41:43.959 --> 41:48.030
them or kill them or prevent them from ever
becoming parents.
41:50.120 --> 41:54.500
In my budget, I propose a grassroots campaign
to help inform families about these medical
41:54.500 --> 41:58.290
risks.
We will double federal funding for abstinence
41:58.290 --> 42:01.739
programs so schools can teach this fact of life.
42:02.110 --> 42:07.429
Abstinence for young people is the only certain
way to avoid sexually transmitted diseases.
42:24.560 --> 42:28.040
There are all these huge organizations that
lobby very hard.
42:28.120 --> 42:30.830
They have plenty of political clout.
They've got good grassroots,
42:31.080 --> 42:36.550
um, and, and they fight for poor access to
birth control,
42:36.760 --> 42:39.280
poor access to good sex education.
42:40.139 --> 42:45.379
Now between sex education and birth control, I
can't think of two better ways other than
42:45.379 --> 42:51.620
abstinence to not have an unwanted pregnancy,
and the best way to reduce abortion is to
42:51.620 --> 42:53.209
reduce unwanted pregnancies.
42:53.459 --> 42:59.699
I mean, this is really easy logical stuff,
but religious-based organizations
42:59.699 --> 43:00.739
sometimes skip a lot of that.
43:04.010 --> 43:08.639
Right now there's millions of dollars being
spent on programs of prevention,
43:08.850 --> 43:11.290
teaching women that it's not about finding the
right man,
43:11.330 --> 43:15.919
it's about being the right woman, sexual
responsibility, sexual integrity,
43:16.050 --> 43:17.479
that's what it's about for women.
43:18.770 --> 43:24.530
Last Friday night, young girls from all around
South Dakota came to Sioux Falls for a spring
43:24.530 --> 43:28.179
ball.
This one is called the Purity Ball.
43:28.409 --> 43:32.250
It's a yearly event run by Leslie Unruh's
Abstinence Clearinghouse.
43:32.899 --> 43:38.560
The idea is that these young women come with
their fathers to celebrate their sexual purity,
43:38.790 --> 43:41.320
that they won't have sex until the day they get
married.
43:43.570 --> 43:47.149
I believe in pure gifts.
43:59.189 --> 44:05.669
that he loves me, that he loves me, and that he
will reward me for my faithfulness, and that he
44:05.669 --> 44:11.790
will reward me for my faithfulness.
Do you believe that young women in schools in
44:11.790 --> 44:15.310
South Dakota should be taught about
contraception?
44:16.080 --> 44:21.949
I don't think that kids have to be taught about
how to load a gun if they're not going to use a
44:21.949 --> 44:25.350
gun.
I think that kids need to be taught and
44:25.350 --> 44:28.780
explained about how not to be involved in
sexual activity.
44:29.070 --> 44:31.229
Contraceptive devices fail.
44:32.080 --> 44:34.649
And I think that that's what they need to know
about.
44:36.010 --> 44:39.100
I've had a program for 22 years; it's called
Truth for Youth.
44:39.169 --> 44:43.239
In fact, the state of South Dakota hasn't every
single school in the state.
44:44.449 --> 44:49.610
And you know, it's the word abstinence, A-B-S-T
I-N-E-N-C-E,
44:49.620 --> 44:53.479
Abstinence means four easy words.
Here they are,
44:53.889 --> 44:56.840
save sex till marriage.
44:57.330 --> 45:02.699
Save sex till marriage, or no sex till marriage.
45:03.139 --> 45:08.600
Any kind of sex; we're not just talking about
regular sex or going all the way,
45:08.729 --> 45:13.679
we're talking about oral sex, anal sex, vaginal
sex, any kind of sex.
45:14.889 --> 45:16.719
That's what we're saying: no sex till marriage.
45:17.989 --> 45:20.550
I need nine volunteers to come up to the front
here.
45:26.969 --> 45:28.989
It's hard to get rid of me.
I'm with you.
45:30.010 --> 45:32.159
What do you think? Crabs have no cure?
45:34.060 --> 45:37.100
There is a way to get rid of crabs.
It's a parasite.
45:37.179 --> 45:38.649
It's a living creature.
45:39.139 --> 45:40.929
It's like you have lice in your hair.
45:41.459 --> 45:43.850
It's kind of like having lice in your private
parts.
45:44.060 --> 45:46.620
So how do we get rid of unwanted pregnancy in
general here?
45:46.860 --> 45:50.540
We have personal responsibility, and if that
fails, um,
45:50.860 --> 45:53.580
if it fails, personal responsibility never
fails.
45:54.679 --> 45:57.350
Really? No.
Why not?
45:58.830 --> 46:02.689
Because when you are personally
responsible, you make decisions based on
46:02.689 --> 46:06.540
responsibility and making good decisions, and
you understand and you know.
46:06.750 --> 46:10.219
See, I don't believe that we're animals in
heat; we're people,
46:10.350 --> 46:13.870
we can make decisions.
We don't have to go with the urges.
46:14.229 --> 46:17.149
We're people that have a mind.
The most important sex organ we have is right
46:17.149 --> 46:18.149
up here.
46:39.409 --> 46:41.270
Oh. Oh.
46:46.189 --> 46:50.810
Sexuality is such a basic element of our
humanness.
46:51.550 --> 46:57.239
What other area are we so afraid of in,
in our
46:58.189 --> 47:04.989
I just, what other area would we say we're not
gonna teach you about? Eating or breathing,
47:06.070 --> 47:09.530
you know, we teach nutrition, we teach exercise,
we teach
47:09.550 --> 47:12.810
you know, all kinds of other things, but we
can't talk about sexuality.
47:13.669 --> 47:15.060
I'm very afraid of that.
47:22.570 --> 47:23.409
I refute this.
47:36.409 --> 47:38.790
Hey, I wish one of those so bad.
47:47.709 --> 47:49.739
That's pretty amazing though.
That was sweet.
47:49.909 --> 47:52.909
That was awesome.
I love goosebumps.
47:57.300 --> 48:01.250
There we go.
I wish they were both two drakes,
48:01.320 --> 48:03.919
but what can you do when the sun's in your eyes?
48:12.560 --> 48:18.949
In Europe, we see more and more anti-church
people coming up with
48:18.949 --> 48:22.689
very radical views on, on.
48:23.409 --> 48:29.350
On these issues, and certainly we see the
consequences of the policy of the US government
48:29.350 --> 48:34.949
policy in, in, in the developing countries these
days. It is becoming
48:35.989 --> 48:41.070
increasingly more difficult to get access to
good sexuality education,
48:41.520 --> 48:46.110
uh, and, and very often sexuality education is
uh,
48:47.159 --> 48:51.550
abstinence until marriage, and, and, and we see
the consequences.
48:51.629 --> 48:56.350
I mean, it doesn't work in the US, and it doesn't
work in the rest of the world. Like, you do not
48:56.350 --> 48:58.080
have sex until you get married.
48:59.340 --> 49:03.040
That is the consequences our partners in, in
Africa, for example,
49:03.189 --> 49:09.270
are fighting that all these huge money
going into abstinence-only programs are
49:09.270 --> 49:15.909
actually reducing the way of having a good
sexuality education and
49:15.919 --> 49:21.280
and access to, to control your own fertility and
to protect yourself and your partner.
49:31.820 --> 49:32.939
Yeah, don't trip and fall.
49:35.840 --> 49:37.479
I might have to laugh a bit if you didn't.
49:49.139 --> 49:50.139
I know it's.
50:04.820 --> 50:06.449
As far as the way I voted, and all that.
50:06.939 --> 50:09.260
I didn't really even pay attention to that, to
be honest with you.
50:09.340 --> 50:10.929
Because I thought there were more important things.
50:12.219 --> 50:17.709
You know, and then the abortion done.
And then the abortion done.
50:56.000 --> 50:59.070
I think one of the things that the peripheral
issues do,
50:59.320 --> 51:04.899
the morality issues, is they distract people
from the true issues of the day.
51:05.419 --> 51:09.379
You know, take abortion, for example.
Abortion is a significant issue.
51:09.459 --> 51:12.379
We're 50th in the nation in the rate of
abortion per capita.
51:12.540 --> 51:15.370
We're an extremely conservative state.
51:15.820 --> 51:18.449
Everybody in South Dakota is truly pro-life.
51:18.699 --> 51:23.050
We, we look at that and so, uh, that's a
distraction to us.
51:23.419 --> 51:27.010
Uh, this law was not really needed.
It's really a,
51:27.139 --> 51:30.979
a complex social issue, not a simple black and
white issue.
51:36.639 --> 51:38.169
There he is.
Thank you.
51:38.179 --> 51:39.070
You bet.
Catch you later.
51:39.199 --> 51:40.840
Have a good one.
Thank you.
52:34.469 --> 52:36.100
Here we are.
52:42.280 --> 52:43.280
And
52:50.260 --> 52:52.010
We raise our drinks.
53:03.050 --> 53:09.429
Ha, and, like,
53:09.429 --> 53:10.919
this I can't.
53:13.639 --> 53:18.479
I did.
Trip again, again.